Comparing Ayer's Essay 'Freedom And Necessity'

Improved Essays
In Ayer’s essay “Freedom and Necessity,” ‘but not suppose it to be claimed that, so far as men’s actions are concerned, there is a limit: and that this is limit set by the fact of human freedom.’ In this quote, he believes that the problem can be deciphered and the interpretation of what is freedom in a relationship to those entities that oppose freedom or restrain it. In either circumstance, what is at risk is the free will of an agent, and whether if that agent is ethically responsible. Also in question on whether not that the individual is acting freely and is accordingly responsible for his or her current situation. In respect to the nature of free will is in reconciliation with determinism in the compatibilist and its absence in the causality

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the Preface of the textbook, Give Me Liberty! , the author Eric Foner draws attention to three key points about the concept of freedom and its importance in American history. The three points are “the meanings of freedom, the social conditions that make freedom possible, and the boundaries of freedom that determine who is entitled to enjoy freedom and who is not”. Foner’s concept of freedom address that freedom is more than one variable. Over the years as America grew and change to be what it is now, history shows us that the meaning of freedom has and can change depending on the situation of the time then.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Eric Foner’s “Give Me Liberty” Franklin Delano Roosevelt was born in 1882 and the fifth cousin of Theodore Roosevelt he won the election of 1932 as the 32nd president. While everyone was in despair from the Great Depression he began to restore the confidence of the people starting with a “bank holiday” and his series of broadcasts to the public. During the “bank holiday” all banking operations were temporarily stopped and many acts were passed to rescue the financial system and prevent the reckless actions that helped contribute to the crash. His broadcasts to the public were called “fireside chats” through these he was able to include the public in politics and he was able persuade them to agree to America joining World War II…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Charles Arthur Campbell was a philosopher who defended the Libertarian view of free will. While he was a believer in free will, he also left room for determinism because he believed that determinism does not go against the correct view of free will. He believed that in order for an act to be free, the agent must be the sole author of the act. If one is subjected to the influence of past events or a set of events one’s action is not free because if other entities other than the agent had influence upon the given act then that act can no longer be deemed morally correlated to the agent. One must also have a real sense that one could have done otherwise in order to be compatible with the view that one event does not lead to another.…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, the free will problem, pertaining to philosophical nature, will be introduced and explained so that the reader can grasp the foundation of this essay’s main focus. The main focus of this essay is A.J. Ayer and his argument for compatibilism. The argument for compatibilism, according to Ayer, is that a choice that one makes cannot be free unless it is caused. Ayer also suggests that a person can only be held morally responsible for their actions if they had the ability to choose otherwise. This may sound confusing right now, but it will make sense soon.…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Regardless of the action, in society everyone is morally responsible for their actions. However, in to hold a person morally responsible for action or decision he must make that decision freely. Philosophers have argued about this concept of the existence of free will and having moral responsibility. Furthermore, there are those philosophers that do not question free will, but rather the idea of being help morally responsible for an action.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the founding of the United States to the present, the idea of freedom has been the staple of America’s appeal. The roots of freedom were planted in the Declaration of Independence, where Thomas Jefferson defined freedom as “all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” The statement held an attractive promise, as it seemingly applied to all Americans. In reality, the promising statement was intended solely for white men, and these restricting ideals were rooted deep into the soil of the rapidly growing America. It is clear that modern American freedom does not equate to that of the Founding, but the degree to which it…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within this essay, I will argue that Galen Strawson’s basic argument, presented in Your Move: The Maze of Free Will, is correct about the impossibility of ultimate moral responsibility. I will do this by first explaining the basic argument as proposed by Strawson, then raising an objection to it concerning the distinction between the self and the way you are by denying the second premise. And finally, I will be refuting the objection. Strawson’s basic argument can be boiled down to the simple notion that one cannot be ultimately morally responsible. He claims that anything you do in any circumstance is an effect of who you are, and the way you are.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The debate of Free Will v Determinism is one that has gone on for centuries, and shall continue to go on for many to come. There are many who believe that their view is the end all, be all, correct view to hold. While not all of these thinkers are correct in their standings, Paul Holbach’s essay, “The Illusion of Free Will,” lays out a strong argument for universal determinism; man does not have any free will, and all of his actions are determined by the laws of nature. His argument is one that is accurate and strong, leaving little to criticize, despite what many believe to be proof that he is incorrect: the presence of choice and the absence of restraint. He takes these two beliefs and shows exactly why they do not denote free will, and all…

    • 2442 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Eric Foner’s Gateway to Freedom: The Hidden History of the Underground Railroad, Foner discusses the rise, fall, and exploits of the abolitionist movement in the United States. Foner, a famous and renowned historian, is currently the DeWitt Clinton Professor of History at Columbia University. Foner wrote this book to explore and dissect newly found information that reveals the hidden history of the abolitionist movement in America Early on, the abolitionist movement in New York City was not very popular. New York City’s economy still greatly depended on the work of slaves in the South, proven by, “New York City’s prosperity…depended on its relations with the slave South” (Foner 44).…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As autonomous humans we generally think we are morally responsible for all the things we have done. That being said, it is only natural to believe that for a person who is morally responsible for what he/she has done than they could have done otherwise. Meaning they could have do the exact opposite of what they did. This alludes to the question that many philosophers have struggled with, this being, what does it mean when someone says that an individual who acted in a particular way “could have done otherwise?.” R. Chrisholm takes this concept as the fundamental question in our metaphysics of action and has formulated many explanations for the so called “free-will problem.”…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For one dedicated to the furthering of liberal ideas within the political sphere, the application of limitations appears, upon first reading, to be in direct contrast with that goal. If the advancement of human society hinges upon the free practice of one’s unique moral code and personal intellectual exploration, in what regard does the limitation of other’s same rights elevate the collective good of a society as a whole? Although seemingly paradoxical in nature, the “enforcement of restraints”(7) complements John Stuart Mill’s major principles of moral human behavior, in such a way that the balance of liberty versus authority shifts in a direction favorable to human progression. In essence, a liberal society is one in which the will of the people is safeguarded by the larger powers at hand; with limitations placed conservatively so as not to infringe upon one’s individual rights. If total free will was the object of desire, it would inevitably undermine the very principles upon which it hinges, destroying itself by the very doctrines it wrote.…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Freedom is a cloudy term, and various ideologies perceive it differently. However, while it is plainly difficult to define what we mean when we throw around the word freedom, we treat freedom like a unity. For such a complex, ill-defined construct, freedom is deployed in literature and society exceedingly often. Morrison deconstructs this unity, overturning the assumptions attached to the…

    • 1411 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This philosophical question is still not unsolved, but in this essay I will argue that a freedom of choice cannot be had by an agent in a deterministic world. Determinism thesis states that all events in the universe are determined by previous events. In determinism, every even is determined to happen by the laws of the the system.it is assumed that once the laws are set and the systems are decided, everyone following the event in the system is also decided. This assumption proves that humans are not free to chose how they act, but are determined by prior events over which they have no control over. The freedom that is precluded by determinism is the freedom to act without recourse to prior events, which means not having a choice determined and is able to act many different ways in any situation regardless of the cause.…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Fight For Survive American is a mixed state, classified as a result of ethnic reasons, of their skin color, immigration, and wealth gap. This is a real problem, which cannot be avoided. Even the liberation movement in the sixties and seventies had arisen in the last century; no idea has ever been substantive solution. Confrontation continued, war continues, halt the only survival rights. In the movie "Freedom Writers", the students at Wilson High School in Long beach, California, live in such a violent atmosphere.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Free Will Vs. Determinism

    • 2021 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Thus, actions must be caused properly in order for them to be free, and that the proper cause must come from inside the person. Compatiblists declare that the common usage of the word free will is essential for determining the correct definition. For example, say that in scenario one, I don’t get on the Internet for a week because I do not have any direct or wireless access to the Internet. In scenario two, I do not get on the Internet for a week because the FBI is tracking me, and I don’t want to get caught. Scenario one, is a case where I was forced to stay off the Internet.…

    • 2021 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays