Michael Young Education

Amazing Essays
In this assignment, I will be outlining and analysing two academic papers written by Michael Young and John White and discussing their key arguments, whilst comparing and contrasting throughout.
The key argument in Michael Young’s paper is comprised of a number of aspects related to schooling. The main question that is being addressed is “What are schools for?” One associated factor of this argument mentions that every passing generation has to ensure they attempt to answer this broad-ranging question, due to the significance of how schools have a distinctive role to play for the future of academic individuals. Schools play a key part in building a bridge to the world of work for young people, assisting them to acquire knowledge, enabling them
…show more content…
Young exemplifies two different notions of knowledge; in essence, he argues that it is beneficial to make a distinction between the “knowledge of the powerful” and “powerful knowledge”. The first term discusses who comes up with the definition of what knowledge is accounted for and who has accessibility to it. Perhaps, in today’s society, many people are attending higher educational institutions, thus it may seem plausible to conclude the fact that they possess a sense of power and supremacy in society, in turn allowing them to gain an ease of access to particular types of knowledge and acquiring it. The second concept is referred to as “powerful knowledge” where Young suggests that it is all about the power of knowledge and the role it can potentially carry out, meaning if it can deliver consistent elucidations or perchance, contribute to new perceptions of thinking differently about the world. Furthermore, touching upon a previous point regarding parents and the sacrifices they have taken, they strongly hope that their children obtain knowledge in education, as it is not accessible for them to acquire at home. Young also gives the impression that powerful knowledge is otherwise known as specialist knowledge, and if the school 's aims are to implement this “powerful knowledge”, then they will require teachers who possess that specialist …show more content…
White’s central argument opposed to Young’s claim is the fact that this type of knowledge does not provide much assistance in moulding and shaping the curriculum schools should have in place. He also states that Young is unsuccessful in complying with the criterion for the national curriculum, as it is deficient of theoretical framework and believes that powerful knowledge, as a rationale for a curriculum will easily fall apart once it has initially been subjected to

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    3. What differentiates your teaching strategy from other candidates? It is important to pick candidates whose students would strive for nothing but the best. It is important for teachers to have major teaching techniques in order to help their students…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dialogic Talk

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Throughout this essay, I have drawn upon my developing professional practice; in light of the experience, I have had as a practitioner to demonstrate the importance of talk as a foundation to learning. Dialogic teaching is vital in the classroom. Teachers should embrace talk to support children’s development in cognitive, social and emotional terms; however, there are barriers to its educational benefits. Not all children in classrooms can access talk; therefore, they will have a different foundation to learn. We as teachers should strive to ensure talk is genuinely…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, the community should take an active part in the education of their children by fundraising and outing words events and such, for if each school relayed on state funding, somewhere someone is getting the short stick. There must be a balance of both. The question of who should be in control is a difficult one. It is in my opinion that teachers should be in control of education. Because they are the ones teaching it and inside the classroom itself it makes sense.…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Interpret The Past

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Additionally, there is an enormous pressure on teacher to prepare each child to meet mandated state’s standards, thus, there is a time constraint and less focus on teacher inquiry based history in favor of fact feeding, and memorization. Our goal as teachers of social studies should be to guide students to ask questions and construct interpretation of past and current issues because even at a young age children can learn important thinking and decision-making…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It’s my belief that a school is a place where children are being prepared for the future. By teachers who challenge, stimulate, provoke and guide each student on an individual path. Students are taught academics and life skills, and learn best through their own experiences. Learning will be backed with allowing students to question topics and ask questions when in doubt and be supplied with extra help. Every school should be focused on preparing students for the future.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For this reason, it is imperative that the principal know how to gather and evaluate data and can convey the importance of this to staff members. At AAHS, I encouraged teachers to gather and evaluate data to better instructional practices through PLC. As a department, we decided to analyze the NGSS science standards across all grade levels. I think that analyzing data would be more authentic if it were done for specific classes. This way, teachers would be able to analyze their own instructional decision-making and see how it correlates to student growth.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Educators were also hesitant to adapt to the online mode of delivery as they saw it as a threat to their academic freedom and struggled with training themselves to use technology as it drove them away from other demands such as advising, mentoring and researching (Bjarnason, 2003, pp.110-113). Based on the perspective of science and technology studies, online education has been described as being overly dependent on a simplistic understanding of the nature of technology. Hamilton and Friesen (2013) argue that online technology is limited to its arena of technical and scientific law, untarnished from the differences, interests and values that symbolizes the social world and is cast as being independent from its social…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If I deny technology I believe I will be denying a big part of what society is made up of and will limit their learning. In conclusion, I want to make a difference in the early years of a child’s life by knowing what my role as an educator is and through my beliefs and values. I want to seek an ongoing learning experiences with nurturing their strengths and weaknesses. I want them to feel safe, welcomed and appreciate learning through different learning styles. My goal is to not only be a teacher but a role model to my students by making mistakes and challenging…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This reminds the parents that if they introduce education and school in a positive manner, they have a better chance at striving for excellence. Parents need to realize their kids are not going to adapt to school immediately. Preparation needs to be a must before children start school. If not done, they may have a hard time adapting to a new scheduled environment away from the parents. They also need to know what is acceptable in school, such as, the rules, who the authority is, and so forth.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It should be considered useful. Another main point in this philosophy is that the focus should be on how to learn and not what to learn. So progressivism is where the child is the center of gravity of the classroom, this means that instead of focusing on the teacher or the curriculum the focus should be on the individual child’s needs. So if a student is struggling with one subject, but the teacher wants to move on to a different topic then that teacher will have to make sure the student understands the first topic before he/she can move on. I really believe this philosophy to be one that I will draw a lot of what I do in the classroom from.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics