Compare And Contrast Puritan America In The Scarlet Letter

Improved Essays
The past of America is portrayed in both The Devil in the Shape of a Woman by Carol F. Karlsen and The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, giving us a better perspective into our past. Puritan New England sets the stage for the two novels because the society is what shapes the characters and the events of both novels. Both novels show relations with Puritan society, sin, and women 's sexuality. However, the portrayal of the different sides of Puritan America and the focus of the novels are different in the novels. The characters in both also have many similarities and differences between each other. These similarities, yet differences in the novels show how Puritan America shaped how society behaved toward people who disobeyed their beliefs. …show more content…
Puritanism was the center of seventeenth-century New England, which made society’s entire beliefs about life and their actions based upon Puritan beliefs. Therefore, the individuals from both novels are accused of breaking Puritanical laws; in one novel Hester is accused of adultery and in the other many women are accused of being witches. Puritan America is mainly represented in both these novels by depicting what happened to these women who defied the norms of their society by committing what society deemed a “sin.” Sin is represented as a major theme in both novels because the sinful actions that the women and men committed in these novels are the main focus. The immoral acts the characters committed resulted in their social degradation and humiliation in their society. Another similarity between the two novels is that they both talk about women’s sexuality. The Scarlet Letter’s main focus is that Hester Prynne has committed adultery, leading to her public shame and humiliation. Her adulterous affair showed the sexuality that was to be repressed in society because it was immoral. In The Devil in the Shape of a Woman, the women were seen as temptresses who would succumb to their sexual desires with other men or even with the Devil himself. It seems as if Puritan society viewed women’s sexuality as repugnant because it was both a “sin” and a disgrace to see this women …show more content…
The Scarlet Letter portrays Puritan society as a bit more lenient than that in The Devil in the Shape of a Woman because although Hester committed a sin also, she was not executed nor exiled for it. Even though adultery was not as sinful as witchcraft it was still a punishable act for she committed an offense to God. Therefore, Hester’s town still punished her for her adultery by publicly shaming her, only living with her sin. On the other hand, in The Devil in the Shape of a Woman the women accused of witchcraft were so feared by their Puritan society that they had to be executed for it. The court officials did not even take into consideration the possibility that these women might be innocent because they only thought that if they were suspicious enough they had to be severely punished. Another difference between these two novels was that The Scarlet Letter mainly focused on the experience of one sinner while The Devil in the Shape of a Woman focused on a numerous amount of sinners. The Scarlet Letter mainly focuses on one character so that the readers could get a deeper perspective of how Puritan society shaped a person when they punished someone for committing a sin. It also gave us a chance to truly see how those around the sinner were also affected by their sinful actions. The Devil in the Shape of a Woman focuses on the experiences of many women

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “And I look—And there was Goody Good…Aye, sir, and Goody Osburn” (Miller 47). After Tituba confessed to witchcraft, she then accused Sarah Good and Goody Osburn, as she would no longer have this fear of punishment because accusing others would mean that they would take the fall instead. Though these women were innocent, Tituba’s fear of punishment lead her to be immoral and accuse these women of witchcraft which…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “The women accused of witchcraft are, not surprisingly, those who did not conform to socially constructed gender roles, such as Sarah Good, who participated in extramarital sex, or those who hold social power such as Tituba, the exotic slave from Barbados” (Tunc 267). As a result of sexism towards women in this time period, many were targeted for accusations of witchcraft, which resulted in the executions of many innocent women. Furthermore, the theme of good versus evil is also present in both “The Scarlet Letter” and “The Crucible”. Both authors use characters to represent the idea that good overpowers evil and that evil is hidden within society. This idea and theme is carried throughout “The Scarlet Letter” by Roger Chillingworth and his personal vendettas which served as motivation towards his evil acts committed.…

    • 1508 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    evil that revolves around the witch trials. In the story, characters such as Abigail Williams and Judge Danforth, as well as the witch trials themselves can all be considered good or evil but one cannot exist without the other, however; they can coexist. The witch trials can be defined as good and evil because the people thought they were doing good by killing the witches when in reality, they were doing evil. When it came to the belief of the Puritans, that also contributed to the witch trials by their belief of anything that was not good or that did not follow God was very sinful and evil, which is why those who were not followers of God were looked down upon as witches or warlocks. The character that portrays evil throughout their life are Abigail and Danforth because they played a part of the witch trials themselves.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She initially tried to go after Elizabeth Proctor to get her true love John Proctor. She felt manipulated and wanted the blame put on other people’s shoulders that she felt was targeting her. They abuse their power in the court convicting their critics. Not only should the girls be blamed for all the convictions, but so should society and the judges for being so gullible into believing the girls. Even at the end, Abigail and Mercy Lewis stole Parris’s money and fleeted, the judges knew they had been lying but also didn’t want to take the blame or lose their pride for killing so many people and standing on the girls side.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In an attempt to save herself from being hung, Sarah Good told the court she was a witch. She admitted to writing in the Devil’s book. Her deceit, along with the lies of all the other members of the community were a direct cause of Abigail’s lie, these women would never have been arrested if it were not for Abigail’s deception. Lies can spread faster the disease in some cases and should not be taken lightly. To convince the court of their intentions to do the work of God, the girls accused many innocent people of the heinous crime of witchcraft.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Damned Women Analysis

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the book, Damned Women: Witches and Sinners in Puritan New England, Elizabeth Reis examines the relationship among women, evil, and Puritanism in the seventeenth century New England. Reis not only explains why women were more likely viewed as witches or followers of the Devil but she also explains how men would sin in Puritan New England. In her book, she discusses why even puritans themselves, came to think that they forged a pact with the devil. Elizabeth begins stating that she believed Women in Puritan New England along with the culture regarded women to be damned more likely than men. Puritans believed in predestination; salvation and damnation were foreordained by god, not in hell or heaven even though god would choose, women and men still could not wait for judgement day.…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hester’s sin was that she had out of marriage sex with another man, Arthur Dimmsdale. The town’s people, upset with her actions, ordered her to wear a scarlet letter ‘A’. "Ah, but let her cover the mark as she will, the pang of it will be always in her heart." (Hawthorne, Chapter II) The guilt of her actions eats away at Hester, but not as much as they do for Dimmsdale. The main difference between how Hester is punished compared to Dimmsdale, is that while Hester’s sin is known by all, she does not say that Dimmsdale was her partner in that sin.…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hawthorne wrote Scarlet Letter to portray the effects on Puritans harshness on adultery for women. Hawthorne made sure to show how much Hester had to go though because she has the child to prove she sinned. However Hawthorne seems to have a small gap that doesn't fit in with the puritans out look. Like the way Hawthorne showed Dimmesdale's weakness towards what other would think, instead of coming clean and clear of his conscience. Also the way Hester had to be the man of the house and took over care of everything.…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aquinas even stated that God had made a mistake in creating women because they brought on the beginning of sin. Early thoughts of women being involved with evil contributed to the popular belief that they were followers of the devil, making it more convincing for their persecution. The witch hunts revealed men’s fear of female sexuality and independence, as they tried to restrict them from everything in the…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Salem Witch Trials Dbq

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages

    After all, witches were in alliance with the devil, and the Puritans did not agree with this, which were why these witches were killed. Another noteworthy reason for the Salem Witch Trials was the social status among the Puritan population. People were accusing each other due to jealousy. The poor were jealous of the rich, and the single women were jealous of married women. According to some statistics, there was an underlying…

    • 1007 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays