Compare And Contrast Greek City And Sumerian City-State

Improved Essays
The Greek polis and the Sumerian city-state were both equally important to the civilization that it belonged to. Although they both were essentially the same thing, both differed in its operation depending on the civilization it belonged to. A Greek polis differs from a Sumerian city-state because a Sumerian city-state had ziggurats, Sumerian city-states relied heavily on agriculture, and Sumerian city-states differed in how they were run. Greek polis gradually advanced during a period known as the Dark Age. However, by the 8th century B.C.E. it became to be known as a distinct and important establishment in Greek society. Physically, a polis surrounded a city, town, or even a village and its encompassing countryside. The town, city, or village was the meeting point where people gathered for social, religious, or political affairs. In certain poleis, people met on an acropolis (a …show more content…
Along with Mesopotamia, they founded a bunch of cities that includes Uruk, Ur, Umma, Lagash, and Eridu. These same cities increased in size and began to exert their control over the encompassing countryside and city-states were established. One way in which the Sumerian city-state differed from a Greek polis is because Sumerian city-states had ziggurats. A ziggurat was a temple that was dedicated to the head god/goddess. The temple was also the economic and political core of the city-state. Sumerian city-states also relied heavily on agriculture along with some trade (Spielvogel 7). The Greeks relied a lot on trade. They traded supplies such as wine, pottery, and olive oil and they received items such as grain, metals, and fish in return (Spielvogel 56). In Sumerian city-states, priests had all of the power until kings took over and received all of the power (Spielvogel 7). Greek poleis had tyrants, who captured power through the use of force, whereas with Sumerian city-states, citizens believed that kings received their power from gods (Spielvogel

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The location of the cities was extremely important due to the availability of water. The need for water in agriculture caused the Sumerians to create irrigation systems necessary for a dependable food supply for the…

    • 841 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both Egypt and Mesopotamia were made up of communities of hunter-gatherers, which evolved into small sedentary tribes when they began to adopt the practice of agriculture and the domestication of animals. These small communities, believed in some form of afterlife, and created shrines to protect their dead. Egypt evolved almost directly from a state of society with no official laws, or government to a civilization ruled by a large government, without experiencing a city-state phase, unlike Mesopotamia. Mesopotamia developed a city-state basis of government just after the beginning of which, Mesopotamia, adopted more abstract symbols for writing. Both Egypt, and Mesopotamia, created temples to worship their gods, when priest-kings ruled.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The final days of democracy in Greece are in fact the story of how Athens lived its last century as an independent state. The moment of fall has to do with its time when it shined the most over Greece: at the height of power as leader of Athenian league and leader of Greek culture. The city-state pattern of Greece created a reality of competition, individuality and community centered exclusively around each political community. That is why Greece never reached a national consciousness, even that there were moments of unity when all Greeks acted as a single body (see Persian wars).…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The greatest achievements that the Greeks were proud of were the advances that they had in the philosophical and scientific thought. As the civilization of Greek evolved, there developments of city-states, that were known as Polis, that were popping up around the mainland of Greek. Their landscape helped in the development of these cities. Through their developed and independent and common governments, they built cultures, language, history, society and religion they build a civilized environment that was worth emulation. Due to the presence of great…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From tyrannical to democratic institutions, the manner in which a particular polis maintained order was very dynamic, and adaptations were frequently implemented in response to a changing social environment, often due to imbalance of power or matters of war. Also, each city state had a constitution specific to their geographic jurisdiction; unlike the United States’ use of federalism, Greek poleis were not united under a conventional set of guidelines, but were rather united through similar language and religious practices. The natural susceptibility of Greek government allowed for modifications to be made; either in a controlled manner of popular vote, or through the revolt of tyrannicides such as Hipparchus and Hippias. Typically, an oligarchy, aristocracy, or monarchy proved to be the most efficient practice and often led to massive productivity through construction of temples and other civic edifices, improvements in water supply and distribution, and other advancements which wholistically benefitted the polis. However, these systems tended to favor the wealthy while silencing the voice of average citizens, putting them in an economic disadvantage, and deteriorating their political efficacy; traditionally, tyranny would subsequently follow.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The rise of the early civilization in different regions is extremely diverse. Although some regions share similarities, they share many differentiations as well. From regions such as small farming settlements to full-blown states, there are many factors that can be compared as well as very different from one another. Specifically, Mesopotamia and Egypt share many components that are similar as well as different. Factors such as the environment, subsistence, trade/exchange, technology and social organization are major aspects that can be analyzed.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why Is Poleis Important

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Importance Of The Polis Most Greeks lived in city-states, called poleis. Poleis were a complex community that within them they had temples, theaters, an agora, and several other public buildings. Each poleis was involved in trade, foreign affairs, and had a type of government. Poleis were the center of life for Greeks in Athens and affected their ways of living. As stated, poleis are city-states; each polis is unique from the rest as evidenced by Sparta and Athens.…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Provide significant details about the author (120-1): Homer Style\5 conventions (121) - Philosophies (Women)-Homer’s philosophies towards women are that they are powerful and beautiful beings. Criticism-very little women were in the story even though he thought of them as strong beings. Literary Era\Age (103-113):____________ Information about the era: (Timeline\Fast Facts)-it was also known as the epic/golden age. Historical(Greeks)-the greeks had very powerful city states,one being sparta and the other athens.…

    • 113 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Classical Athens Vs Sparta

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In ancient Greek history, Greek civilization were divided and consisted of separate and independent city-states called the Polis. Through Polis, each state was allowed to form its own rules and govern its people. States such as Athens and Sparta evolved into Greek Polis, and they developed their own unique systems that significantly impacted Greek history. The Spartan developed into a military state, oligarchy, where they completely focus on military training and excellence. In contrast to Sparta, Athens formed a democracy which united the entire city and allowed all free male citizens to participate in state affairs.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Sumerians turned to trade in order for their civilization to thrive. The Sumerian people discovered that copper and tin together made bronze. This discovery made trade efficient because they could produce tools and weapons that were then sold to other nations. Not only were goods transported in the trade network but stories, writings, and art were also spread. Egypt was developing around the same time as Sumer in Mesopotamia around a river as well.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These chances led to alterations in Greek politics, by creating a political hierarchy necessary for social structure in Greek society. Political structure therefore played a large role in the Archaic Greece everyday life by leading society into prosperity throughout the Archaic Period. The political structure is described in concise detail in Pamela Bradley’s Ancient Greece: Using Evidence, in a modern written source which displays the general pattern of political development in Greek city-states in the archaic period. Political structure started with simple monarchy, which then became a struggle between king and nobles. The source continues to describe this leading to the development of aristocracy, where leaders of racial groups or tribes would rule the city-state.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Greed In Ancient Greece

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the famous words of one Allan Poe E., ‘the glory that was once Greece’ did not live for as long many would have expected it to. In fact, mighty Greece only survived for a short while and remained confined to a geographically minute area. As of the 5th Century BC, mighty Greece was primarily Athens. The state as a whole was Attica but Athens was its driving force at the time. To many, Athens was the “eye” of Greece based on it being a rich artistic hub and highly democratic (Brody et al., 2009).…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Monarchies and tyrants ran a lot of these cities. There was also a select few that used oligarchies. But the main form of politics was democracy. It was a widely regarded as the Greek’s greatest contribution to civilization. Then there was Egypt and their evolution throughout time.…

    • 1611 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sumerian Writing Essay

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The Sumerians had built an urbanized civilization in Mesopotamia (Mr. Giotto’s site). The Mesopotamia civilization was built around having a family and clans, specialized jobs for individuals, a hierarchy, artifacts, and culture based on upon the common factors of behavioral, language, and religion. The Mesopotamia land made it feasible for the Sumerians to make a civilization because it was flat, accessible to fresh water, rich soil, and agriculture (Mr. Giotto’s site). With the water and agriculture Sumerians were able to feed their animals and grow crops. It was a civilization were people worked specialized jobs such as a weaver, farmer, and pottery making.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Sumerians were ruled under a Theocracy which is when a priest portrays to be the god. Around 2100 BCE dynasties arose under the rule of Sargon I. Saron was the leader of Mesopotamia and the Sumerians. In summary, The Egyptians and Sumerians shared characteristics along with some noticeable differences. Both of these great civilizations had similarities in their religion and location, specific development in their political aspect, along with who their leaders were. The Egyptians and Sumerians are both polytheistic, established near rivers and ruled by some type of god.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays