Compare And Contrast Disney And Cinderella

Good Essays
While reading the original version of Cinderella by Grimm’s, I noticed that Disney didn’t just remake the movie. They changed quite a few important aspects of the story and also removed some. The first difference I observed in Disney’s version of Cinderella is that Disney removed the death of Cinderella’s’ mother. In the original version Cinderella had a difficult time accepting the death of her mother. Disney’s version made Cinderella’s principal crisis as making it to the ball. An additional difference between the two films is that the original version by Grimm’s ending included the step sisters going blind due to the birds pecking out their eyes. Disney’s very popular version displayed the step sisters as ugly. The third difference is the …show more content…
Cinderella’s father took no action or initiative in changing how her step mother treated her because he also viewed Cinderella’s as just a servant. Though there was endless differences in the two stories, there was also some similarities. In both Disney and Grimm’s version of Cinderella, Cinderella had task that had to be completed before attending the ball. Another very obvious similarity is that both stories aim to teach the audience that being compassionate and kind is how a person should always act. (Grogaard, 4). While reading both stories it was obvious who the intended audience was for each author. Disney’s version of Cinderella, in my opinion, was made specifically for a younger audience. Disney did not include Cinderella’s mother’s death and the father’s harsh treatment towards Cinderella. Disney also made Cinderella complete her chores alone before attending the ball. My perspective is that this was Disney’s way of installing in children that the right thing to do in situations where you have to choose between work and play. Always be responsible and complete your work and then enjoy …show more content…
By the 1900s it was obvious that most of the audience watching Cinderella was a younger audience. So the cruel and violent scenes that the Grimm’s brother included in the original version needed to be reconstructed. One very important part of the story that had to be changed was the part where the bird pecked out the sisters part (Thorpe, 9). Disney definitely didn’t want children thinking birds would one day cause them to go blind! The overall effect of the original version was to create scenes that all ages could relate to. The older crowd knew that birds would never peck out their sister’s eyeballs for being mean. But the children who didn’t know that did learn that there’s consequences for being rude to your siblings or people in general. Both stories were made to teach the lesson “to always be generous and stay true to yourself” (Grogaard, 1). Overall, the Grimm’s brother just portrayed the message in a more harsh way. The original version of Cinderella offers reality to all audiences. The Grimm’s version displays real life scenarios that people of all ages could relate

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Fairy tales are full of fantasies of romance and magic, which in reality aren’t possible, however, one can dream. Walt Disney’s film Cinderella, and the Brothers Grimm story, Aschenputtel (Cinderella), both tell the tale of a young maiden who loses everything, except her dignity, which results in her sadly becoming a servant to her evil stepmother and sisters, but eventually she finds her prince charming, living happily ever after. Although these two stories seem alike, they are each told differently. The Brothers Grimm version, in which Walt Disney based his film off of, was mainly written for adults, due to certain gruesome scenes too harsh and graphic for children. As a result of this, changes were made by Disney, making the story friendlier…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Panttaja mentions that, “Cinderella’s mother is imagined as absent despite the fact that she plays a central part in the unfolding of Cinderella’s destiny” (286). The “Cinderella’s” traditional theme considers the main character’s ability to achieve success while still remaining humble when confronted with negative circumstances, but by Panttaja’s repetition of the word “mother,” she presents a new theme of a mother and daughter’s relationship. Panttaja does not choose other words such as “mom, parent, or child-bearer” because it diverts from the effect of the word “mother.” By frequently repeating the word, it sticks in the reader 's minds and compels them to listen…

    • 1037 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    From most of my critical texts I found that all of them shared the same opinion about these gender stereotypes, and how Disney has not taken a step forward with the error we live in to eliminate these stereotypes. Cinderella the hopeless house slave, Ariel the girl who gave up her voice for a man she had only seen once, and Belle the girl who stayed with her abusive partner out of fear. Disney has created films that represent woman as weak, male dependant, and uneducated. Being a woman in society you should be strong, independent, and intelligent three things that according to Disney films aren 't relevant in the life if a female. Disney’s target audience appeals to the ages of four to eleven.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cinderella 's dad asked her stepsisters and Cinderella if they liked anything from the fair Cinderella replied with the choice of a tree branch which is truly humbling and strange of her to ask for a twig and that truly shows how close she is to nature and how she is not superficial and materialistic like her stepsisters. Therefore, her decision of the tree branch was a major turning point for Cinderella and that humble decision opened a lot of possibilities for her life and future. On the contrary, her stepsisters asked for dresses and jewels. All they asked for was nothing but superficial and materialistic objects. Thus, they got what they asked for, but did not deserve the gifts.…

    • 1446 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As the second one tries it on and it does not fit the mother once again hands her the knife and tells her to cut off her heal. So she did and once again the price knew it wasn her she he took her back. Cinderella's father did not want her to try on the shoe but the prince demanded that she did, but before she could the stepmother broke the slipper. Cinderella had the other shoe and once the prince knew it was her they left and lived happily ever after. While some similarities between Disney's Cinderella and Grimm's Cinderella are evident, the differences are salient.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, one may argue that in the Disney Film adaptation of Snow White the stepmother dies as well and therefore why is there a difference in the level of violence. This has to do with the sequence that this event occurs in comparison to the Grimms version of Snow White. In the Grimms version of Snow White it 's the last image the reader gets, while in contrast the last image in Disney’s adaptation is Snow Whites beautiful castle. This is because in the film Disney decides to suggest the stepmother’s death, but never implicitly shows her dead. This illustrates Zipes point that Disney and others tended to root for the happy ending opposed to the one described in many fairy…

    • 1649 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this we see a similarity to the way that modern society still see’s women as always having to be a certain way to “get a guy”. Its also in this that we see how Cinderella is not the main purpose of the ball nor was she ever meant to be however she turns out to be. We see the way that the stepmother makes Cinderella pick all the lentils out of the cinders and how Cinderella has the assistance of the dove and her friends, very important characters for the future. Sexton presents this along with the causal idea of what happens next. After Cinderella has help from the dove and his friends get all the lentils out of the ash, the step-mother still denies Cinderella her permission to go to the ball, “No, Cinderella, said the stepmother, / you have no clothes and cannot dance.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When talking about the similarities and differences between Disney princesses and their original Brothers Grimm tales, one might think Disney just took the exact stories, added a song or two, and made a cartoon movie out of it. As a whole, Disney princesses are portrayed as beautiful, young women that always find their perfect man, solve all of their problems, and live happily ever after. On the other hand, the Brother’s Grimm fairy tale stories are far from this. The folk stories that the brothers collected were passed down from generation to generation; the brothers wanted to save the stories from extinction and created a storybook titled, Nursery and Household Tales. Despite the name, these stories were not intended for children (Myint).…

    • 1867 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Rapunzel is gullible and believes everything her mother tells her until a strange man appears in her tower. She has had no contact with the world so the fact that she is able to defend herself gives her the impression that she is ready for the outside world. When being told a story, children probably do not think how realistic they could be. It is when children are older that they start to realize that the world is not perfect. This is also apparent in Tangled where everything is going fine until she gets older and becomes…

    • 1982 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cinderella Analysis

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages

    When Cullen explains D’Aulnoy’s version of Cinderella, she says, “When their parents abandon Finette and her sisters, she engineers daring escapes for all three. They plot against her, but Finette remains loyal. With a God Mothers help she finds some magnificent clothing and triumphs at the ball.” (Cullen 320) When someone reads D’Aulnoys version of Cinderella and “Rapunzel” these two quotes prove that in each fairy tale somebody always comes and rescues the princess, which is something the readers need. Readers also need to feel that the evil will receive their much-deserved fate. Fairy tales are good because the protagonist is always rewarded and the evil is always defeated.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays