Compare Reverend Hale And John Proctor

Improved Essays
Reverend Hale vs John Proctor
In the play The Crucible by Arthur Miller, there are two main characters, Reverend Hale and John Proctor. Both of them are portrayed as two very well respected men in the play. They both play a big role in this play, as Hale is an intellect and an expert in witchcraft, while Proctor is a farmer who stands against witchcraft. Ultimately, Hale helps Proctor by siding with him when Proctor was accused of witchcraft. However, Proctor chooses his own fate and he is hanged as a tragic hero. These two characters are role models for other Puritans. However, they weren’t completely identical. There are many similarities but even more differences between Reverend Hale and John Proctor.
John Proctor and Reverend Hale are
…show more content…
Even though, Hale believes in witchcraft and his job is to search and destroy witchcraft, he doesn’t think that John Proctor believes in witchcraft. John Proctor isn’t always being truthful. For example, John Proctor replies “I….am sure I do, sir” (Miller 66). When Hale asked Proctor about whether he knew the 10 commandments, Proctor lies because he breaks one of the commandments, adultery. On top of that, John Hale cannot lie because he is a minister and it will ruin his reputation if he lied. Although John Proctor and Reverend Hale’s motives were similar, they were still a little different. John Proctor tries to stop witchcraft to rescue Elizabeth Proctor, his wife, and to bring the execution of innocent people to a halt. Hale also has to stop the witches and the executions, but Hale isn’t stopping witchcraft to save his family, he is doing it because he is an expert at it and he wants to stop the evil. Reverend Hale’s actions are always honest because he would get a bad reputation if he was caught lying. Proctor’s actions aren’t always as honest as Hale’s because they are all to help save his life, which causes him to lie more. In addition, Proctor yells at the court and also uses profanity, revealing a bit of a rude personality. For example, when John Proctor yells, “God damns liars, Mary!” (Miller 117). Proctor yells at Mary Warren to get her attention, by using profanity. On the other hand, Reverend Hale is a …show more content…
They are both men who are around the same age and they are men who don’t fancy hypocrites. Their Motives are very similar in this play, because they are both trying to prevent people being accused for witchcraft from being executed and they don’t like hearing or speaking of the evil side. Another similarity is that they both have a soft side in their personality. However, there are more differences between these two characters. First, both characters have the same goals, nonetheless, they have different reasons for completing their goals. Moreover, John Proctor lies about his actions while Reverend Hale doesn’t lie at all. Also, John Proctor is more hot-tempered, while Hale is usually calm and formal when speaking. As the play progresses, the similarities and differences become even clearer than before, giving even more context and content. (word count:

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Proctor evidently comes to realize that he values integrity and moral justice more than his reputation and even his life. At first, he accepts his conviction of being hanged because he knows he has no way out of it, but changes his mind after his wife Elizabeth’s persuading. His mindset was that since he already committed a sin, therefore he wouldn’t go to heaven like Rebecca Nurse. He believes that one more lie cannot send him to Hell twice, so he chooses to lie and delay going to hell—the same consequence. He is cooperative and confesses that he has seen the Devil, but after Danforth’s asks him whether he had seen other people with the Devil, he loses his patience.…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Nothing’s spoiled by giving them this lie that were not rotten long before” (136). John Proctor doesn’t want to lie anymore as a sinner because now that he forgives himself for his unfaithful actions. He can use “shreds of… “ 9At this point, John changes because he chooses to die honest than live with another lie. His change is important because it shows how much he wants to prove to Elizabeth that he loves her and not Abigail. This is because he chose to stay with his statement which said that Abigail was a fraud and he chose that which would get him hung.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Proctor wants to forget that there was once an error in his judgement that caused him to commit a very serious sin. This quotation demonstrates that even though both characters are equally responsible for committing such a negative deed, Proctor is too proud to admit that what he had done was wrong. Proctor is trying to keep Abigail silent because he knows that if the truth was known by the people of Salem, his reputation and good name would be ruined. John Proctor’s pride causes him to avoid dealing with the consequences of his negative actions rather than dealing with the problems his sins have caused. The fatal flaw of pride is once again seen in John Proctor when he destroys the document that was going to save his…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He expresses the truth when he states, “I speak my own sins; I cannot judge another. I have no tongue for it” (Miller 141). Before the fallacy of witchcraft was brought about in Salem, John had a different outlook on honesty compared to his outlook at the final trial. The reader can infer this by analyzing the change in his quality of honesty in that time period. David Sundstrand proves this when he states, “Yet Proctor refuses to let the court keep his signed confession for it is hard evidence of a lie.…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Proctor opposes the court because he does not want to ruin his name. When Judge Danforth orders Proctor to sign his confession, Proctor refuses “because it is [his] name! Because [he] cannot have another in [his] life! Because… [he has] given… [his] soul” (The Crucible 143). By confessing to witchcraft, Proctor gives his soul away to the Devil, but signing would mean that he would have to give up his name.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He has the opportunity to save his life by confessing to witchcraft, but refuses to smear his name any more. John’s name is highly important to him, and disgracing his name is like disgracing himself. John has the opportunity to keep his life by destroying his name, but he feels that his life is not worth living if he is unable to keep his name. John also feels that he is unworthy of doing the right thing and acting like a hero. He feels he does not deserve to stand next to Rebecca Nurse and Martha Corey, and this almost causes him to save himself by confessing to lies.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Symbolism In The Crucible

    • 1661 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Proctor will not let the members of the church and state pressure him into making the false confession and using him as their pawn to crucify more innocent people. By choosing to die for his beliefs, Proctor proves to everyone that he has moral principles that will not let him sacrifice his name or his family. Even though he started out as arrogant and selfish, Proctor takes responsibilities for his actions and transforms into a good person that his family can be proud of after he is gone. In his determination to gain back his strength of character, John Proctor uses his contempt for the corruption of the church, his undying love for his wife, and his need to take responsibility for his actions to admit his sins, to denounce Abigail Williams, and to save his soul during the Salem Witch Trials. Even though Proctor finds himself in this enormous mess, he learns what is right and…

    • 1661 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Parris and Danforth were responsible for the witch trials because they had the opportunity to stop it but they chose not to. Parris is a reverend which means that he has power in the community. He is also a selfish man who would want his reputation to be good in the community and be surrounded by his wealth. He also didn’t intentionally want Betty to be affected by witchcraft because he feared that people would not like him if that happened. However he put complete faith in Hale when Hale said it was witchcraft.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He is one of the characters to blame for the initiation of the Witch Trials because he accused others of doing the devil’s work, particularly Abigail, to protect his own name. It is evident that he is trying to prove his power. To save his own reputation, Proctor is willing to trash the character of others. By doing so, he further tarnishes his own prestige. In Act IV, when Proctor is called upon to sign the confession of demonology to be nailed to the church door, he does not sign it because he believes he is too good to stoop to that low level.…

    • 1258 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He says that others like Rebecca Nurse, are untainted by sin, so it would actually be a lie for him to be hanged looking like he is sinless too. When Danforth requires him to sign his “confession” so that it can be hung on the church door for all to see, John signs it, but immediately snatches it up and refuses to hand it over. Early in the play, Proctor’s desire to preserve his good name keeps him from testifying against Abigail. Now, however, he has come to a true understanding of what a good reputation means and what course of action it necessitates- that he tell the truth, not lie to save himself. He feels that, in confessing a lie, he has not only cemented his own lack of integrity, but also that he has confirmed his own moral worthlessness.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays