Comparing Tale Of Tulisa And The Princess And The Frog

Improved Essays
A common misconception among young girls and society is that the happily ever after ending in movies is true, when in fact these stories provide a false perception of a relationship narrative. The love story of that in The Tale of Tulisa has been repeated throughout history by different cultures to portray a similar yet unique message to women of different time and cultures. The plotline of this folktale provides the basis for those as the Iron Heinrich folktale in Germany, accompanied with the movie The Princess and the Frog of Disney’s “American” culture. These three works all depict a similar story, moreover different cultures have taken an original myth and have adapted it to better suit the specific region. The recreation of this narrative …show more content…
These two stories provide the idea that the place one is born into in society does not have to be the societal rank in which they remain for life. The myths both begin with young women of low societal standing, in the Indian myth Tulisa is the daughter of “a poor man named Nur-Singh, who supported himself and his wife and daughter Tulisa by wood-cutting.” The beginning of the myth starts off in the lowest societal caste one could partake in of society, Nur-Singh who is Tulisa’s father promises his daughter for marriage in exchange of “great wealth.” In the end of The Tale of Tulisa, she achieves climbing the hierarchy of society to becoming queen of the society who had looked down upon her. This is the original depiction of a woman being able to climb the societal ladder, while The Princess in the Frog follows a similar plot line there are many differences. The main character is Tiana, who is the daughter of a cook and a maid, this story takes place in New Orleans and the main characters are African American. This tale is the first of a Disney princess who is of African descent and works in a diner, “I’m gonna work a double shift tonight.” In this story unlike in The Tale of Tulisa the daughter works for money and still remains in low societal standing, she kisses a frog who believed she was …show more content…
The pieces of work discussed in this piece all share a common 745 format, which the prime example is Cupid and Psyche, which shows that overcoming adversity to find love is worth the battle. The 745 formatting is common in most Disney films and often used in romance stories in which obstacles must be overcome to achieve happiness. The Tale of Tulisa depicts this since Tulisa is, “undeterred by these dangers, boldly entered upon her journey, and reached the river swarming with snakes.” Tulisa must overcome the dangers in her world in order to be reunited with her husband and to earn back the honor of her family, this is essential in creating the proper power to instill in women. In Iron Heinrich the princess must overcome her personal bias against the frog that she will end up marrying, “it is a disgusting frog.” The portrayal that this gives young girls is to overcome fears, biases, stereotypes, as well as giving individuals opportunities to show the positive aspects. The Indian story and the German rendition of this story depict women who overcome adversity in different ways, it is important for young girls to see that struggle appears in all forms not just one uniform way. The Princess and the Frog had the power to display a woman as the strong character of a Disney movie, going against prior notions

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Disney Brand Desire

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the article “Through the Window at Disney: A Lifetime of Brand Desire,” Susan Bennett and Marlis Schweitzer critically analyse a feature of Disneyland: the “Bibbidy Bobbidy Boutique.” Bennet and Schweitzer offer detailed descriptions of the boutique while critically responding to the services it provides, such as the Princess makeover. The article gives evidence to suggest that the Princess makeover uses child consumer/models to embody the “Disney fantasy” in a crafty method of “brandscaping” (28, 25). Using this article as a reference, I will critically analyze scenes from Disney animated films such as The Princess and the Frog as well as some relevant Disney products and experiences. I will pay particular attention to the messages being…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Philip Cohen’s article “The Trouble With Disney’s Teeny, Tiny Princesses”, he focuses on Disney’s depiction of men and women. He examines the differences in size and the magnification of the size between the genders and the effects it has on the younger generation of kids. Through the clear use of purpose, organization, and logic, Cohen clearly states his position that Disney should stop creating movies with misrepresentation between men and women. Philip Cohen’s main…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Women are some of earth’s most unique and underrated creatures. They are not weak, they are not emotional, and they are not the negative stereotypes that the world describes them as. “Trifles,” “Story of an Hour,” and “My Wicked Wicked Ways,” presents us with three women who are strong, mentally and emotionally. These three women: Mrs. Wright, Mrs. Mallard, and the speaker’s mother stories all relate in a way. The three ladies all relate in the way of being emotionally and physically tied to someone they either loved or not, who does not make them happy.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fairytales’, being around for several generations, have evolved through time and caught the attention of many folklorists, and demands an explanation of how feminism plays an essential role in today 's culture. Folklorist and author, James Poniewozik wrote, “The Princess Paradox” to raise an attempt to explain the “girls-kick-ass culture” (323). Peggy Orenstein published, “Cinderella and the Princess Culture” to examine and identify the belief of feminism within fairytales. Even though two different authors studied and evaluated the same topic, being feminism in fairytales, their approaches and conclusions on the topic tend to differentiate slightly, but also come to an agreeance in other areas.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The original version provide a narrower outlook on the story and can easily set up unrealistic expectations for young girls. This change alters the theme from good conquering evil to a story between a mother and daughter. As part of Maitland’s new theme, she promotes a feminist message within her version of the fairytale. This allows her to establish a moral with a larger meaning. Because of this version, more people can come to the realization that there is a far greater “happily ever after” for the princess who doesn’t wait around for the prince to come sweet her off her feet, but instead who is strong enough to provide herself with her own happy…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Said to be one of Disney’s best films, Beauty and the Beast is based on a French fairy tale about a beautiful woman who falls in love with a beast. This film sends the message that “it’s what is inside that really matters”. Jeanne Marie- Leprince de Beaumont wrote the timeless tale of “The Beauty and the beast” which has been embraced by the hearts of many for decades.…

    • 1761 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost all girls have either seen or have heard the “Cinderella” story before. Being a princess has been most girl 's dreams as a child, but little do they think about the theme and the message the “Cinderella” story creates. Elisabeth Panttaja, professor from Tufts University and author of the article “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior,” explains a theme that people may find unsettling because she claims that Cinderella and the prince may not have been in love. She hints at the fact that Cinderella’s mother may have been the culprit in scheming and seducing the prince into marrying her.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A classic princess story, Cinderella remains to be one of Disney’s most popular movies. However, what is disturbing is the manner in which this movie imposes gender roles by depicting women in a negative manner. This film seems to be reinforcing the notion that women are weaklings and that the only way in which any society can survive is by upholding male dominance and embracing female submissiveness. The movie begins by showing Cinderella living happily with her parents in a faraway kingdom.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social background and culture no doubt are the major factors affecting story elements. This paper will compare how social background and culture affect the way of expression in Western and Chinese children’s fantasy literature when two stories having the same elements, by comparing Cinderella and Ye Xian(葉限). Ye Xian is a Chinese fairy tale written by Duan Chengshi(段成式) in Tang dynasty compilation Miscellaneous Morsels from Youyang(酉陽雜俎). It is one of the oldest known variants of Cinderella, where Cinderella was published in 1812. When comparing Ye Xian and Cinderella we can easily found out that both are strikingly similar in themes and plots, although written in different era and country, they reflect a common theme: good people are rewarded,…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For centuries, folklore has defined different cultures around the world. Many of these tales have been adapted into mainstream media for children by companies such as Disney. Unsurprisingly, Disney leaves out a lot of the original stories. The fairy tales from the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Andersen are meant to express topics involving the loss of innocence that young ones are not expected to know. Amidst modern literature, Joyce Carol Oates’s inserts similar connotations in her 1966 short story “Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been.”…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Prince Naveen arrived in town, all the white women flocked around him in hopes to gain partnership and become a princess. Although, Tiana was the first black princess in a Walt Disney film she was only able to become a princess because she married a prince. This idea creates a negative connotation that African American’s can only gain high status and power if they marry into wealth. In other fairy tales films such as Cinderella and Snow White finding their dream guy wasn’t such a long journey. Love didn’t come easy for Princess Tiana as she was faced with many hardships before she married Prince Naveen.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Even though Cinderella two wicked step-sisters were heartless and arrogant, “she still embraced them and forgave them with all her heart and married them to two great lords of the Court”. In the Grimm’s brother’s version, the folktale ended violently and fiercely because “the two step-sister’s eyes were pecked out by pigeons for their wickedness and falsehood” and they were blind as long as they lived. According to Maria Tatar the author of numerous articles on fairy tales and also ten scholarly books, “fairy tales have modeled behavioral codes and development paths, even as they provide us with terms for thinking about what happens in our world”…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Film ‘A Little Princess’ directed by Alfonso Cuaron in 1995 and tells a story of a young girl from India, who is sent to stay at a boarding school while her father goes to fight in war, as her mother is dead. On the other hand, the novel ‘The secret Garden’ was written by Frances Hodgson Burnett in 1911 and tells a story of a spoilt ten year old girl who has to move from India to her uncle's house in England after her parents had died from a disease. Both film and novel displays the theme of independence, change and growing up throughout while also having many differences between them. The central themes between the two texts is explored in the setting, characters, plot structure and style. There are many similarities and differences which…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    This fairy tale teaches society that even though someone may have achieved a heroic feat, such as the little mermaid saving the prince, they may not be renowned for it. This is evident when the little mermaid is rejected by the prince who thinks the young woman from the convent is his rescuer. The prince tells her, “The youngest of them found me on the shore, and saved my life. I saw her but twice, and she is the only one in the world whom I could love; but you are like her, and you have almost driven her image out of my mind”, showing that he truly loves his supposed rescuer (Andersen). That lesson of an unknown hero was lost as the tale was adapted into modern society.…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Young girls watching these films should aspire to be like Rapunzel who is strong and capable and not like Cinderella who is affected by others but rarely makes her own way in the…

    • 1540 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays