Comparing Holden And The Catcher In The Rye

Improved Essays
Hello darkness, my old friend. I've come to talk with you again. Because a vision softly creeping. Left its seeds while I was sleeping. And the vision that was planted in my brain. Still remains. Within the sound of silence. (Bachelor). Sound of Silence is a song about a man with a dream, but no one will listen to his dream. No one cares enough to listen, but the only thing that is always there for him is the darkness. The darkness is a constant in all people, some have more than others, the man in the poem tells of a dream in where no one listens to him, he is alone. This relates to Ben and Holden who are outcasts in a very one sided society. There is one specific path to success and if certain criteria are not met along the way, they will …show more content…
Holden moves on to try and find a way to fill his heart a different way. This way involves Sally Hayes, she is a friend of Holden’s. When Holden and Sally supposedly horse around in a cab Holden says, "I told her I loved her and all. It was a lie, of course, but the thing is, I meant it when I said it. I'm crazy. I swear to God I am" (Salinger 125). Holden at the first chance he has a chance for a relationship he exclaims his love for Sally, but he also says that he lied, Holden is so needy for love, but he does not even understand what love is. He has never experienced love from his parents. The closest he gets to love is with Jane Gallagher. Having that relationship with Jane, which Holden has now frozen in a painful place where he may not longer touch it, has caused him immense heartache that, worsens the whole in his heart (Shaw). Similarly to when Ben tries to move on from the cancerous affair with Mrs. Robinson, that has plagued his life, in favor of a girl, who just happens to be Mrs. Robinson’s daughter. After one date with Elaine Robinson, he thinks he is in love. Ben wants to marry her, within a couple days of knowing her. He even stalks her to Berkeley when she goes back to college. Ben follows her around school pestering her with questions “‘Tomorrow then - can we get our blood tests tomorrow …show more content…
Some common signs of depression found in Ben and Holden are, mood signs; anxiety, general discontent, guilt, hopelessness, loss of interest, loss of interest or pleasure in activities, behavioral; agitation, irritability, or social isolation (Healthline). Most of these traits are found in either Ben, Holden or both. Holden throughout the book showed signs of depression by his guilt from Allie’s death, general discontent with other people and the world and not caring about his future. Then his behavioral signs are social isolation and irritability, he thinks everyone thinks weirdly of him. These signs in Holden may be just part of the teenage years though. According to, Peter Shaw, "The teenage years stand out as life's most complicated and tortured period. It has been said that teen behavior, with its swings into and out of rationality, actually resembles schizophrenia" (125). But there are also clues as to why Holden developed this distasteful view of the world. Holden developed this way because of the only person who he ever really cared about and who he really loved, Allie, died when he was young. In addition, the almost non-existent parents who just sent their kid to a mental hospital to get analyzed. “‘She killed Allie, too’ Of course he means by ‘killed’ that she amused Allie. But his unconscious

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Holden fears the possibility that he may spend the rest of his life as an outsider looking in. Although Holden attempts to change his social position, his mindset is out of place, preventing him from relating to how a normal individual would feel. Therefore, Holden struggles immensely in terms of making lasting connections with others, mainly because he cannot see eye to eye with them. “He focuses on the danger and potential death instead of love and a personal relationship” (Edwards).…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When he introduces a girl he likes, Sally Hayes, he emphasizes how he finds her personality annoying and loud, although it is clear that he is attracted to Sally because of the way he interacts with her. Holden’s experience with Sally clearly points out his issue with acknowledging the good in people and as a result of his confusion towards society’s actions, Holden’s mind is constantly put under a state of uncertainty. This uncertainty gradually causes him to lose faith in humanity to the point where he can no longer tolerate society and completely loses faith. Through his experiences, society continuously tests Holden to a degree so high that he can no longer handle reality, and goes…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Holden Caulfield Case Study

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited

    It can be characterized through various symptoms. The individual must have suffered from at least one manic episode, which is an abnormally long portion of a persistent expensive, irritable, and excited mood. Typically, it takes at least one week for it to be considered; however, Holden’s hospitalization and subsequent psychological evaluation allowed for there to be a shorter time period in conclusion. Depression also happens to be a symptom of this disorder. Depression is not normal sadness; inadequacy and hopelessness accompany normal sadness and that produces depression.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden deeply care for Jane more than life itself. Holden relationship with Jane is somewhat complicated. He is able to recall every details he remember about her and think about her almost every single moment. Holden consider running off with Sally Hayes,…

    • 485 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden has a form of depression likely spawning due to the loss of his brother, Allie, who has been implied to be an important piece in Holden’s everyday life. Holden has many mental diseases, one of the most prominent among addiction is that of clinical depression caused by overbearing grief, as well as the result of Holden’s depression.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Society is at fault for Holden's breakdown because of his brothers death. His breakdown is also due to the depressing realization that the world is corrupt and filled with evil. Holden also believes adults are phony from Pencey. As for…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden also says that she is a “royal pain in the ass” (173). Plus afterward he does not really mean anything that he tells her but at the moment he just spits it out because he is so excited. Both of them say that they love each other but they really do not mean it because if she does love him, she would have wanted to go with…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the teenage years, young people begin their quest for identity which is often a messy, sometimes jumbled path. This is where one will strive to find his or her personal path to success, and this journey is where an internal battle will begin to erupt and cause teens to become disoriented and confused. Holden’s major internal conflict revolves around his inability to deal with the death of his younger brother Allie. His parents never put him through any counselling or professional help, so Holden's feeling of loss and inadequacy eat at him from the inside. Because he is constantly at battle with this internal conflict, external conflicts because to stem as the result.…

    • 840 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pressure to be normal during teenage and early adult life in addition to tragic childhoods cause Ben and Holden to develop depression and other psychological issues. Some common signs of depression found in Ben and Holden are, mood signs; anxiety, general discontent, guilt, hopelessness, loss of interest, loss of interest or pleasure in activities, behavioral; agitation, irritability, or social isolation. Most of these traits are found in either Ben, Holden or both. Holden throughout the book showed signs of depression by his guilt from Allie’s death, general discontent to other people and the world and not caring about his future. Then his behavioral signs are social isolation and irritability, he thinks everyone thinks weirdly of him.…

    • 301 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It could be inferred that his mental state is what caused him to wind up in what is thought to be a mental hospital. Holden 's mental state in the passage is depressed since he suffers from suicidal thoughts because he is lonely and has no one that…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden constantly speaks about Jane, how he should call her and talk to her, yet Jane is never actually spoken to. Holden’s view of Jane is stagnated, forever entrapped in the youthful summers he spends with her: “Every time I got to the part about her out with Stradlater in that damn Ed Banky’s Car, it almost drove me crazy. I knew she wouldn’t let him get to first base with her, but it drove me crazy anyway”(89). In Holden’s eyes, Jane…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The point of a child is to prepare oneself for adulthood by learning valuable life lessons. The point of adulthood is to be the best person the community and their family calls them to be. But in The Catcher in the Rye by J. D. Salinger Holden wants to be an adult but wants to keep the good childhood memories thinking that that image will be these people forever as a frozen image. Holden is the main character in the novel and he has gone through tough times but one thing he does is refer to his favorite people with nothing but good memories of them putting them in a box witch to him are seen as “perfect people”. Early in the novel, he tells us a memory he has of his younger brother Allie saying “My brother Allie had this left-handed fielder’s…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Anthony D’Angelo Holden’s Mental Journey How does Holden’s trip to New York city in The Catcher in the Rye disallow him from reaching mental stability? Everyone in his or her life will face adversity at one time or another. Although facing adversity can be tough both mentally and physically on someone, dealing with hardships is necessary for the growth of one´s character. Today's society, however, can pose many distractions that can deter one from reaching a goal and overcoming certain adversity in their life. Highlighting this occurring issue in one's life, J.D. Salinger describes in his novel The Catcher in the Rye a young protagonist under the name of Holden Caulfield, who gets kicked out of boarding school and lives a life in New…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Holden said, “I’ve told you about ten times, I don’t owe you a cent.” Maurice told Holden that he was going to beat him up if Holden was not going to give him the money, but Holden stuck with what he said and would not give up his money. If Holden would have acted differently in the situation he could have been hurt. In addition to these choices, calling Sally Hayes and making a date with her was a debatable situation to Holden.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    An inescapable aspect of growing up is that parts of life will change. Though one may not like these changes or want to accept them, they must. These changes, like the death of family members or people around them, can mold a person dramatically, and shape the way that they think of themselves and the world around them. The Catcher in The Rye exemplifies this idea perfectly through the main character’s, Holden’s, experiences as he recounts his life and his actions and experiences before being admitted into a mental hospital. Through the character of Holden Caulfield and the idea of death, J.D. Salinger provides a narrative about how the realities of life and modern society can shape a person as they develop and accept those concepts.…

    • 2075 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays