Compare And Contrast Montana 1948 And Twelve Angry Men

Improved Essays
Larry Watson’s Montana 1948 and Reginald Rose’s Twelve Angry Men both view society in a negative light that is full of prejudice and injustice. By placing both of these texts in a pessimistic view, readers are able to see that all humans are flawed. Both authors are able show that character’s varied ideologies, mistakes, and traits are a part of human nature. Watson displays these ideas through Wes and Julian whilst Rose mainly shows this through Jurors 3 and 10. Equally, Watson and Rose showcase in these texts that prejudice and injustice are prevalent and damaging to society.

Everyone affected by Frank’s crimes in Montana 1948 leaves them with a choice between justice and loyalty. These events also bring out the common prejudice against
…show more content…
Both texts put these flaws mainly in characters that we see in a negative light. Juror 10 and Julian are similar characters in the way they stick to their prejudice and have aggressive or dominating tendencies. However, Juror 10 gives up in the end when he realises that he is the minority and no one else on the jury will change his mind. Julian on the other hand, stays loyal to Frank to the very end, even it if did cost him the relationship between his son, Wes. What contrasts between these two texts that there is no progress in erasing the class prejudice in Twelve Angry Men compared to the racial prejudice in Montana 1948. Wes is a character we come to respect. He changes his attitude from thinking Indians are “ignorant, lazy, superstitious, and irresponsible” to taking these allegations seriously and seeking justice. Unlike Wes, Juror 3 or 10 for example show no signs of changing their ideas against class or age. Their prejudice ideas are still a big part of their personality even when their verdict is ‘not guilty.’ Both texts still view the human race as flawed but each text perceives this idea in different ways.

The texts Montana 1948 and Twelve Angry Men both view humans in as flawed in a pessimistic way. Watson and Rose both showcase this through character’s traits, ideologies, and mistakes. Watson displays this idea through Wes and Julian. Rose on the other hand, betrays it through Jurors 3 and 10. In the end, their view on society may sound cold, but it is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Although the jury knew Tom was not guilty, they still elected him guilty cause it was socially unacceptable for a black man to win against a white man’s word. After the trial, Atticus explains to Jem and Scout how the court system and society is flawed, “There’s something in our world that makes men lose their heads - they couldn’t be fair if they tried. In our court’s, when it’s white man’s word against black man’s, the white man always win. They’re ugly but those are the facts” (295). Here Atticus explains to Jem and Scout how society functions.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Atticus believes racism is ignorant and hateful. This is shown during Tom Robinson’s trial when Atticus, while addressing the jury, criticizes Bob and Mayella Ewell for, “the assumption - the evil assumption - that all Negroes lie, that all Negroes are basically immoral beings, that all are not to be trusted around our women, an assumption one associates with minds of [the Ewell’s] caliber.” (Lee 204) Atticus associates racial prejudice with wickedness and stupidity. To Atticus, Bob Ewell’s racial prejudice, as well as racism in general, is immoral and ignorant. Atticus, in contrast to many other characters in the novel, does not accept the institutionalized racism that is entrenched into Maycombian society. Instead, he fights racial prejudice because he views it as fundamentally flawed and stemming from a lack of empathy and understanding for those outside one’s social group.…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racism is one of these major issues. Shown in the novel, “To Kill a Mockingbird”, by Harper Lee, Tom Robinson was clearly put into a bad situation by just trying to help out another human being in need and ended up being persecuted for it. Racism was the cause for this and it happens to so many others in the world around us. Robinson was not the one at fault here, but is found guilty because there is a folly in the system of right and wrong. Clearly, racism needs to end, in order for everyone to live as one.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They both agree on their points about judgement and injustice. These stories have a main point of racism which are shown to be very important throughout. Both Harper Lee’s and Sidney Lumet’s stories show the problems in America’s judicial system through views on racism, injustice, and judgment. To Kill a Mockingbird and 12 Angry men are stories about racism. To Kill a Mockingbird shows racism through Tom Robinson’s case…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The white people still respect Atticus because he has courage to stand up for what he believes in. Also the white people respect Atticus because, deep down agree with him but are not brave enough to say it, and if they do they will get tormented as well. For example, Link Deas is Tom’s boss, but believes he's innocent and for that the white people are shaming him or not buying food from his store. Atticus Finch, a courageous and respected lawyer that treats everyone equally even the Ewells; even though the Ewells are the poorest and illiterate people in Maycomb. True courage is standing up for those who are discriminated even if you others disagree with…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If that were true then racial prejudice would not exist. There would no be police brutality would, no hate crimes, and no need for protests. Despite that fact, people out there still live their lives everyday ignorant to what is going on in the real life. Coates is right to warn his son “to be a conscious citizen of this terrible and beautiful world,” because otherwise, he'd be living a lie. The history of America has shown us how cruel and violent "white Americans" can be to those they view less.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although Atticus manages to prove Tom Robinson innocent, as the white jury still refuses to declare the innocence of Tom Robinson a black man who was physically impossible to commit the rape and did look for physical evidence. Scout "climbed into Tom's skin" and could see how Tom Robinson was a man who did not harm, had a family, and helped others like Mayella Ewell out of kindness. Tom Robinson was proven guilty when innocent once again racial prejudice has a huge impact on the white court and have executed a "mockingbird". Atticus has taught Scout that she should be able to put herself in the other person's…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    People of different races and genders experience shame for not satisfying society’s standards of perfection, and the resulting stress can lead people to hate themselves and hide their flaws but in reality making mistakes is human. Brown concludes that shame is an epidemic…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Saul mentions, ‘’holes in the universe that swallow all light all bodies. St .Jerome’s took all the light from my world.’’ This explains how even before going to St. Jerome’s that he experiences depression from the lack of Aboriginals. Also through discrimination from other races and without the support of Aboriginals, Saul is changing into a negative person. As Saul expresses, ‘’ I started to notice things after that I started to see a line in every arena.’’ From the discrimination towards Aboriginals when they are not well represented, the racism forces Saul to be aware of the racism around him but with the amount of racism Saul will think that every conflict is related to race. From this it leads Saul to more…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result of the change from innocence to experience, one of the most important themes is the hatred between the races. Prejudice, and ignorance harm innocent people such as Tom Robinson who is not evil as many people take him for. Jem discovers how cruel the world is when the trial ends and even though all evidence is in Tom’s favor he is found guilty. Scout doesn't completely understand which makes Jem’s view important to the reader. Jem learns how unjust the world is and the evil that surrounds him while Scout has only learned that bad things can happen to good people.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays