Comparative Analysis Of The Three Renaissance Masterpieces

Great Essays
Comparative Analysis on Three Italian Renaissance Masterpieces The Renaissance started from the fourteenth century and lasted in 16th century when Michelangelo died. In this era, there where several technical innovations such as the invention of oil painting, the use of Chiaroscuro, and the use of perspectives in paintings. Leonardo da Vinci, Michelangelo, and Raphael are the so called “the three giants” who were very influential and well known for their works. Some of the well known features of renaissance art was the use of linear perspective, aerial perspective, sfumato, and chiaroscuro. In this paper, I will evaluate three art works from Masaccio, Botticelli, and Leonardo da Vinci and describe the art work in detail. Then will compare …show more content…
The “Holy Trinity”, “Birth of Venus”, and “Mona Lisa” all exemplifies the Renaissance period and each have a distinguished style and look in the work. They all have some similarities and differences in their style and each fits in a category that has been already examined. They also seem to have an implied message in the works; religious, mythological, and reflectiveness of beauty. 
 Masaccio was one of the pioneers in the creation of Renaissance art and has greatly influenced the art of painting in this era. One of his famous art works, the “Holy Trinity with the Virgin, St John and donors” has been said that it was the very first example of the use of the perspective in the whole history of Western art (In Italy, 2016). The “Holy Trinity” is a religious fresco painting with image of Jesus Christ being crucified. There are in total six figures in the painting and a skeleton. Each figures are outlined and are on a different level. They are all facing towards the crucified Christ and seems to be mourning. The ones with a gold halo are likely to be representing someone with close relations to the religion, or it could be representation of angels. Also the skeleton is likely there to show …show more content…
He had a lot of capabilities including engineering, natural science, music, and art (Ficher, 2016). Fischer also praises him that “If the Italians of the High Renaissance could have nominated a counterpart to Classical Greek’s four-square man, it would have been Leonardo da Vinci” (2016). His famous portrait work, “Mona Lisa” exemplifies the use of sfumato. Mona Lisa is an oil painting on a wooden panel. Like what most portrait paintings looks, there is only one figure in the picture. Unlike past art works, this painting does not have a outline to the figure. Leonardo da Vinci uses a technic called sfumato and instead of outlining, he used the contrast of light and shadow. This makes the painting seem more life like and realistic. The location of the back ground is said to be unknown even today and the identity of Mona Lisa is also said to be a mystery according to Ficher and on numerous articles and websites (2016). Though making the furthest misty and foggy, it gives depth to the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Renaissance is among the most prominent and influential historical time periods in all of art history. Derived the from the French term for “rebirth,” the Renaissance was a renewed interest in the ideas, culture, forms and perspectives of the ancient civilizations of Greek and Rome. As the Renaissance flourished in different regions of Europe, the social, political, and cultural factors of the regions culminated in discrete styles. Although there were similar overarching principles, there were characteristics of the art of the Northern Renaissance and the Southern Renaissance that were unique to each area.…

    • 1657 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The scene of Renaissance art is not exactly how many paint it today. While during the fifteenth century Renaissance a plethora of art as well as artists were created, the concept of ‘artistry’ was completely foreign. Today, when we see Botticelli’s “The Birth of Venus” and Michelangelo’s statue of David, we identify both as art and comparably we recognize the beauty of the art forms that they are. However, during the Renaissance, Botticelli, a painter, and Michelangelo, a sculptor, would have been recognized as having two very distinct professions and comparison of the two would be nonexistent. Today, artists are the outsiders of society who thrive in isolation, but in the Renaissance they were very present participants in society. These men whom we now consider artists would have been called craftsmen in their time. What we now view as a calling was simply a profession. Although the Renaissance art we see today in the churches, streets, and museums of Italian cities is without a doubt exquisite art, the philosophy of how these pieces were created is not the same as how art is done or respected…

    • 967 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The religious scenes became more realistic and proportioned. The anatomy of the people within the paintings and sculptures of Italian Renaissance work appear scientifically correct and the scenes of the paintings have depth. Italian Renaissance artists used linear or one-point perspective to render proportioned work. An example is Holy Trinity and Tribute Money by Masaccio. In Masaccio’s work, there are vanishing points, orthogonals, a horizon lines, and foreshortening and atmosphere perspective used to give the viewer a realistic idea of the…

    • 803 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Italy is often known as the birthplace of the Renaissance, a time of great achievement in all aspects of the Modern Age. Specifically the art during this time uniquely represented this era. In fact, Renaissance is majorly represented through its magnificent art. Architecture, sculpture and painting were the leading categories for all the Renaissance artists. The art during this time shared some similar qualities. For example, no matter what the category of art, there was heavy stress on the right proportion, utter balance and complete harmony in the artwork. In specific, the all around “Renaissance Man”, Leonardo Da Vinci will be discussed in terms of his artwork and numerous skills during this time period.…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From the Early Renaissance to the culmination of the High Renaissance art goes through a great evolution in techniques and in perception. Light and shadow are more often exemplified within the artworks of this era and it also truly did bring about a realistic depiction of life within art. Along with that there is the great advances in perception due to the popular use of linear perspective, which gave a genuine depth and space to artworks of this time. Due to the great gains and expansions of ideas within art techniques during this time, artist for generations owe a great deal to the many “masters” throughout the Renaissance…

    • 1011 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Therefore, people in Europe at that time were able to have their own thoughts in order to express themselves. Since people had their own individual ideas about the world, new concepts were established. The Madonna Enthroned Between Two Angels by Duccio di Buoninsegna showed Mother Mary on a throne with baby Jesus. However, the painting resembled more as a two-dimensional image if compared to the Mona Lisa, which was painted by Leonardo da Vinci during the Renaissance. Mona Lisa, a beautiful work of art that was still popular in modern days, showed many details and emotions in it. In addition to that, The Madonna was very religious, and it was quite generalized. The Mona Lisa was a one-of-a-kind artwork and a worldly figure. During the Renaissance, humans became more aware of possibilities that they could do with art. With that ability, people became more creative and focused more on details and emotions that their arts portrayed. Mainly because of the movement called humanism, which praised the beauty and intelligence of the individual, people were able to understand the importance of humans, rather than supernatural matters. Most people stopped doing religious drawings to having their minds flow and creating one’s unique work. As a result, portraits and landscapes from around 1300s to the modern time had become more realistic than before 1300s with the help of increasing individualism in the…

    • 1168 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Painted in the late thirteenth century the Virgin and Child with Two Angels, portrayed through the magnificent art work of Deodato Orlandi, is truly a magnificent piece that reveals a great deal about the Christ child and the Virgin Mary. The method by which the artist depicted the image, the meaning behind the painting, and the history of the painter are all critical aspects to consider when attempting to gain a full understanding of a piece of artwork. There are hundreds of techniques used to create an image, and thousands of styles specific to each artist, making each piece of art extremely unique. Additionally, the meaning behind each picture as another layer of individuality to each masterpiece. There is a famous quote that says,…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Renaissance Dbq

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Renaissance artists expressed their thoughts about human nature through detailed paintings. “The [clearest] evidence of the break with medieval culture comes from the visual arts” (Doc A). Comparing the art of the Madonna from the middle ages to the Renaissance painting of the Mona Lisa. Change in time is demonstrated by Leonardo da Vinci exceptionally detailed art,…

    • 699 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the early 1500s, Pope Julius II ordered an artist by the name of Raphael to create one of the world’s most advanced artistic pieces of its time. Raphael’s “School of Athens” (among many others) establishes a new tone for Renaissance artists. As new color pallets arose and depth perception began to develop, Renaissance art began to parallel with its historical context through its complex societal concepts and profound artistic representations.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Art is influenced by everything around it, it comes as a direct result of the cultural sphere it occurs within. The Italian group of painters known as the Macchiaioli are no different from this rule, during the nineteenth-century they took outside influences to create a new esthetic that reflected their personal ideals. Although how independently this new esthetic came about, and who influenced them directly can varied. Depending on the point of view of the author writing on the Macchiaioli, there can be a very large difference of opinion. The influence of outside sources is agued in four different ways by the authors Norma Broude, Nancy Troyer and Anna Cavina. Each have a different way to examine the same group of Italian artists, although…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This painting shows a poised woman with her mysterious smile which was what made this painting famous. The landscape had some greenery, but the plants and trees were blurred focusing on the woman in the picture (Leonardo da Vinci, Document 5). The famous Leonardo da Vinci painted this masterpiece, that is known today as the Mona Lisa. Painted in 1503, Leonardo da Vinci was a Renaissance artist in Italy. His painting of the Mona Lisa was really lionized and showcased a variety of art techniques used in the Renaissance. From the art styles and techniques used in the Renaissance, it showed significant improvement in technique for painting. Unlike older techniques such as the Middle Ages, the techniques used were very displeasing to the eye. The art style used in this piece was a vanishing point, the pyramid shape of the human figure, better proportions, chiaroscuro, the idea is highly secular, and that it looked more realistic. From the usage of different techniques and a different display of meaning in the arts, showcases that the arts can be used for art and for enjoyment. The image depicts a "Zodiac Man" which shows twelve different signs that are branching off the human's body. Ten of them are branching out of the human, while the other two were by the human. German astronomer Johann Regiomontanus shows a "Zodiac Man" and the twelve constellations and how each of the…

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    It is a piece “at the Church of Santissima Annunziata”(Gardner 630).Created in 1505, it showcases the Virgin Mary, a figure of great focus with her eye-catching red dress, dark blue robe with gold embroidery, and her dainty blonde hair up in a fashionable updo. Even though her appearance seems quite austere, she seems to be invoking an atmosphere of beauty and grace and she kneels to witness the important interaction between Saint John and Jesus Christ as small infants. Saint John and Jesus Christ are mischievously playing around with Saint’ John’s cross-shaped staff as if they don’t realize the significance of such a religious icon. Only the Virgin Mary is suspected to know the repercussions of such a feat as she stares at the two individuals in such a melancholy facial expression. She seems to be the only person of intuition. Both infants are nude, but Saint John adorns a brown cloth wrapped around his pudgy body. All figures in the painting have faint golden halos around their heads, signifying their holiness. While these figures take up space in the foreground in a pyramidal composition, greenery surrounds them in the background. The figures are enveloped in a state of utter nature-plants spurting off the ground, the fluffy trees employed in the distance, the grassy hills, so much so that the small town pictured in the background seems to have green hues. The sky in the background takes on a muted blue-grayish tonality with faded white clouds. To match the holiness of these important religious figures, the background seems to act to the illusion of a beautiful landscape, a pastoral scene of “Eden” to suit. The lines are more sharper in comparison to Da Vinci’s atmospheric painting, and so a more crisp centerfold focus…

    • 1276 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Throughout the history of art, the human body has intrigued artist to create pieces that captivate audiences from all over the world. The human body is still till this day used as a muse to create art, especially the body of a women though controversial. In today’s society it is rarely viewed to use the naked body as a piece of art, some know how to create art but others seek only attention. During the beginning of the sixteenth century was when Michelangelo created art in a format that was expressive and held to its platform of divine work. Throughout this essay we will be talking about the works of Michelangelo David and Jan Van Eyck the Arnolfini Wedding. We will explore the detail the summary and techniques at the used throughout the early Renaissance from the use of paints to the use of marble.…

    • 1737 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The high alter piece of Virgin and Child Enthroned by Cimabue was painted for the church of Santa Trinita in Florence (M. Stokstad, 536). It was 12 feet tall, painted with tempera, along with gold thin lines throughout the painting that show great importance. The virgin Mary holds the child on a giant throne that is surrounded by angels. Mary, Jesus and the angels have golden painted light behind their heads which resembles their halos. This shows how sacred and holy these individuals are in the painting. Beneath Mary and Jesus in these arch ways are the four Hebrew prophets, they have expressions of concern and wonder. Cimabue paints Mary’s clothing is shown as draping over her by…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Mixing the colors of Titian and sketches of the great Michelangelo, Tintoretto brought an awe inspiring new air to the art of the Renaissance with his innovative ideas combined with the works of older Renaissance masters. He created many works over the course of his lifetime, and through those works Tintoretto portrayed some of the most prominent themes in the fine arts of the Renaissance. With outstanding contrast and color usage mixed with an amazing skill in creating accurate and realistic figures, he was a very successful painter of his time. His skill is shown especially in his later work, The Last Supper, and in the massive Paradise. Tintoretto’s use of steep perspective and dramatic lighting highlight the realism and anatomy in his…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays