Compare And Contrast Gandhi And Civil Disobedience

Improved Essays
The man of nonviolent resistance, Mohandas K. Gandhi once said “‘Civil disobedience, is the inherent right of a citizen.... Above all, [it] must have no ill will or hatred behind it” (Contemporary Heroes and Heroines). Meaning it is one’s free will that makes them able to be civil disobedient. This is shown through the character Antigone in the play Antigone by Sophocles. Also through one of history’s most influential people Mohandas K. Gandhi of India. His civil disobedience is shown through a speech called To Every Englishman in India by none other than himself, and a biography titled Mohandas Gandhi by the writers of Contemporary Heroes and Heroines. Many people refer to him as Mohandas Gandhi a.k.a Mahatma Gandhi, and more simply as Gandhi …show more content…
Antigone persists on having a proper burial for her brother, and ignores all the laws pertaining to Polyneices burial. Her act of civil disobedience does not affect her; to her it is just fulfilling an act worthy of anyone. Comparable to Antigone, Mohandas Gandhi wanted to bring the rights of every other race to equilibrium with the ones of the Hindu-Muslims in India, prompted him to initiate a movement. The movement that was initiated was a nationwide non-cooperation movement against the British Empire. It was launched in 1920, it “demonstrated to Britain that it was futile to rule a society where a collective unwillingness to be ruled existed” (Gandhi). This act headed by Gandhi is protecting the people of India’s human rights because they don’t want to be governed by an outside force, where they have the willpower to do it themselves. This movement came from Mahatma’s free will to protect his rights and those of his fellow Hindu-Muslims. Similarly, Antigone protects her deceased brother’s rights by burying him while the government denied it because he was a traitor. When the soldiers found the one who buried Polyneices, Antigone get into an argument over whether it was right for her to bury or not. But as they argue Antigone explains that he is given a proper burial traitor or not. Creon and Antigone argue that “There …show more content…
They both seek to do things that help influence themselves or the people around them through their choices they make along the way and how they decide to protect human rights. Antigone chooses to bury Polyneices and defend his human rights of a proper burial. Gandhi refuses to move which start his non violent revolts and protects his rights through a nonviolent movement. These two people from our world’s past, as well as many other influential people, have influenced this world for the better. Whether it be to stop racial discrimination or give someone all their rights that they are entitled to as a human

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The British government was well aware of the caste system that Gandhi supported; so the British took governmental actions against this system to ensure that the Indians won’t have a respected organization and for Gandhi to change the local community. However the strength of Mahatma Gandhi and the protesters that were against the British, brought attention to the society of the British and its army. The British happened to be annoyed due to the protesters and the Gandhi revolution and they successfully stopped the British from forcing Indians to have no freedom for themselves. Gandhi was able to manage India to be free from the British government and the Indian society supported Gandhi…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Antigone could be compared to the volunteers who buried the refugees because they knew it was right—she wanted to give her brother at least a simple burial. King Creon, representing the state, considered Polynices a non-citizen and did not allow for a burial, as he explains that “an enemy is always an enemy, even in death” (Antigone, 522). Both of these examples showcase the state exercising their right to choose who to provide aid to, but any moral person would be left uneasy at…

    • 1680 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to Creon he was doing what was pragmatic and fair, although Polyneicês was apart of his family. In order to set an example of a practical ruler, he did not reward the traitor with the same burial as a soldier who served his country. Creon’s son Haimon tries to explain to his father that everyone in the city says that what Antigone did was the right thing and that she should be honored instead of put to death. Haimon suggests that reasoning with Antigone might be the right thing to do. Creon rejects his suggestion and says to Haimon, “Do you want me to show myself weak before the people?…

    • 1478 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The excerpt from Gandhi’s writing expresses his respect and understanding of Thoreau’s philosophies. Like Thoreau, Gandhi believed that the government was not using their power to do what needed to be done, and that the government was corrupt. He started a movement to try and solve the issue. This movement stemmed from Thoreau’s civil disobedience, because he led a civil disobedience campaign, starting after the Transvaal government passed a decree about its Indian population. His passive resistance is a nonviolent noncooperative movement to solve the issue of discrimination in South America and to gain India’s independence from Great Britain.…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is also a social virtue to be cultivated like other virtues. Surely society is largely regulated by the expression of nonviolence in its mutual meanings. What I asked for is an extension of it on a larger, national and international scale” (p. 209). Mahatma Gandhi understood that it was easy to be nonviolent and non-confrontational when there were no issues going on, but when people were challenging those protesting, were they going to continue to stand their ground and remain nonviolent. He wanted to challenge people to remain true to the movement and see that more could be accomplished through peaceful protest as opposed to burning down buildings and destroying the places they lived.…

    • 1799 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Indians do not have to obey British’s laws and to not respect them. Thoreau guided his people to not pay British taxes, especially salt’s tax. The idea of “civil disobedience” belongs to Thoreau. Henry David Thoreau’s ideas had an important role of the India’s history. Mahatma Gandhi was inspired by him very much.…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is only in this way that we can hope to arrive at truth, and fulfill the great responsibility which we hold to God and our country” (Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death, P.1) Even thought, Henry was not in agreement with the British he tried to state his opinion in the most respectful way possible, he tried to make it seem like he was not condemned the British, but giving them an opportunity to realize how wrong they were ruling the colonies by stating the fact they were living different experiences, impossible to argue Henry knew more about the situation in the colonies that any British back in the British empire, Ignoring peaceful and coherent complaints was a mistake from them and they suffered the consequences. Henry wasn’t the only one making peaceful protests “Our forefathers… left their native land, to seek on these shores a residence for civil and religious freedom…Parliament adopted an insidious maneuver calculated to divide us, to establish a perpetual auction of taxations… we are reduced to the alternative of choosing an unconditional submission to the tyranny of irritated minister, or resistance by force… In our own native land, in defense of the freedom” (Dickson and Jefferson, P.1, P.3, P.4) With all the protest going on it surprises me that the British Empire never actually considered Colonist complaints, if they were willing to discuss, it…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Necessary Freedoms

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    You said: " But you want to get rid of the amendment that gives us our most basic and necessary freedoms to ensure tyranny never takes root here ever again. " News flash asshole, the first amendment does not give us our most basic and necessary freedoms to ensure tyranny never takes root again. Remember, our founding fathers escaped kings, dictators and RELIGIOUS leaders who thought they knew how we should live. That is why it is written in the first amendment that NO RELIGIOUS TEST SHALL BE GIVEN FOR GOVERMENT OFFICE. Get it dummy?…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this passage, Gandhi talks about what nonviolence means to him. He talks about how important it is for him and his people to fight with the method of nonviolence. He talks about how nonviolence is a part of his life and how important it is for his movements like satyagraha, noncooperation, and civil disobedience. He also says non violence is the only way India can gain freedom. I believe that he is right, India gained their freedom, because of Gandhi and his non-violence method of fighting.…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Antigone Vs Creon

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the story Antigone by Sophocles, Antigone and her sister Ismene had an idea of burying her brother because it was the right thing to do. There’s only one problem with this, it is illegal to bury one. Antigone and Ismene are arguing about what their plan will be, Imene is still unsure though. Ismene decides not to go along with the plan, but she wouldn’t tell anyone about Antigone’s doings. There is a new king, Creon is approached by leaders and they expressed that Creon was old and that a younger man should rule.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays