Rational And Control Theory In Criminology

Amazing Essays
Introduction - The subjects of study which has “logy” in them became very popular from previous century. The critics are getting involved very much in every field. Theories need to be proved properly and use practically in favour of mankind. In Criminology, from the beginning the laws were introduced by the high class people in western countries. Some of their hypothesis and assumptions were shown as right without any scientific proofs. The rational and control theories are in this debate from ages. Some argues these are perfect and should use as a major criminology theories but some disagree. Both theories are very complex and flexible which is the main reason why they still exist and working. In brief, rational choice theory means that every …show more content…
He did advocate the control theory from the long time. He argued that individual who is tightly bonded to a social group such as family or school is less likely to become offender and increase person’s likelihood of obeying rules, because of the development of self-control (superego). Hirschi listed the four key interrelated elements in the creation and maintenance of this bond. The first and most important is Attachment then the second one is Commitment, third is Involvement and fourth is belief (Jones, 2012). A General Theory of Crime (1990) by Michael Gottfredson and Hirschi again try to expose that a person with low self-control if ever get an opportunity, crime will happen. There are numerous reasons for that such as sometimes they prefer quick solutions, not being able to plan or predict things and so on. Usually offenders failed at school, work and in marriages. In simple words they are bit different from the beginning and that is why good parenting is needed. After the Gottfredson and Hirschi’s book twenty-one studies published in ten years. They support that there is a strong relation between low self-control and crime …show more content…
Hirschi shift the basic question of criminology which is “why did they do it” to “why did not they do it”. The control theory is mainly depend on assumptions. Predictions can possibly on the basis of individual’s belief can be wrong. They said everyone can commit crime which practically seems not so true. In older age social bonds break sometimes, but most people do not commit crime then. Opponents shows that this has more effect on property and drug crime instead of violent ones. Overall males commit more crime than women. According to old theories it is impossible to prove high level crime such as white color crimes. They do over prediction sometimes which cannot affordable practically. Rational choice theories often use similar to choice theory but these are different. Most crimes do not appear rational to most people. It do not stop the crime just change the area

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    National Crime Victimization Surveys include crimes that are not reported to police which is called the dark figure of crime. Crimes not reported typically include rape, sexual assault, and abuse. People do not want to report crimes because they are afraid of the results so many of these incidents go largely unreported. The NCVS also uses careful sampling techniques and conducts a yearly survey. Self-Report Surveys also include crimes that are not reported.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Historically, very few attempts at vigilantism have been done correctly, but in the slim chance that it is done successfully, the streets of the most dangerous cities will become safe. Criminals feed off of rebellion of the system; there is a reason that increasing law enforcement and police resources is a faulty…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Another factor that influences the crime statistics is when numerous crimes are committed and only the most serious offence or the top four offences are reported. What this does is it overemphasizes the most serious crimes and ignores the less serious crimes. If six offences were committed and only four were noted that leaves two crimes that are not in the system and minor or not, that shows that the crime statistics are not that accurate especially if one wants to know exactly what is happening in their communities. So while police crime statistics may be somewhat helpful in generally knowing what is going on one should not fully trust it because police discretion, underreporting and underrecording, creates a big dark figure of hidden criminal activity that is actually…

    • 1268 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In almost every case, firearms were the main weapon used when mass murders took place. Even with the statistical evidence many individuals are blinded by their second amendment rights than to see the correlation between guns and mass murder. Even though the link is well noted, imposing stricter gun control laws does have its flaws; they do not account for guns that are purchased legally. Some argue there should be stricter background check for individuals who are purchasing firearms especially when it comes to mental illness and previous crime. But when looking at the statistics behind previous mass shootings, many of the perpetrators were not clinically diagnosed with mental illness.…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Victorian Era Crime Essay

    • 2089 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Life was very tough for law abiding citizens when police were a distant thought. This era was making anyone into criminals, and even young kids were marked as thieves and murderers. Although later in the era, the percentage of criminals decreased, it was still an out of control problem. This is still decreasing in the modern era. The modern era of Britain brought a new type of crime where criminals were not committing crimes because of poverty, but because of opportunity.…

    • 2089 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many criminals do not see great importance in their life and believe they do not have as much to lose if they were to be caught. This makes the concept of deterrence ineffective because individuals do not see the punishment as a major deal. Alcohol and drugs are often involved when crimes are committed. With this being said, judgment is impaired. Generally, individuals more likely associate shame and embarrassment to illegal acts rather that the punishment (Berger, Free, and Searles 2009).…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If they do not get what they want they will use fear and maybe even physical attacks to gain what they desire. Fear is huge when it comes to organized crime, but the failure of perspective plays a part in organized crime. Time and time again people get the perception that organized crime operates in a separate world of crime, that it targets only those who are greedy and are getting what they deserve. But this far from the truth and it is because of this perception that organized crime does not get the attention that it requires. Even though public officials do acknowledge organized crime they see it as a small problem compared to other situations.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Apparently, this method does not show the exactly amount of people who have been victims of crime because of many scared people of declaring a crime due to threatens or simply are not recognised as such. Survey methods is more reliable as is inquired to individuals from different social class to measure whether there are more victims of crime within working class or media-class, however, this method cannot be used for young people under 16 years old, although some people declare that the majority of young people are more likely to be victims of crimes than elderly people as a young people seem…

    • 1746 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    But, for some who show criminal behavior it can be very hard to find out exactly what would be shameful to the criminal. You see for some criminals’ acts or criminal behavior, all it does is give them street credit especially if they are sentenced to jail/prison. Most of the officers within the criminal justice field look for these vises in order to make criminal behavior stop, but that does not always work. So, can it work in the criminal justice system? Well, I believe so, but it will not be an easy task, because some criminals are just like terrorists they are not easy to shame, break or embarrass.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Despite increased overall arrest rates, recent research by NIJ shows that dual arrest rates are low, and more than half of arrests made do not result in conviction,” (Hirschel, 2008, pg. 3). Once again, do not result in conviction. “Federal laws also make criminal certain acts that involve violence committed among persons in intimate relationships,” (Followill, 2015). If abuse is against the law, why are the abusers not convicted?…

    • 1054 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays