Comparing Orenstein's Cinderella And Princess Culture

Improved Essays
Over the years, young girls all over the world have fallen in love with the princess culture. Peggy Orenstein, a contributing author for the New York Times, writes about her strong feelings on how princesses have adverse effects on children in her article, “Cinderella and Princess Culture.” The author does not see princesses as just a passing interest for young girls, but as a leading reason for their self-confidence issues. Orenstein wants to make sure that the generations of girls to come stay individualized and do not fall into the trap of what society wants them to be. Using strong feminist ideals, Orenstein allows the reader to see eye to eye, expanding on how princesses are digressing the progress that has been made in the lives of woman …show more content…
Orenstein convinces readers that the princess culture is poisonous to younger generations by using personal experiences. Through the usage of words like, “evil stepmother,” “royal rubric,” and “royal moment,” she creates a fairytale-like tone. A primary example of this is when Orenstein experiences this conversation between her daughter and her dentist, “’Would you like to sit in my special princess throne so I can sparkle your teeth?’ I lost it. ‘Oh, for God’s sake,’ I snapped. ‘Do you have a princess drill, too?’ She stared at me as if I were an evil stepmother” (326). This may seem as if Orenstein uses hostility to get her point across in the real world, but in reality this shows how much she cares for her daughter. She wants to insure that her (daughter) future will be bright and the princess culture will not have any undesirable effects on her. Orenstein intentionally added the contrasting viewpoints to ensure that the reader could see where she is coming from. By applying these interesting fairytale words, she grasps …show more content…
Specifically, Orenstein shares that, “school-age girls overwhelmingly reported a paralyzing pressure to be ‘perfect’: not only to get straight A’s and be the student- body president…. But also to be ‘kind and caring,’ ‘please everyone, be very thin and dress right.’ Give those girls a pumpkin and a glass slipper and they’d be in business” (329). This deteriorates the legitimacy of the author because a small interest, such as princesses, is not the only reason as to why girls strive to be “perfect.” This elaboration on the issues that the princess epidemic produces limits Orenstein’s ability to reach a valid argument. By adding more reasons as to why a child, specifically a young girl, would feel self-conscious about her own body when role playing a princess will revitalize Orenstein’s argument. A topic that Orenstein could have added to ameliorate the reader’s understanding of the article would be to connect the topic to more current examples of why children of today’s society have lack of self-confidence. Orenstein’s success in the field of writing shows that she has had

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Peggy Orenstein’s point is that she is expressively disappointed on how today’s society labels young girls wanted to be girly, princesses, ext. She gives many examples that have happened to her daughter. She states that multiple people had called her daughter princess, been given a pink balloon without her having any say in what color she wanted. Labeling her as the “Ideal” female child by today’s standards. Mrs. Orenstein then continues that it’s not only towards female girls but to boys as well.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This strong sense of identity also carried over to the girls’ literary underlife. According to Finder literary underlife “created opportunities to disrupt the official, to document a refusal to embrace the obligations of the institution” (56). For the queen bees…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The character princess Elizabeth is stereotyped based on traditional fairy tales; where the princess Elizabeth has to rescue the prince by fighting with the dragon. She faces a sexist stereotype. This essay will briefly explain how effectively both the authors Levine and Munsch deal with stereotyping. In the story Hana’s suitcase, Hana’s family belongs to Jewish religion, who lives in Czechoslovakia in Europe.…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once women become exposed to society’s idea of “perfection,” they feel as if they are never good enough no matter what it is that they do. Both Orenstein and Poniewozik point out that women feel pressured to be both pretty and smart. Orenstein also adds that a lot of girls have stopped playing sports because it was viewed as “unfeminine” (Orenstein 673). The importance of this is because it means that these girls would only focus on making themselves look and act nice and they won’t care about actually being involved with themselves, meaning they would be so worried what other people will think about them, that they won’t have time to realize what they think about themselves as human beings instead of an…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotypes In Liz Prince

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages

    She states that “girls are expected to be polite and lovely and pink and frilly and dainty and reserved,” (16). However, she dislikes those expectations, not because there is anything wrong with it, it is just that she just feels like “they’ve never described” (16) her. She is aware of how society “makes a lot of assumptions about gender” (18), but she is not sure what…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society has a specific view on beauty that plays into the lives of children and adults that captivates society every day. Those who do not fall into these ideas of beauty are shunned out and chastised for their differences. First, Natalie Angier looks into the world of toys, and how the way these toys are being represented is shaping the minds of the children of tomorrow. Adding to this, in Andre Dubus’s short story, “The Fat Girl”, Louise, the female protagonist, is chastised and condemned as a result of her being overwhelmed which ultimately extinguishes her self-esteem. To close, in Marge Piercy’s poem, “Barbie Doll”, the central character must accommodate her entire life in to fit into society’s view of beauty.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These younger generations of girls/ladies have learned that not only can they be a princess and look beautiful both inside and out, but they are strong young ladies that have the world at their finger tip. This generation can become whatever their hearts desire as they increase their learning and social involvement. Parents should take it upon themselves to discuss with their children the visual display that is exposed by media such as Disney’s Princesses and today's modern idols; because their child might be going through the discovering phase or like Orenstein's daughter understands that, being a princess is a phase, but being a fireman is for…

    • 669 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Often, Caucasian women are portrayed as slim, perfect women who have perfect lives, just as barbies are portrayed. However, these little girls in Cisneros’ story show that they have overcome the value of materialistic value and the image that society has on women. The little girls play with the barbies, and one points to the other, “This and a dress invented from an old sock when we cut holes here and here, the cuff rolled over for the glamorous, fancy tree, off-the-shoulder look” (Cisneros 15). This shows that the little girls can make something useful out of having nothing. Their parents might not have the money to buy them clothes for their barbies, so they just use socks to make their dresses.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Image Expectations: A Comparison In the nearly not-a-short-story “Girl,” Jamaica Kincaid tells of a girl growing up in Antigua and receiving a long list of rules from her mother, while in the short story “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves,” Karen Russell writes about girls who were raised by wolves until taking in and reformed to fit into human society by nuns. Both stories have significant differences, but despite them, both “Girl” and “St. Lucy’s Home for Girls Raised by Wolves” share the issue of gender and the world 's forced and limiting image of a “perfect” girl. The girls from both stories deal with the pressures of becoming a "perfect" girl through the world’s high expectations of what their appearance, behavior, and relationships…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “She should be pretty, but as a class president way, not a head-cheerleader way… be able to stand up for herself… she must be socially conscious… she should above all not want to be at least until she changes her mind” (Poniewozik 325). Peggy Orenstein presents a more “school aged girl” idea to the means in which a girl should persist. Her idea continues to be more common in today 's society, a girl 's objective should be “not only to get straight A’s and be the student-body president, editor of the newspaper, and captain of the swim team, but also to be “kind and caring” please everyone, be very thin and dress right” if they want to become a princess (329). Although the authors have a different way of explaining what a princess should obtain, their ideas are very similar in which they both believe in a princess having leadership skills, integrity, self-discipline, and…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The original version provide a narrower outlook on the story and can easily set up unrealistic expectations for young girls. This change alters the theme from good conquering evil to a story between a mother and daughter. As part of Maitland’s new theme, she promotes a feminist message within her version of the fairytale. This allows her to establish a moral with a larger meaning. Because of this version, more people can come to the realization that there is a far greater “happily ever after” for the princess who doesn’t wait around for the prince to come sweet her off her feet, but instead who is strong enough to provide herself with her own happy…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost all girls have either seen or have heard the “Cinderella” story before. Being a princess has been most girl 's dreams as a child, but little do they think about the theme and the message the “Cinderella” story creates. Elisabeth Panttaja, professor from Tufts University and author of the article “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior,” explains a theme that people may find unsettling because she claims that Cinderella and the prince may not have been in love. She hints at the fact that Cinderella’s mother may have been the culprit in scheming and seducing the prince into marrying her.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To be a child in America essentially means that you are learning from your surroundings, therefore the general and popular modern day advertising, culture, and lessons are what a child is going to be seeing and hearing growing up. A child’s experience can be extremely different from another child’s experience, depending on gender, race, religion, and class. In the article from “A fabulous Child’s Story," it explains how there was a baby being raised with the gender unknown by the parents. Some might think that it was an impossible task, for example, in the story it states how family members and friends wanted to, or already had bought gifts for baby X, yet the parents would not tell them “what is was," in consequence, baby X barley got attention…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Responding to the Critic’s idea: Young girls tend to imagine and dream of being whisked away by a charming and wealthy prince because of fairytales like Cinderella that show and encourage it. I agree with Jack Zipes’ analysis on the decisions that women in fairy tales make. This supports the fairytale Cinderella and the decision that Cinderella made. Jack Zipes says that “comic endings call upon young females to value communal stability over individual needs.” meaning that the women in fairy tales made the decision to chose communal stability which is marrying a wealthy and handsome prince instead of individual needs, which is being an independent woman who looks after herself, provides her herself and creates her own wealth instead of…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article by scholar Carol Bailey, his focus is on the idea “preserving the self” Bailey states that readers of “Girl” only observe only the fictional representation of how to educate a child. Bailey points out how the speaker of “girl” provides many guidelines of living and lectures to the girl, but the girl has no room for discussion to defend herself. The idea that there is no room for discussion comes from the repetitions of “This is how” in Kincaid’s work “Girl” (Bailey 108). The constant nagging to a child of “This is how” gives the child no sense of just simply learning from her mistakes, instead she has to always strive to be correct. In order for women to be successful they need to appropriately perform their gender based on their culture, constantly being judge whether they do or…

    • 804 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays