Comparing The Right Choice In John Steinbeck's Of Mice And Men

Superior Essays
How would you know if it was the right choice to end the suffering of someone you care about? Could someone be so bad off that death would be the best choice? At the end of John Steinbeck’s novel, Of Mice and Men, George Milton has to decide the right choice for Lennie Small. Lennie is George’s best friend that is a mentally-challenged full grown man. No matter how hard George tries, he can’t ever seem to keep Lennie out of trouble. After Lennie ends up killing a woman at the ranch that they are working on, George has to decide whether the right choice would be to put Lennie out of his misery so that Curley doesn’t get a hold of him. George makes the right decision in killing Lennie because Lennie would’ve continued to do bad things no matter …show more content…
Lennie acted as if he was an animal. He used his instincts instead of thinking things through. “His huge companion dropped his blankets and flung himself down and drank from the surface of the green pool; drank with long gulps, snorting into the water like a horse” (Steinbeck 3). Lennie did not stop to think about the possibility that the water he was drinking could be contaminated. He dove into the water without thinking. Lennie not only acts like an animal, but he also has the strength of one. Lennie killed a puppy and said that it was the puppy’s fault for dying because it was too little. Lennie liked to pet mice because he liked the way their fur felt, but he always ended up killing them. Lennie crushed Curley’s hand because he did not know when he was supposed to let go or how hard he was really squeezing. Lennie also killed Curley’s wife because of his strength. He did not do it out of meanness. He latched onto her hair because she was being loud and it scared him. He didn’t mean to break her neck, but not knowing his own strength and being frightened lead up to it. George was right to kill Lennie. Lennie could hurt anyone or anything with the strength he had and that makes him very dangerous to anyone he comes in contact

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    1) Lennie by accidentally kills one of the puppies and he tries to hide it under a pile of hay. It seems as if he is more worried that George wont let him tend the rabbits, than he is upset with the fact that the puppy is dead. 2) Curley's wife enters the barn and tells Lennie not to feel bad about killing the puppy because there are plenty of dogs in the world. She also tells him that she could of been a movie star, but things didn't end up well for her.…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George did the right thing at the end of the book because Lennie was a threat to everyone around him and if George did not kill him sooner, he would have killed more people later on. With Lennie’s strength and size, he overpowered anybody that he faced and because of the mental state that he was in, he could not control his power remarkably well and that led to many tragic outcomes. For example, “And then she was still, for Lennie had broken her neck,” (91). Since Lennie cannot control his power, it causes him to do things that he never intended of doing. What was only supposed to be the stroking of Curley’s wife’s hair, lead to her death only a few moments later.…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    They both are caretakers of someone they love and both are also very protective people. In the same way, their responsibilities to their companion affects them both socially because since they always have to take care of someone, they lack freedom for themselves. In contrast, Gilbert is more calm and passive aggressive to problems as opposed to George. George shows that he is very aggressive when it comes to problems with him and Lennie. In summary, George and Gilbert are both very similar but different in their own unique…

    • 90 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After Lennie killed Curley's wife, the other guys had their mind set on killing Lennie for what he had done, but George decided he should do it himself so it wouldn't hurt him as bad as knowing that he let other people do barely know Lennie, do it. Even though George knew he was better off without Lennie in his life he's even told Lennie “I could be living so good without you getting me in trouble and outta a job” (Steinbeck). Honestly George knows he’d be better off in his life without Lennie,but he doesn't want to leave Lennie because he knows he would be alone and put in place for the mentally impaired people. Although, George wants to keep one job and possible get a wife and have some children, but he can't do that because of Lennie and his way of not being able to keep a job.…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    George made the right decision by shooting Lennie Because. George did not want Lennie to suffer for what curly had in store for him so think of Lennie death as a mercy kill fast and less suffering also if George wouldn't have shot Lennie he could get tortured in many different ways. But most people say that George and Lennie should have run away instead of killing Lennie. My first reason that George should have taken Lennie life is that first of all. If Lennie had tried to escape with George both of the men would be considered wanted so it would be hard to have any type of job or place to live because their reputation would be murderers, But George thought that running away would be a bad idea so he did not want Lennie to deal with all this so he took his life.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George did the right thing by killing Lennie because, locking Lennie up wouldn’t have been better, he put Lennie in a better place, and Curley would have killed Lennie violently. Other people claim that George should not have killed Lennie because they were friends and killing Lennie would make their friendship pointless. If George wouldn’t have killed Lennie he wouldn’t get to stay at the Ranch he would have had to leave since he was tied to Lennie. Also, if George wouldn’t have killed Lennie, they could have gone off somewhere and started over trying to achieve their goal of the…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lennie Small Is Childish

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One not belonging to Lennie himself or the narrator but from his companion, George Milton. In the last section of, Of Mice and Men, we are taken through a gut wrenching chain of events in which, caused by nothing other than an unsafe environment for Lennie due to his mistakes, George must kill him. There should not even have to be an argument after the previous two examples as to why there is no possible way that Lennie’s own killing could ever be his fault. Yes, it was because of how badly he had messed up that the man he saw as his best friend wanted to get him out. Yet it was not Lennie’s choice nor did he know what was going on or have the mental capacity to realize it sooner.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George should have killed Lennie because he would have been put in an institution, Curley would have been cruel to him, and to keep others safe. One of the reasons why George should have killed Lennie is because he would have been put in an institution. From the beginning, it is easy to tell that Lennie is crazy, or at least mentally handicap.…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some readers think that George made a bold and harsh decision to kill Lennie himself and get rid of him for good. However, George made that decision because he wanted protect Lennie from the other men. “But Candy said excitedly, ‘we oughtta let ‘im get away. You know that Curley.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Best Friends Until the End Imagine having to kill your best friend. In Of Mice and Men, George made a hard decision which was if he should kill his best friend, Lennie. George killing Lennie was justified because had to think about Lennie’s life ahead if he didn 't make this choice. George making this choice was right because Lennie had unknowingly brought a threat among people, Lennie had died much quicker and painless, and Lennie was basically George’s responsibility.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    " It hurts to let go, but sometimes it hurts more to hold on". In John Steinbeck's novel, Of Mice and Men, George and Lennie are placed in life-threatening situations because of Lennie's atrocious choices. Although there were occasions where George was able to take action and save Lennie from severe punishment, there was simply so much he could do. When the time came and George realized there was nothing he could do to save Lennie, he concluded that it was only right to put Lennie out of his misery by putting a gun to the back of his skull and pulling the trigger. Although George committed a crime by executing Lennie, he had a positive motive behind his choice and made the correct decision, had George decided not to execute Lennie he would've…

    • 1558 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lennie doing this did not fit into the societal norm seeing as though Lennie thinks as a child and acts like a child is not helping him because he 's a grown man. Lennie crushing the mice foreshadows the frailty of his dreams and the inevitable way they, will be crushed. Lennie 's dreams will be crushed because he is incapable of self regulation. When Lennie drank from the dirty lake that is an example of him not showing self regulation because he can 't control himself when he does that kind of stuff while the other people in society can regulate themselves from doing such thing. Lennie does now learn from his mistakes because he doesn 't know better.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Do you ever feel helpless, like you do not have choice? Instead the choice was already made for you and you cannot do anything about it? In some situations you encounter a time where you do not have a choice, which can be in a positive or negative way. The choices you make now can affect the choices you make in the future. In the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, two characters Lennie and George, get a job on the ranch in Salinas Valley.…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sometimes in life difficult decisions have to be made in very short amounts of time. Making split second decisions usually end up going one of two ways, right or wrong. In Steinbeck 's Of Mice and Men George had to make many hard and fast decisions because of his partner Lennie. In Of Mice and Men George had to kill Lennie in order to keep everyone on the ranch safe even though it meant sacrificing his greatest friendship.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    George is justified in killing Lennie because it’s for Lennie’s own good, he spared him a harsh death, and he prevented him from spending his life in jail, or running from the law. George is justified in killing Lennie, considering Lennie would have suffered a harsher death if George didn't’ kill him. Lennie accidentally killed Curley’s wife by breaking her neck while stroking her hair. When Curley learns of his wife’s death, he immediately suspects Lennie is the killer and is determined to brutally kill him.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays