Comparing Heroes In Beowulf And Sir Gawain

Superior Essays
Throughout all of literature, heroes, along with villains, ideally display the culture surrounding the setting of time during which the work was produced. Every detail placed throughout the work reveals both flaws and noble qualities within the hero or protagonist and also, by extension, within the society itself. These illustrations begin when the hero is compelled to act upon a threat in order to save the community. As the hero goes on his journey, the reader goes with him; they both in a sense face the same conflicts and learn helpful morals for later on in the journey allowing the hero and the reader to further themselves with more knowledge to be capable of passing through the rigor of the next conflict at hand. During Anglo-Saxon and …show more content…
In Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Gawain is called to adventure when the Green Knight asks “If any knight be so bold as to prove my words let him come swiftly to me here, and take this weapon, I quit claim to it, he may keep it as his own, and I will abide his stroke, firm on the floor. Then shall you give me the right to deal him another, the respite of a Year and a day shall he have. Now haste, and let see whether any here dare say aught,” (Weston) and his Uncle King Arthur steps forward. Gawain takes the axe from Arthur and decides to trade axe hits with the Green Knight. Gawain later crosses his first threshold by leaving camelot to search for the Green Knight. Both of these heroes are different because Gawain hesitates to accept the call to adventure at first while Beowulf does not refuse the call, instead Beowulf’s people think he is to strong and capable for this job. Beowulf displays anglo saxon values of duty and free will as he does not have to go save Geatland and Gawain expresses late middle english values of moral courage as he does not have to step up to face the Green Knight. One that guides the hero on their adventure is called the mentor, Hrothgar is a good king who is the mentor of Beowulf throughout the folk epic and displays a father like figure, and sets the …show more content…
And Gawain’s ultimate trial, he receives an axe hit from the Green Knight 3 times. Gawain flinches the first time, the second time the Green Knight messes up, and the third time, the Green Knight nicks him. This cut is his unhealable wound to display his breaking of the deal they made. The Green Knight revealed he was the host and made him suffer consequences for his actions as wearing the green girdle back to Camelot to remind him to always be ashamed of himself. (Weston) Both of the final trials are similar as both suffer consequences due to their pride because Gawain had the choice to travel but if he did not, Camelot would be embarrassed and Beowulf let his pride get to himself as he goes to slay a dragon alone. However their outcomes are different because Gawain lives and Beowulf dies. Both display cultural values of humility in terms of the anglo saxon and late middle ages. At the end of the ultimate trial, Beowulf is dying from a poisonous dragon bite and tells Wiglaf who would soon become King to bring him the treasure from the dragon’s lair. Beowulf’s apotheosis is that he feels like over his years he returns peace within the community along with wealth and fame and that makes him feel accomplished. While Gawain’s apotheosis is when the Green Knight does not kill him, Gawain is internally dead for allowing his needs come before what he is to do as a noble knight. This makes

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    As seen through the multifarious and complex world of literature, heroes or protagonists, have been instilled with various characteristics that reflect their individuality, while simultaneously demonstrating the broad sets of values held within their cultural world. By the reader picturing the hero’s journey through the hero’s very eyes, the reader has an increasing sense of what the cultures encompass and can relate it back to the individual’s faults and conflicts he undergoes within his or her journey. As heroes often take the bull by its horns and confronts particular obstacles, as seen in both Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, there is always a moral lesson that the hero extracts from the given event. For instance, as seen in…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This shows how Gawain lives up to the high standards of knight and will never shy away from a challenge. Sir Gawain was determined and always followed through. Gawain held the axe high, and then “quickly brought it down on the green knight's neck, cutting through his skin and bones,” therefore accepting that in one year and one day he would receive the same treatment (Raffel 68). Knowing that he would most likely die in one year and one day, Gawain still accepted the challenge and cut of the knight’s head. Gawain displays his bravery through his journey to the green chapel, because he faces many struggles and fights both physical and…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    To make him appear to the knights as even more intimidating, he wielded an enormous green axe that no sword would stand a chance against. The writer of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight states within the story that “It seemed no man there might survive his violent blow” (Greenblatt pg.190). The massive knight spoke of a game he came all this way to play, which required a knight of Arthur’s to chop his own head off, then he would get to return the favor to them. He then began to mock the knights calling them cowards due to the fact none of them would step up to the plate and accept the challenge. Then, with Arthur and Guinevere’s permission, Gawain rises from his seat and accepts the call of the Green Knight.…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sir Gawain: A True Hero

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The appearance of Green Knight was truly an unexpected incident, which gave Sir Gawain a precious long-awaited opportunity to execute his knighthood without hesitance. Green Knight’s call for dueling had a terrifying condition. It is described in the book as follows: “‘If any man in this hall is so brave and so courageous as to exchange stroke for stroke, I will give him this noble axe-- heavy enough truly to handle as he may desire: yes, and I myself will stand here on the floor and receive the first stroke of the axe wherever he may smite me. Only me must swear, and you, lord king, to give me the right to deal him such another blow, if I may, a twelve month and a day from now’”…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, Gawain had a green girdle from the lord’s wife. She said it could protected him and unable to be killed. He knew his could save his life, so broke the rules to kept it for himself. The Green Knight drawed his axe for the first blow, as soon as Gawain flinches, he stopped his hand. He was mocking Gawain for being a coward.…

    • 431 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cultural values of a community reflects the protagonists of literary works through their actions and beliefs. From the Early to the Late Middle Ages, some deplorable and splendid features persist throughout this era. Moreover, Sir Gawain and Beowulf, embark on quests that illustrate their era’s ideals. More specifically, both protagonists demonstrate honorable qualities as well as fraudulent characteristics in accordance with the paradigms of the peoples they represent. Although the quests in Beowulf and Sir Gawain and the Green Knight take place in varying time periods, corresponding and clashing traits have the potential to become evaluated through analyzing the context of the storyline and archetypes according to Joseph Campbell.…

    • 1766 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Green Knight proposes that "Anyone with the nerve to try it, take this axe, here...and give me a well-aimed stroke, and agree to accept another in payment, when my turn arrives, but not now: a year and a day will be time enough. So: is anyone here able to rise?" (Raffel, 56-57). Gawain waits and lets Arthur try first, but decides that he wants to prove himself and accepts the Green Knight’s challenge.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After having been granted permission to take the challenge from King Arthur, Sir Gawain immediately grabbed the ax, “hefted it high,” then “swiftly slashed” at the Green Knight’s neck. Sir Gawain did what he agreed to do and “the fair head fell from the neck to the floor of the hall” (215). The entire task was not yet complete however. The Green Knight then instructed Sir Gawain to find him at the Green Chapel a year and a day later so he could return the strike with his ax. As promised, Sir Gawain honored the knight’s request and set out to find the Green Knight’s chapel and conclude their deal. Like a true knight of the round table, Sir Gawain did not shy away from the idea of being struck by an ax.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    His character progression slowly but surely takes place for the better along his journey to find the Green Knight. Sir Gawain defeats all of his internal conflicts, even though they can be the hardest to face, and he goes to the Lord in times of need and thanks Him constantly, showing the qualities of a true hero. Sure, Beowulf defeats Grendel and gets glorified for it, but Sir Gawain accomplishes so much more and does not need praise, although he receives it. A true hero does not need glory, but a true hero…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Green Knight states “I never heard tell that Sir Gawain was ever a coward! / I never moved a muscle when you came down;” (284-285). The Green Knight thinks that Gawain is now a coward because Gawain flinches when the Green Knight comes down with the axe. The Green Knight teases Gawain about how he did not flinch when Gawain came down on his neck with an axe. Gawain states “I shied once:/No more.…

    • 1100 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Catherine Swanson comments, “To Sir Gawain’s surprise, the Green Knight reveals himself as the host of the castle and explains the blows. On the first two blows Sir Gawain escaped injury, because for the two days he faithfully kept the covenant. The third drew blood, however, because Sir Gawain failed to reveal the gift.” Every time that the Green Knight Hit Gawain with the ax, it didn’t do…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The stories of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and Beowulf both tells the stories of two honorable and noble kings, whose bravery is put to the test when they have to overcome obstacles in order to succeed in returning a favor and keeping a promise. There are some similarities and some differences that could be analyzed from these stories due to the fact that they both have heroic reputations that they seem to own up to by the end of them. Although, along with the similarities are the differences between them because they both have different experiences with their journeys that are displayed in their stories. As you continue reading, you will be displayed these similarities and differences between both heroic stories along with summaries…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beowulf exemplifies bravery and heroism throughout the entire epic poem, showing his embodiment of being the greatest warrior among men. Sir Gawain is described as being one of the noblest of knights, who exemplifies chivalry, loyalty, and courteousness. Beowulf…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These two great literary pieces, “Beowulf” and “Sir Gawain and The Green Knight” revolve around the idea of heroes being brave, courageous and honorable. Both are very similar with slight differences, such as the way the hero is depicted throughout the story, the various elements of the stories, magic, and more. These stories influence readers at the time like what it means to be a hero and also there are Christian influences. In “Beowulf”, the main character Beowulf is legendary and venerable.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    King Arthur's acceptance of the challenge gave Sir Gawain a realization his reputation is at risk and he now must act appropriately to grow his reputation. Sir Gawain respectfully asked King Arthur to let him decapitate the Green Knight instead of the king doing all the…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays