Comparing Benjamin West And Frère Luc's Paintings

Decent Essays
I completely agree with you assesment of Benjamin West and Frère Luc's paintings. These painting show two different views on Native Americans one as inferiors and the other as equals. In Frère Luc's painting the Native American is veiwed as inferior to Europeans. In the painting the Native American has gone though a process of assimilation and has accepted European superiority and converted to Christianity. Europeans adopted the process of assimilation because they believed that their religion and values were superior to the Native Americans. Benjamin West painting tells a much different story. In the painting William Penn is negotiating to buy land from the Native Americans. During this time it was common practice to just take the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans have endured disease, colonization, and relocation from their homes. Much of their culture was drastically changed due to mission efforts and government intervention which led to massive acculturation. However, to claim that their culture was buried with their ancestors is a rather ignorant accusation. In other words, it was transformed to fit the view of modern society, but remaining in touch with their roots. To better understand this transformation, I have focused to analyze a painting by Oscar Howe (Native American) titled Rider which creates a unique blend of Native American and Western design.…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When the white man found Native culture, it was not appreciated, rather it was viewed as iniquitous and senseless leading the Euro-Americans to become pompous and refuse to allow room for adaption and…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Both articles, Julie Schimmel’s Inventing the Indian and Leonard Bell’s Artist and Empire: Victorian Representation of Subject People, delve into the topic of native people and their representation and misrepresentation in artwork. Bell’s writing dives a bit deeper in my opinion in terms of his historical analysis than Julie Schimmel’s. Schimmel’s writing comes from the viewpoint that leans more toward the side of art history rather than historical and tends to brush over the historical relationship between the whites and the Indians. I should note that she does go into enough detail so that a reader with no prior knowledge of the already strained relationship between the Native Americans and the White Americans would be able to understand…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Articles Of Confederation vs. Constitution Before the Constitution of the United States was incorporated as the Supreme Law of the Land, the Founding Fathers drafted the “Articles of Confederation”, which can be deemed as a “mini constitution” which contained many flaws and inaccuracies which the Fathers attempted to rectify and improve upon. Initially, the U.S. was not actually united in the legal sense – rather, they were a loose confederation of states (hence the Articles of Confederation) independent of national authority and supremacy. For example, the States coined their own money, taxed their own citizens, controlled their own trade and commerce – and there was no President who would oversee the States to execute the law. With these few examples demonstrating the fallacies of the Aricles, we have already grasped a few problems. Firstly, how are the States capable of conducting trade and business with each other if they individually coin different currencies?…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Discussion 1 The turn of the century in 1900’s, most remaining Native Americans had been forced, to leave their ancestral lands; it was truly a time of cultural assimilation (Assimilation through Education). Some chose to live on the reservations that were created by the U.S. government starting in the 1890s, while others spent their lives hiding from whites whom they feared would kill or capture them. Native Americans world as they new it naturally died out, from progression (Assimilation through Education), they needed to become a part of white society. There Indian language, religion, and art, would become something from the past to be studied or viewed in a museum, but would not be the products of living cultures.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1. After the Reconstruction the freedman had a hard time. They had a hard time both with finding jobs and eating at times. The good thing was having the options to move to try and live better lives.…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Trail of Tears was a series of forced removals of Native American nations from their ancestral homelands in the Southeastern United States to a piece of land that was designated as Native Territory. In 1803 the Indian Removal Act was passed leading to the removal of the Creeks, Chickasaws, Choctaws, Seminoles, and Cherokees were relocated off their land. The trek was over 1,000 miles long and thousands of people died while being transported. Before the Indian Removal Act, the tribes were thriving in the southeastern United States. White americans saw American Indians as unfamiliar, alien people, causing them to try to “civilize” them by trying to make them as much like white americans as possible.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Due to their strong belief, they felt Native Americans could not be civilized until they accept the social practices of whites’ society, or superior society. The only way…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    An Analysis and History of Native American Injustices Everyone in the U.S. grows up learning about Columbus, Thanksgiving, and the British colonies. Meanwhile all that many are taught about the indigenous peoples is that the “savages” showed the Europeans how to farm, there was a good harvest, and then they lived happily ever after. A majority of people doesn’t know what the history teachers leave out. The Europeans came to the Americas not just to explore but instead to profit from its resources. Also it was the Ancient Siberians – the ancestors of the Native Americans – who found the Americas, not Columbus or Leif Erikson.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Europeans have had an impact on many peoples’ life and culture. This was no different when the Europeans first came to America and encountered the natives. When the English and the Puritans first arrived, the Native Americans handled them in different ways. Some welcomed them with open arms, while others approached them with caution. ; however, despite handling the Europeans differently, the natives were still impacted by them all the same.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Of course, the Native American and English cultures repel. The Native Americans have a different perspective on Earth, captured in Pocahontas’ Colors of the Wind, property, and religion than the Europeans, focused on ownership, a product of imperialism. Moreover, English religion distorts colonial relations. Europeans decided that the Indians did not fit into the story of the Bible and, inherently, are not human. This misconception—and failed attempt to fit Native Americans into the European culture—provides a catalyst for English violence towards the Native populations.…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since 1494 the Native Americans have been called savages and were treated unjustly by the Europeans. The Europeans assumed that they could go to America and take what they wanted, without caring whom was already living on the land. The Europeans also thought that they were superior over the Native Americans. The Europeans were much more advanced with their weapons compared to the Native Americans, and the Native Americans were frightened by the loud noises that the weapons created and the violence that followed it. Once America was invaded by the Europeans, the Native Americans lives were forever changed.…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Arguing the Feelings of Native American Mascots In “Appropriating Native American Imagery Honors no one but Prejudice,” Amy Stretten argue “Racial stereotyping, inaccurate racial portrayals and cultural appropriation do not honor a living breathing people. Plain and simple, cultural appropriation- especially when members of the culture protest the appropriation - is not respectful” (Stretten par.7). In short, Stretten is arguing that the way society goes about “honoring” Native Americans is offensive and should be discontinued.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The history of Native Americans and settlers in the New World has long been biased towards that of the colonists settling in America. Few people know the extent to which the bias exists and they also don’t stop to consider the perspective of the people that have rightful ownership of the land. What most people do know are the stories of conquest that are often taught in school. These accounts are heavily in favor of the settlers and paint Native Americans as the savage evildoers hell-bent on ruining lives.…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If the Natives were given a fair share for the land and were allowed to coexist with the Americans, then Manifest Destiny expansion would not be seen in such a terrible light. Thinking of the Indians as equals would have not caused the white settlers to treat them so harshly. It was only in execution that America’s expansion west is reflected on so poorly. The way Manifest Destiny played out was despicable, but the notion of expansion was quite viable.…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays