Comparing Neil Salisbury And Joyce Appleby

Improved Essays
Neil Salisbury and Joyce Appleby composed two articles about the era the “New World”. The two articles are closely related and have several similarities, for instance they both talk about how the discovery of the “New World” affected certain people. Salisbury went into great lengths about the indigenous people of the Americas, and Appleby wrote about how the encounter affected the Europeans. Both of the documents have substantial arguments and both are greatly supported, however, it was brought to my attention that Mr. Salisbury’s article was far more convincing than Ms. Appleby’s. Neil Salisbury uses artifacts to defend his argument, but he also states, “… a number of scholars have been integrating information from European accounts with the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    8 – 10 (Did Columbus Kill Most of the Indians?) explains how the quincentenary of Columbus’ voyage to America elicited large amounts of controversy regarding the exact amount of native deaths that Columbus and his crew were responsible for by “discovering” America. S&A claim multiple resources state that the estimated 100 million population of Native Americans in 1492 was grossly overestimated, instead falling below 53 million, rendering the contemporary claim of up to 56 million native deaths (itself calculated with questionable methods) due to Columbus’ endeavors impossible. S&A then claim that the 53 million estimate is too high, stating that the environments of North and Central America could only support around 20 million people, not adjusted for inter-tribal warfare fatalities or disease deaths from pathogens already present in the New…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By viewing the early European-Indian encounter through the eyes of the Native Americans, this revolutionary examination intends to “turn familiar tales inside out, to show how old documents might be read in fresh ways...and to outline stories of North America”…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is no refuting Mann’s work, for it links pre-Columbian studies with contemporary thinking, but overall depiction, it seems that Mann is spoon-feeding his beliefs that all societies were sophistically unique. Though, Mann does focus on the indigenous people, he spends a great deal of time trying to rewrite history rather than engaging in an in-depth analysis of how the New World Natives were predisposed to collapse. The indigenous of the New World were prone to Old World disease thus a large factor in collapse of the pre-Columbian people. This factor is critical to the study of American exploration in the Age of Conquest; however, Mann simply alludes to this as minor significance – though this may be a flaw of his journalistic…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In chapter thirty three of Undaunted Courage, Stephen Ambrose records the events that transpired directly following the the famed Lewis and Clark expeditions. Robert Morgan’s theory that no true history of western expansion exists is based on the fact that…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In spite of the fact that both Howard Zinn’s “A People’s History of the United States” and “Part 1: The World Before 1492: Contact and Exploration - 1491-1607” both explore the same time period, the two works greatly differ in the aspect of the message they convey to the reader. This is seen through observation of the difference between the largely personal level from which Zinn describes the causes and effects of European exploration and the broader and more general view from which “Part 1: The World Before 1492: Contact and Exploration - 1491-1607” details the voyages of Columbus and the results of many other attempts at expansion- as seen in the textbook’s approach to the journals of Columbus. In contrast to the primary efforts of “Part 1: The World Before 1492: Contact and Exploration - 1491-1607” to shadow the inhumane aspect of European voyages in the Americas, Zinn’s text exhibits this nature of overseas exploration with ample detail. This distinction between the works of literature is seen at large with Zinn’s inclusion of a firsthand account by Las Casas of the work required of them “to exasperate, ravage, kill, mangle and destroy” (Zinn 7) the Native Americans.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Case: Omi And Winant

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Omi and Winant I. Racial Formations A. Susie Guillory Phipps vs. The State of Louisiana 1. Susie Guillory Phipps sued the state of Louisiana over the right to change her racial classification from black to white 2. Due to state law which states anyone with one-thirty-second “negro blood” in them was to be classified as black 3. Her case was lost and her classification was unchanged B. Racial Categories on Birth Certificates 1.…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The intended audience of the article “ The Indians' Old World:Native Americans and the Coming of European”, are the general public and historians because the article shows how a lot of people give more importance of American history after Columbus rather than before Columbus and criticize how historians know much less history prior to arrival of columbus in 1492. For instance, the author Neal Salisbury states that “historians now recognize that Europeans arrived, not in a virgin land, but in one that was teeming with several million people (435)”. 2. The author’s main argument is that there was densely populated society before European arrival, how certain patterns and processes originated before and after contact with the Europeans.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, many European countries formed colonies in the Americas. The most well-known countries were, Spain, England, and France, who all claimed land and worked to serve the mother country. However, they encountered many problems such as; a lack of knowledge of the land, unknown food sources, and, the Native Americans. The two books, A People’s History of the United States, by Howard Zinn, and, A Patriot’s History of the United States, by Larry Schweikart, discussed different view about how the Natives were treated by the explorers. Zinn’s book had a critical view of the explorers and their treatment of the natives, while Schweikart’s book had a more conservative view, due to each author’s opinions and research.…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, I will use Neolin’s “Journey to the Master of Life 1763” and “The Spiritual Travels of Nathan Cole” to rationalize how the discovery of the ocean world and the beginnings of American history was heavily…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Brothwell, Don. “On Biological Exchanges Between the Two Worlds.” In Europe and the Americas 1492-1650, edited by Warwick Bray, 233-244. New York, NY: Oxford University Press,…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Brilliant Essays
  • Great Essays

    He notes that in William Bradford’s Plymouth Colony, the settlers would rob Indians in order to survive throughout the harsh winter once they got off of the Mayflower. Diseases brought over by the Europeans also aided in wiping out many of the Native cultures living there as well; before the Mayflower, Europeans had already been exploring the Americas. These diseases would, therefore, have wiped out a vast amount of Indian cultures before many of the colonists ever arrived, skewing their views on the Americas and who inhabited them. Mann then brings up the debate of how many Natives actually lived in the Americas ‘at the time of contact’. James Mooney in 1910 wrote that 1.15 million people were inhabiting the Americas in 1491; however, in 1966, Henry F. Dobyns published a paper that completely changed anthropologists’ views on the number of Native societies in the Americas.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Papers from figures like William Henry Harrison would naturally cast a biased shadow upon the Natives and may have been elaborated upon in order to produce favor for the Americans. At best, all accounts by the author are historically accurate; at worst, they contain misinformation. However, the author used his well-qualified discretion in selecting the sources; which are arguably the best available. Without the ability to travel back in time, we will never know how truly accurate these sources…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Paper #1: Chapters 1-3 of Voices of Freedom Looking back at the whole occurrence of the discovery of the New World it becomes evident the many hardships that the colonial settlers caused which justifies the egocentric intentions of the many Europeans. It seems that even though the settlers were fleeing from a country that forced views among themselves or caused unjust situations; the colonists were precisely acting on the foreign population, who they viewed as “lesser”, similarly to that of their homelands. Although at the time the occurrence was not obvious, looking at it from today’s standpoint, it is quit ironic. On more than one instance the settlers treated distinctive groups with an inhumane disrespect with no regard to their well-being.…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the chapter ‘Forget Columbus’ of the book ‘The Inconvenient Indian’, the author Thomas King writes about his point of view on the forgotten history of the Native Americans. He conveys about the tales made up about the natives and americans engraved in the history to mainly appeal to the white audience. The author starts the chapter by telling how insignificant was the discovery of the land of natives made by Columbus. According to him the only reason why he was given credit and recognized because his story as Columbus sailing the oceans, travelling across with interesting adventures and going through hardships with a letter to the Emperor of Indies by the King and Queen of Spain captured the imagination of the audience and met the expectations…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The exploration and colonization boom of the 16th-17th centuries permanently connected Europe and the Americas, a connection that eventually formed the modern “West.” This new global connection not only created positive effects, but it also created a few negative ones as well. The European and American perspectives vastly changed because of this new connection that was created. Before the connection came to be, Europeans believed there were multiple continents, unaware of how big the world truly was. The Europeans believed that new trade routes, adventures, and the spread of religion could be a good aspect to come out of exploring the world, but it was also dangerous, unknown, and time-consuming.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays