Comparing Hobbs And Grafe's Youtube Pranking Across Cultures

Improved Essays
Different cultural and social backgrounds affect how people perceive the world. In the case of pranks, one person may respond with laughter and another may respond with anger. Pranks are typically viewed as forms of mediocre entertainment, but they offer insight into mediated culture and its societal implications. Hobbs’ and Grafe’s Youtube Pranking Across Cultures, examines cultural differences in online prank videos; they establish that pranks are a dark form of cyberculture, and I strive to further document their findings of how its negativity results in social solidarity and ethical discussion. The article changes interpretations and recognizes pranks as having more than entertainment value. Pranks have always existed in social culture. …show more content…
This is seemingly natural to humankind. Social unity derives from prank videos because the victims lack control, “but when comedy and malice are linked, it’s possible that re-articulations of social power through humiliation serve to represent and share complex emotions through online circulation . . .” (Hobbs & Grafe, 2015, para. 13). Prank videos are popular because the subjects in the videos are familiar to people: other humans. Viewers like to see what happens when someone is put into a situation without control. It is akin to reality where individuals can only maintain so much control over variables in their lives. The ending is always unpredictable. It is a thought often avoided, but indulged in when watching prank videos, due to its relatable “loss of control” factor. Viewers share the transgressive experience with others, despite not being the actual victim in the prank, “by making the target the victim of disparaging humor, other group members can gain a feeling of solidarity and cultural superiority” (Hobbs & Grafe, 2015, para. 12). Thus, social solidarity is established from viewing these videos. It plays on familiar human attributes and brings people together. Furthermore, Hobbs’ and Grafe’s finding of social unity is a greater revelation, despite their research centered on pinpointing cultural differences across online prank videos. It is important to find these cultural …show more content…
31), the article recognizes that the videos of children as victims garner more attention. The study finds that the traditional lower status individuals humiliating higher status individuals is not recognizable. Instead, children are the common victims in the U.S. videos. Comments responding to these pranks either normalize or reject the video content. The rejection is the key aspect that launches a social debate on the topic of pranks. This in turn “may support the development of digital and media literacy competencies that promote critical thinking about a wide range of humorous but distracting media content” (Hobbs & Grafe, 2015, para.

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Tyranny of the Mob” by Joel Stein focuses on how the internet is being used as a gateway to hate and that the people who have access to it have normalized the negative attributes. This article shows personal examples of how the web is becoming a vile link in the lives of humanity. Leslie Jones, a co-star in Ghostbusters said “They started sending me threats that they were going to cut off my head and stuff they do to ‘N words.’ It’s not done to express an opinion, it’s done to scare you.” Stein uses this personal example to show that the article’s main idea is how these trolls are threatening the lives of others through social media and how they are effecting the victims’ life.…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Julie Zhuo’s essay, Where Anonymity Breeds Contempt, does not effectively reach content providers because of Zhuo’s lack of consideration to the provider’s own experiences on the topic of trolling. Throughout her essay she argues that content providers need to take control over trolling by not allowing anonymous commenters, watching over comments, and asking users to report trolls. By following these steps, Zhuo believes that trolling will decrease. Trolling is when someone makes hateful or rude comments online- usually anonymously. Zhuo’s essay was published in November of 2010 during a time when Facebook and Twitter were the most popular social media sites.…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Frank's Redhot Analysis

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “Frank’s RedHot… I put that sh*t on everything!” said Jean Hamilton. Hamilton is a 92-year-old Caucasian woman that stars in Frank’s RedHot commercial. Contrary to popular belief Frank’s RedHot did not pop up out of thin air with a little old lady commercial. The history of Frank’s RedHot dates back 1918 when pepper Farmer Adam Estilette partnered with Jacob Frank in New Iberia, Louisiana, to create a sauce.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. The topic I chose for my argument explores how film producers handle bullying within their creations. The purpose of this topic is to see weather movies effectively or ineffectively represent bullying in the real world. The topic is based off of an essay called Anti-Gay Bullying written by Daniel Fricker and Lars Kushner.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Proctor and Gamble Should be Prosecuted for the “Tide Pod Challenge” A beautiful dark haired, blue-eyed young woman of the age of fifteen sits down to film herself engaging in the “Tide Pod Challenge.” As she bites down on the small, highly concentrated package of detergent, the great tension on the tight plastic packaging bursts, exploding the contents of the pod into her mouth. She frantically coughs in between gags as minuscule amounts of laundry soap creep down her throat. Swallowing the detergent causes burns to her esophagus and stomach, as well as gastrointestinal distress.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On January 22, 2018 A sophomore named Emily Gipson posted a video on Youtube. The video was titled “Welcome to Lebanon High School”. In this video, Emily explains bullying, gun threats, how she thinks suicide should be treated, and the awful ways people in her school community act. Some of the key things she says are about an online post saying, “She should just put a gun to her head like that girl from Lebanon High School, -Anonymous” and “gun threats are passed out like candy.” The administration pulled Emily out of class and gave her a punishment of two days in-school suspension.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Facebook: It’s Complicated Our lives with social media can be described as, well, complicated. People often find themselves in a heap of lies, misunderstood statuses or comments, and “friends” that aren’t even your actually friend. In Lauren Tarshis’ article, Is Facebook Making You Mean? she talks about how one simple comment on a friend’s Facebook picture or status can be misunderstood. Steven Levy’s article, Facebook Reset, describes how Levy wants a “friend-list do-over” (Levy, 2014, p. 169).…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In recent years bullies have found new tools because of the Internet. In the fictional movie Mean Girls the characters make up a burn-book where they write awful things in it about other classmates and pass it around the school as a way to bully and humiliate their peer. The modern-day version of this is the “burn page” made through Facebook on the Internet. In this iteration students make a Facebook page that other classmates join to disparage a peer.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is no questioning that in today's school system, one of the major issues is, and always has been, school violence. Which can range from a brawl amongst students, to more tragic events, for example, school shootings. Many of us have witnessed a fight in middle school or high school. Which usually have no permanent effects. But school shootings usually have a different outcome, on January 4, 2012, in my hometown of Brownsville Texas, a student from Cummings middle school was shot and killed after running around the school with a gun, which was later identified to be a pellet gun.…

    • 693 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A 14-year old girl was found hanged in her bedroom after receiving hate messages on her ask.fm page where strangers told her to cut herself, drink bleach, and kill herself. In this social media platform, the users are allowed to ask questions while remaining anonymous” (“Stories of Bullying”). The Internet has millions of suicide stories, similar to the one about this 14-year-old girl, all due to social media. Social media is the new trend and continues to grow. When out in public, it is almost impossible not to see people on their smart phones, checking email, facebook, ask fm, twitter, pinterest, myspace, tumblr, snapchat, or texts.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The results of this portion of the study showed those exposed to the video were significantly less likely to demonstrate negative bystander behaviors, but once again gender did not have a significant effect. In the third and final portion of the study, cognitive empathy on negative bystander behavior, the same video was viewed by all participants, but with different sets of instructions. The first group was told to identify with the cyberbullying situation in the video and focus on the victim’s emotions, and the second group was told to focus on the behavior. The results of this study show that both conditions significantly reduce negative bystander behaviors, and again gender played no role in this determination. The overall results of this study show that three factors are likely to increase negative bystander behavior: the online medium, the private nature of the act, and the experience of being a cyberbullying perpetrator.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There are a plethora of social media sites today. Discovering Computers 2016 (2016) defines social media as "a website that encourages members in its online community to share their interests, ideas, stories, photos, music, and videos with other registered users" (p. 72). From Facebook, to Instagram and Twitter. There are websites where you can socialize and then websites, such as YouTube, that are used to just post short videos. No matter what the social platform, there are millions of people plugged into them.…

    • 1482 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Close Reading Essay

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Writing Assignment 2: Close Reading Essay I will be looking at the article, “YouTube pranking across cultures”, by Renee Hobbs and Silke Grafe. After reading this article on online pranks, readers are able to understand the structure of articles. Thus helping the readers get an understanding of how prank videos have evolved over the years in our culture, in a good way and bad way. This is done by providing readers with good arguments, evidence, methodology and conclusions. With a good structure in articles it can help become more purposeful for audiences.…

    • 1054 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the data yielded by this study, the researchers found each of their hypotheses to be accurate and to have correlated with each other in the study. First, people who exhibit higher levels of verbal aggression are more likely to engage in the use of aggressive humor. However, as stated in the text of this article, the implications of this finding needs to be subjected to further research. The authors believe more information should be sought out before confirming the effects verbal aggressiveness has on people’s aggressive behaviors. Second, individuals who scored higher on the social dominance orientation scale were also more likely to use aggressive humor.…

    • 364 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humor In Social Media

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Finally, social media were used for the government’s propaganda through humor. The citizens demanding their rights framed the concept of Gezi through various ways such as posters, banners, graffitis, and caricatures. Nevertheless, political humor was the powerful weapon and the useful tool to form a political presence in the country during the Gezi. Nancy K. Baym argues that humor can be very significant to create social meaning in the online environment. In her work “The Performance of Humor in Computer-Mediated Communication,” she suggests “humor serves at least four social functions; it aids self presentation, facilitates the creation of common understanding, and helps generate solidarity and group identity” (Baym n.p.).…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays