Comparing The Peasants War And The German Reformation

Improved Essays
The Peasants’ War was a time of violence and rebellion; there is no question about that. But who can be seen as responsible for instilling the use of force as a solution for the injustice by the Church and lords? Arguably the two largest leaders in the Peasants’ War and the German Reformation were Martin Luther and Thomas Müntzer. Although they both wanted to fix injustices, they used very different forms of rhetoric to do so. Martin Luther’s writings condemned violence and asked rebels to trust in God rather than force. On the other hand, Müntzer’s writings encouraged the peasants to take up arms and invoke violence. By looking at Martin Luther’s writings in A Sincere Admonition to Guard against Rebellion and Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants, it can be seen very clearly that Luther had …show more content…
It had gotten so bad that Luther wrote a pamphlet titled Against the Murdering and Robbing Hordes of Peasants in which he went a step further than condemning the peasants’ actions, but told lords and princes to stop the insurrection. This time can be seen as a turning point of the Peasants’ War because Luther would rather call for defense against those he originally sought to lose power than condone the actions of those who were using violence to accomplish his goals. At this point, Luther disassociated himself from those who he originally was a leader for. Luther did not consider the peasants followers of himself anymore because the peasants were not contending for the Gospel, but instead had become ruthless, disobedient, and savage murderers (133). Luther even went as far to say, “I think there is not a devil left in hell; they have all gone into the peasants” (132). Especially later in the Peasants’ War, Luther had not only lost all respect for the peasants’ cause, but showed great hate for constantly using unlawful

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    The things that the peasants did Luther didn’t want to happen at all, is because the church won’t change drives him to use other ways to against the church, which lead detection and chaos to Europe during the reformation. According to Luther he says “The Pope did and he made himself lord over the Church, proclaiming [the Church] at the same time a powerful mother, and empress over the Scriptures. This could not be tolerated.” (Luther’s Table Talk, 1535) All he wanted was to change the rules to Church. For the first evidence here, all the time Luther just want to change the Church from his own words, he didn’t want to bring chaos and distortion to Europe, from the quote he just angry about the Pope have all the things power and money. But he inspired the peasant revolt, which it is a fact he will never be able to change forever.…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He continuously wrote to both sides about the wrong that they were doing. He on one end was telling the nobility to not fight the peasants and he was telling the peasants that God would not be pleased at their violence against the lords and clergy. Though Martin Luther 's agenda was more of a religious revolution in the church what he incited was a political and social revolution among the parishes and townspeople that live there. Martin Luther wrote “Admonition to Peace: A Reply to the Twelve Articles” in response to the articles that the peasant shave written. He goes on to tell both sides what is wrong and how they should go about things.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is difficult to imagine the Barbarians and Christians had much in common when they rivaled each other so adamantly during the Medieval period, but resentment toward one another surely stimulated fierce conflicts that paralleled their violent tendencies. Those within the Carolingian Empire required biblical justifications for any controversial matter concerning Charlemagne’s desire to pursue the universal expansion of Christianity. Pagans proved to be exceptionally defiant toward converting to Christianity, which led the Franks to believe they rightfully needed to enforce a religious transformation across Europe by any means possible. The Saxons Wars and Vikings raids in Paris stressed the need for Franks to define violence as God’s tool…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Trajan Martyrdom

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The confusion of the pagans towards the pacifistic approach to “war” used by the Christians against the Roman religion implies that Rome was unaccustomed to this kind of rebellion. Romans had been taught to live and die for their emperor and the empire The puzzling behaviour of the Christians to accept their gruesome and humiliating deaths did not deter pagans from converting to Christianity as these martyrs acted as a means to opposing the erroneous aspects of Christianity that previously deterred…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfortunately, when the difference of opinions spread throughout the peasants, the German Peasants’ War broke out. However, the mere fact that a war did pursue speaks volumes as to how much people cared about this movement and their religion. The people who were previously unheard in the church were suddenly able to take a stand and have their voices heard. In the end, this is the biggest reason I believe the reformation had such a large impact. It gave the peasants a voice despite the fact that Luther was not always in agreement with those who dared to rise up against the Roman Catholic Church.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    However, Luther strongly opposed the peasant’s revolts. Luther remained allegiant to the noble citizenry of Germany and spoke against the violence of the rebels. In his pamphlet, Against the Murderous, Thieving Hordes of Peasants, he outlined his thoughts on the war. After visiting Thüringen and seeing the reality of the war, Luther preached against violence. In his book, Luther admonished the peasants for violating oaths of loyalty, committing crimes against their faith, and using Christ’s name to justify their actions.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As shown in Document D, they found Luther comparable with the devil, as in the painting he is depicted having clawed feet and a tail, trying to tempt Christ. This painting is Catholic propaganda that could be seen as being used by the church to try and prevent the temptation of Catholics to Martin Luther 's view, or by those who were strongly against the reformation that Luther unintentionally became a leader of. As Martin Luther became more popular, peasants at the time began to see him as someone who can help them push through the political and societal issues they were having at the time. Luther never wanted this though, as all he was trying to do was reform the corruption of the church, not lead a revolt against it, or defy it. This didn 't stop the peasants, who continued to see him as the leader of their revolt and independence from Wittenberg, due to his views on Christian freedoms and criticism of monastic landowners.…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John Huss’s actions brought about his excommunication, which aimed to keep him away from the church and stop him from spreading his faulty opinions more people. Huss was accused of heresy while he was still alive and was imprisoned for his actions and teachings that were against the church. Huss’s death at the stake benefited the church because it rid them of the man who opposed them and inspired others to oppose the papacy. Huss’s supporters started a revolt which was not expected by the church and eventually won religious reform and control but still the church remained as the power. From Huss’s death not many more supporters could have increased to damage the church compared to if Huss was kept alive and secretly sharing his work.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Also by not making the current sacrifice to be with God eternally. The peasants wanted to start this rebellion against the lords because they wanted to have the same access to the natural resources such as the trees, the meadows and the animals. But Martin Luther was right to say that true Christians experience hardships in this world to have a better life later. Martin Luther believes that the peasants were led by false leaders to start this rebellion even though this was not their place to do so. Martin Luther believes that God has the power to settle all disputes and not to take the actions into your own hands.…

    • 1161 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther, a German Philosopher during the Protestant Reformation said, “People must have righteous principles in the first, and then they will not fail to perform virtuous actions”. The cause of the Protestant Reformation was the widespread corruption of the Catholic Church. The Protestant Reformation impacted European Countries because it challenged authority of the Pope during the 15th century and put an end to religious unity. There were key religious figures during this time that provided legitimate proof as to why these corrupt Catholic teachings were wrong. During the 16th century between 1517-1548 was a time of religious and political upheaval that divided European Countries and their religious beliefs.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays