Comparing Changes In The Land And The Organic Machine By Richard White

Superior Essays
Five hundred years have passed since European contact was made with what is now known as America. Colonization quickly followed, creating a New World with distinct cultures, traditions, religion, and politics. However, an economy driven society would prove to be the most influential factor during this settlement. The Industrial Revolution would not only alter human history in America, but would also drastically modify the natural environment as man progressed across the continent and learned to acclimate and exploit nature for its overall advancement. Both Changes in the Land by William Cronon and The Organic Machine by Richard White, discuss the effects man has had on the American environment—and vice versa—since early colonial days of settlement. …show more content…
Prior to the arrival of the Europeans, trade had already existed among the indigenous; a simple, effective method of likened goods. Example: one food for another food. “The whites particularly changed these relationships. They offered nonfood valuables for food.” (24) Reluctantly, the Indians eventually began to trade their salmon. Their expert skills, and efficient canoes and navigation of the river, allowed for sufficient fishing, much more than the settlers. The Indian tribes who had long depended on the Columbian River knew how to best utilize the “organic machine” to receive substances without damage or depletion. In essence, they understood how to work with the natural energy of the river to receive nourishment. Unfortunately, disease would ravage the region, decimating a magnanimous amount of the Indian and European populations. “By 1875, the total loss was close to two-thirds.” (27) Fishing of the salmon in the Columbian River never regained its previous grandeur by neither Indian nor white. However, human ingenuity and technology was on the rise, and other plans for the energetic river had been realized by Joel Palmer in 1845 upon his arrival in Oregon City. Hence the arrival of steam powered and water propelled machinery into a rapidly modernizing …show more content…
The Columbian River was dammed to produce hydroelectricity, altered for extensive irrigation, while fish breeding became a popular cooperative that replaced the once generous salmon population. According to White, machines using hydroelectricity and steam soon became the replacement for manpower, for a machine’s capacity to “exert far greater force than a man’s body could ever muster,” gave an obvious advantage in overcoming nature’s challenges to reaping in the rewards of advanced production. The result of these new implementations would be the transformation of an “organic machine” once ruled by the laws of the environment, into a manmade instrument void of true nature, which is now beyond repair and can never return to its former, as nature intended,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Change(s) in the Land William Cronon’s change in the land: the book is about Indian colonists and the ecology of New England, the book discusses the history of the economy and ecology of colonial of New England and how it affected the future of the region. In Cronon’s thesis he calms, ‘ the shift from the Indian to European dominance in new England entailed important changes well known to the historians in the ways these people organized their lives, but it also involved fundamental reorganization less well known to historians in the region’s plant and animal communities’(Cronon vii). According to Cronon, the environment the Europeans first encountered in New England shocked them. Early descriptions were restricted to the coastline, but…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organic Struggle, written by Brian K. Obach provides an in-depth overview of the organic movement in the United States. The author covers the history of the movement, the people involved, as well as the policies governing organic production. Obach also covers social justice and the future of the organic movement. Throughout the text the author ties together the political, social, and economic conditions of the movement.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Occasionally, a professor will assign a book in their lecture whose origins can be traced to a seminar paper. Undergraduates typically respond to this piece of trivia with emotions ranging from indifference to mild admiration. Graduate students however, tend to display more of an annoyed reverence which conveys the understood difficulties involved in forming an original and unique argument designed to contribute to the existing historical scholarship. In this regard, I am quite annoyed with William Cronon, who wrote Changes in the Land: Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England during his time as a master’s student at Yale University. The book not only contributed to the history of colonial New England by casting the environment as…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How did the Lewis and Clark expedition impact the United States? Starting with the birth of the United States, waterways were essential for trade, communication, transportation, and the formation of colonies. With the Louisiana Purchase under way, colonizing the west became a large priority due to the many resources and opportunities it held. In 1803, under the presidency of Thomas Jefferson, the United States purchased a large sum of land from France which was known as the Louisiana Purchase. According to America, This purchase included 875,000 square miles of land extending far beyond the boundaries of present-day Louisiana”…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book, Changes in the Land by William Cronon, he describes the drastic changes of the environmental landscapes and natural resources in New England during the colonial era. According to Cronon, these drastic changes occurred as a result of human interactions, which depleting the natural resources and destroying the ecosystems. He stated that Native Americans and Europeans played a significant role in changing these landscapes by depleting the natural resources and destroying the ecosystem of the New England. According to Cronon, Native Americans and European affect the New England ecosystem very differently because of their different views about nature, living styles, agriculture, and the economy. Native Americans and European affect the ecosystem of New England…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How did transcontinental contact lead to the emergence of a global exchange in the 1500s? Claim: The contact between Afroeurasia and the Americas in the 1500s influenced trade through the exchange of new agricultural products of which changed the diets of individuals as well as the use of peoples for slaves in the Americas due to the many plantations used to cultivate crops for export, both of which increased trade, for the purpose of increasing income and economic growth, benefitting only the Europeans through the use of African people and the brutal treatment of Native Americans, generating a one-sided global exchange between Europe and the Americas. ¶Paragraph 1:…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Industrial Revolution was a time of modification for the United States of America. The old ways of life were scrapped, melted down, and reformed into a powerful machine of industry. But as the economy and boomed, society rotted and decayed. Poverty was rampant everywhere and death infested the cities.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    William Cronon’s Changes in the Land – Indians, Colonists and the Ecology of New England, depicts the changes that occurred in New England after the arrival of the Europeans. It not only provides a detailed account of the changes that took place from a historical point of view, but also from an ecological pint of view – meaning it not only paints a picture of how the European settlers changed the lives of New England’s Indian inhabitants, but it also clearly shows how the arrival of the Europeans forever changed the landscape of the ecosystem at the time. Cronon’s thesis, according to him, is simple: “the shift from Indian to European dominance in New England entailed important changes – well known to historians – in the way these peoples…

    • 2123 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Using property perception and trade economy to explain how said shift caused irreparable damage to New England’s ecosystem. The strengths of his argument lie in his formatting and use of multiple points of view. However, his weaknesses of consistency and placement of his concessions undermine his book. Ultimately, Cronon succeeds in explaining how much colonialism changed the environment despite the lack of technology. The reader should keep in mind how much more can be changed with our new…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Erik Gilbert and Jonathon Reynolds, authors of Trading Tastes: Commodity and Cultural Exchange to 1750, “trade would seem to be a basic human urge” (2). It has existed throughout human history, even before written records and farming. Trade has been a critical part of life for as long as we have known. Up to the present day, trade affects the closest parts of our lives. The clothes we wear, the food we eat, the toys we play with, the tools we use, and several other things we encounter daily are often obtained through the act of trade.…

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the book, Steinberg touches upon factors such as expansion, conservation, and urbanization that have all had huge impacts on the environment. In the chapter “The Unforgiving West”, Steinberg shows us how the Gold Rush sparked mass Westward expansion and the implications it had on nature and humans likewise. The Gold Rush caused many…

    • 1438 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The members of the expedition “unwittingly brought new diseases [smallpox] to the area that decimated the local native population. Where the Mandans had a thriving and sophisticated trading center when Lewis and Clark arrived in 1804, by the late 1830s their total population had been reduced to less than 150” (“Exploration: Lewis and Clark”). A comparison can be made between Christopher Columbus and the explorers as they both wiped out a significant portion of the Native American population, as many of them had not developed an immunity to the diseases. Additionally, many Native Americans were forced to convert to Christianity and take up farming. This eradicated the Native’s way of life, which was centered around their religion, traditions, and hunting-a method of gathering food and skins and proving oneself in the tribe.…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Reading a standard American history textbook from cover to cover, one would likely not run across many references to the natural world. Occasionally the author mentions the influence of mineral discoveries, or devastating natural disasters such as earthquakes and dust storms, but never how the environment molded the societies that developed within it. Ted Steinberg’s Down to Earth: Nature’s Role in American History is a noticeable departure from this methodology. His ambitious goal is simple, “to change the way you think about American history.” (Steinberg, ix)…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Changes in the Land” is a personal work of William Cronon that generally gives a persuasive and original interpretation of the dynamic conditions in the plant and animal communities in New England that took place when there was a change from Indian authority to European authority. It uses both the ecologist and historian tools to construct an analysis of the way the people and the land influenced each other, and the way the complex network of relationships created the communities of New England. In his book’s thesis, in page xv, he states that, “the change from Indian authority to the European authority in New England resulted in many significant changes that are known well by historians regarding the ways the people lived that time and also led to basic reorganizations of the animal and plant communities in the region. As Cronon writes, when the settlers arrived in New England, the environment that they first encountered astonished them.…

    • 1233 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    When Christopher Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492 the world had no idea what the effects on the environment would be. The interaction between the Europeans and the New World Inhabitants of North and South America and Africa, as well as Asia is still relevant in the ecological impact that took place between their encounters during the Age of Exploration and onward. The exchange of ideas was the utopian ideal but the utter truth was that the natural environment and human stewardship of that environment during this new global encounter was altered for the worse. This paper will examine the great exchange between different cultures and examine the ecological imperialism that was carried out by Europeans.…

    • 1471 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays