Comparing Girl With A Pearl Earring

Improved Essays
Throughout 17th century Holland, many people of the lower class sacrificed their life to improve the life of others important to them. People of the higher class didn’t realize the struggles some people and families went through to survive each day. Each character suffers to a certain extent throughout the duration of the book. The author, Tracy Chevalier, captures the differences and difficulties the separate social classes run into. Chevalier also captures the adaptation that the maids have to do when working in an unusual atmosphere The novel, Girl with a Pearl Earring, shows how different social classes have to adapt and collide in the duration of the book.
To start, Griet in the book is obviously in a lower class which is clearly stated
…show more content…
Throughout the book Griet starts to butt heads with one of her bosses named Catharina. This is because Griet has more flexibility than Catharina with the places she can go to in the house. Catharina has to adapt to this action, but she has a hard time doing that. Catharina, the wife of Vermeer, does not adapt or like Griet at any part of this book. Catharina is very uptight, rude, and sassy towards Griet because she notices, since the beginning, Griet has had a connection with Vermeer that Catharina does not have. Catharina would never dream of giving Griet any compliments like others in the book because she is jealous and judgmental of Griet. Catharina is nowhere near to being ready to adapt to another person entering her life that is not a family member. Griet, Vermeer, and the rest of the family has to keep the secret about Vermeer painting Griet from Catharina because she would be immensely jealous. The secret becomes extremely difficult to keep from her because her daughter, Cornelia, who is not very fond of Griet either, is starting to get scepticle. Between the pages 210-216 is when Catharina finds out. She completely destroys the painting with a knife. This shows that Catharina will never be accepting of Griet and will continue to collide on the marjority of things. Catharina, unlike her daughter, does not fixate her life on …show more content…
Griet, the lower class character, adapts to the ways of the homeowner’s life only because she knows the consequences if she does not. She would no longer have the job if she fought back against Catharina and Cornelia. On the other hand, the higher class characters, Catharina and Cornelia, know they have more power over Griet which makes them think she has to meet their requirements to have them adapt. This mother-daughter duo does not have the ability to adapt to another person who is a complete stranger. These three characters worlds collide in the attempt of getting rid of the one who is not considered important to the family,

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: This memoire written by Annie Ernaux is a conceptualization of class struggle and the roles of different actors within a family and society. It focuses on the death of Ernaux’s Father, and thusly how his life was constructed through societal norms and how the people around him acted in accordance with those norms. As an uneducated man who raises a daughter that escapes her social binding, the contrast between class structure, labour ideals and gender roles are prevalent throughout this memoire.…

    • 2160 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Strong Woman Would Never Give Up It is a movie to honor a great woman that never give in to difficulties and insist to her career. The Freedom Writers states a strong woman’s voice. A woman could be strong and never give up. At the beginning, we could see the background of the story, it is real, and really happened in America, gang violence could be a horrible threat to people while racial discrimination were terribly happened. And voluntary integration was taken into actions.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This brilliantly written novel by Tracy Chevalier is based on the 16th century painting, Girl With a Pearl Earring painted by the talented artist, Johannes Vermeer who at the time lived in The Hague, Netherlands. In the novel, Greit; a young teenager raised in a lower class family is being involuntarily told to be the full time maid for a high class family; the Vermeer’s. In the 16th Century, social differences, stereotyping, and class rankings were “social rules” that were practiced during this time. This is what makes the plot line interesting throughout the novel. Some examples of this are when; Catharina and her husband, Johannes Vermeer; the famous painter during the 16th Century, visited the household of Griet where they were looking…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Light wind whistles throughout the cold mountain air as the snow starts to fall and piles up higher than the tall peaks. The winter gloom is starting to settle in when the log cabin fires start to crackle. Trapped in their homes, people start to become claustrophobic and ill. Resentment builds between families, and tensions can be cut with a knife. This eerie scene is somewhat identical to Edith Wharton’s Ethan Frome.…

    • 1423 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Fahrenheit 451, Ray Bradbury introduces two women who influence the life of the main character Guy Montag, a firefighter whose job is dedicated to destroying books. The seventeen-year-old neighbor, Clarisse McClellan, is mentioned first and provides the stimulus for Montag’s new outlook on life. His wife Mildred, whose personality differs completely from Clarisse’s, portrays the second woman who impacts Montag. With their differences, Clarisse and Mildred influence Montag in opposite ways with their words, emotions, and outlooks on life.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Regarding education and friendship, significant learning is not able to develop without meaningful relationships. This idea is prevalent in Rules, a novel by Cynthia Lord. Rules tells the story of twelve-year-old Catherine and her struggle to find a balance between caring for her brother David, who has autism, and discovering her place in life. Preteen Catherine yearns for a “normal” life; one that doesn’t include frequently babysitting her brother and one not worrying about other people’s judgments of her family. Rules prove to be important in her family, as shown by Catherine, as she creates a set of rules for her brother that exceed the average house rules, such as “no taking off your pants.”…

    • 1448 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Power of Death and Tradition Beyond the words and structure of the short story “A Rose for Emily,” the author, William Faulkner, draws the reader’s attention to the power of death and tradition given by Miss Emily Grierson and the townspeople of Jefferson. Mr. Grierson and his daughter, Emily Grierson, live in the South in a community of judgement. The Grierson’s are monuments of the past and live their life accordingly to traditions. They are respected, yet also thought of as a burden because they restrain the community of Jefferson to modernize.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Griet’s relationship with her parents changes the most during her absence. Over the course of the story, Griet keeps the truth from her parents more than she would previously and comes to lying more often. She does this in order keep her parents from questioning her about her actions or what is happening around her. In her father’s eyes, the family lost Griet as soon as she left to work as a maid. One Sunday, Pieter the son visits their church in order to make an appearance to her family and she reassures her father that she will always be there for the family, even if Pieter the son stays in their lives.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Necklace: Change in Perspective In The “Necklace”, by Guy de Maupassant, Madame Loisel is a middle class French woman who always wants to look like the rich, and feel like it. So you can imagine she is quite thrilled when her and her husband, Monsieur Loisel, are invited to a ball at the Ministry of Education. Her husband buys her a new dress and her friend Madame Forstier lends her a beautiful diamond necklace, but problems arouse when Mme. Loisel loses the necklace.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The story “ Miss Brill By Katherine Mansfield ” is based off of the rather lonely life of an elderly English woman in Paris whom makes a living as an English tutor for young children and also reads to invalids. Miss Brills life is quite dull and dreary, as only a limited amount of things bring joy to her. The main ones are displayed throughout the story as her fur coat, and her ritual every Sunday in the Jardins Publique where she listens and watches the people around her to try and relieve her of the isolation she feels. Every Sunday Miss Brill will pull out her fur coat, dust it off and goes to the Jardins Publique for the weekly concert they hold.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the beginning of time women had to fight to get acceptance in society and prove that they could handle own amongst men. Women deserve the same treatment as men do and women are capable of doing the same exact things that a man can do. Susan Glaspell “Trifles” shines a light on the treatment of women and how they’re not treated equally as men are. Trifles simply mean of little importance or value. Men viewed their wives as a trifle and that they were only good for being a housewife.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brie Duvall: A Short Story

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Tabitha idly circles her index finger around the rim of her Manhattan’s glass. She is thinking about the new information she received only a few moments ago. She has already forgotten which of the three twits surrounding her brought it up, and if those screechy giggles that keep breaking into her thoughts are any indication, the girls have already moved on to criticize the maiître d’s new dye job. But the information itself keeps resurfacing in Tabitha’s thoughts. A new family has joined the club.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After discussing Chevalier‘s Girl with a Pearl Earring and listening to Berger talks about how critics mystifies art. Art is no more for the worthy, like Maria says, “It’s a shame such a fine painting is to go only to the baker (123). Vermeer’s works of art can be seen by millions, and still treated as a holy relic, but somewhere a teenage girl is wearing a shirt portraying the mystification of to who really is The Girl with a Pearl Earring was to hundreds of people, when she walks down the sidewalk in New York City. NYC’s bystanders viewing her shirt and then questioning the mystification of Johannes Vermeer past arts of works of the Dutch Golden Age. Chevalier writes in her book, “I wanted to wear the mantle and the pearls.…

    • 174 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the story of “Girl with a Pearl Earring”, the reader meets Griet, a young Protestant girl who is forced to become a maid in the Catholic home of the Dutch painter Vermeer. As a young woman growing up in the 1600’s in a strictly Protestant home, Griet is hesitant to work as a maid due to the poor reputation of maids and the distrust…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Similar to ‘An Unknown Girl’, the story begins with the protagonist deeply unhappy with her station in life, feeling as if she deserved to belong to a different class. There is a series of events building up to when the persona feels most accepted at the reception of the Ministry of Education. However, unlike a poem, this short story has a clear climax: when Madame Loisel loses the necklace. Thus ensued her spiralling descent into poverty, and her ultimate acceptance of belonging to a lower middle-class family. Dialogue is also used tellingly to convey the central protagonist’s wish to belong to a higher class.…

    • 2235 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays