Common Themes In Hamlet And Judith Guest's Ordinary People

Decent Essays
Does age really matter? Many students, and even adults of the 21st century argue that there is no meaning behind studying books and plays dating back to the 1500’s, because the time during which they were written, is nothing like life as they know it. However, many of the themes, problems and struggles in plays and books of the renaissance era share a plethora of commonalities with the challenges and struggles today’s society faces. There are many common themes between Shakespeare’s play Hamlet and Judith Guest’s novel Ordinary People. The three major themes that the two literary works share in common are mental health, fate versus responsibility and family and a sense of belonging. The first theme that is prominent throughout both pieces is …show more content…
It is present commonly throughout the two pieces and it influences both plots massively. In Hamlet, Hamlet feigns madness after his father’s death and convinces his family and friends that he is truly mad in order to fulfill his responsibility to avenge his father’s death. By doing so, Hamlet was able to create himself a clear path to reach avengement without many obstacles interfering. Hamlet’s family frowned upon his madness and they tried to cheer him up through several methods none of which worked. Ultimately, they believed that the best way to deal with his madness would be to send him off to England to be killed. In the end, Hamlet’s antic disposition allowed him to avenge his father’s death which also lead him to his own death. In contrast, In Ordinary People, Conrad was truly in a poor mental state and he suffered from severe depression. His family also recognized that he was suffering from mental illness but their …show more content…
In both literary pieces, the protagonists’ families were torn apart by tragedy and by the end both families fell apart. In Hamlet, the Hamlet family was destroyed by the murder of King Hamlet. King Hamlet was a vital part of Hamlet’s life and he was looked up to dearly by Hamlet. When Hamlet learned of Claudius’s crime against his father, Hamlet was torn because he realized that he could no longer trust anyone in his own family and he lost his sense of belonging. Another reason for Hamlets loss of sense of belonging is the fact that neither his family nor friends offered him support through his darkest times. Although Hamlet was feigning madness, he was still unpleasantly surprised at the superficiality of those around him. Since no one wanted to help him other than Horatio, he had no true family and he didn’t belong anywhere or with anyone. The Jarretts from Ordinary People were also torn apart by a tragedy, but theirs was of natural causes. Due to the fact that Conrad idolized his older brother Buck, he was devastated by his death and thus, Conrad fell into a deep depression. Conrad was neglected by his own mother because Beth didn’t want to associate herself with anyone who was depressed because she claimed that it made her look bad. Although Conrad’s father really wanted to help him through his tunnel of darkness, he couldn’t do much because he

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Hamlet Essay In the play Hamlet, written by William Shakespeare, the main character, Hamlet, plans for revenge against the man that murdered his father and married his mother. Hamlet’s insanity, suicidal thoughts, and sarcastic comments are what creates his character and pushes his family and friends to spy on him. As Hamlet attempts to kill Claudius for the murder of his father, his actions indirectly lead to the deaths of his friends and family, including his own. Hamlet does not feel remorse or guilt for his actions and feels like he is justified for what he does. Shakespeare uses many literary devices, such as sarcasm, puns, soliloquies, and dramatic irony to develop Hamlet’s character and his need for revenge.…

    • 1428 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His mother alienates him for the reason that he ruined her reputation and because she has always cared less about him. Conrad’s friends isolate him after his return from the hospital because he is a “flake”. His brothers death and his suicide attempt have caused him to…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There is plenty of evidence provided in the play to show that Hamlet experiences all of these things after his initial meeting with the specter of his father all the way up until his own death, and there is similar evidence in Ophelia that shows her madness is similar to his own madness, proving that Hamlet is mad after all. Beginning with his depression, regarded as a mental illness, he grieves for the loss of his father and suffers from melancholy. Despite swearing that what he’d seen was real, no one else can interact with this ghost but him, providing evidence of Hamlet’s hallucinations. Following the news of the murder of his father, he falls into paranoia wondering if what he’d seen was real, but soon becomes suspicious of everyone else and becomes fixated on revenge. Additionally, he experiences on-and-off depression, falling into melancholic moods periodically throughout the play, and is unable to express his grief coherently.…

    • 1869 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Polonius did everything to keep them apart, which eventually drove them both insane. The murder of Polonius not only sparked anger in the King, it sparked anger in Laertes, Polonius’s son. This specific scene of violence contributes to the overall meaning of this play by showcasing one of Hamlet’s diverse emotions. The lack of trust and constant paranoia controls Hamlet’s ability to think and act sanely. After Polonius is killed by Hamlet, his mother is quick to ask why he would commit such a sin.…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The former King is filling him with thoughts of betrayal by his own family. When he reveals the truth behind his death, he plants in Hamlet’s head the idea of betrayal which is the beginning of Hamlet’s madness. Although a father should guide his son in a positive direction, Old King Hamlet actually does the opposite. He explains to Hamlet that his own brother was the sole killer by poisoning him. He asks Hamlet to “revenge his foul and most unnatural murder” (Act.1 Scene.5 Line.31).…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Conscience In Hamlet

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The play “Hamlet” written by William Shakespeare is full of characters showing their conscience getting the best of them and losing their conscience as well. From Hamlet to Claudius and even Laertes, all showing some form of conscience and how they use or lose it throughout the play. In my opinion Hamlet shows the most use of his conscience but eventually, because of all the events that occurred throughout the play, loses his conscience to execute his goal that was set by the ghost of his father. At the beginning of the play, Hamlet meets the ghost of his father, the ghost tells Hamlet his father was murdered and needs to seek revenge upon Claudius for the murder. However, Hamlet doesn't know if the ghost is really that of his father thus delays…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Oedipus Complex In Hamlet

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Mostly Polonius’ death scene suggests that he is only infuriated with the person who killed his father and his thirst to take revenge against his uncle is due to his broken heartedness from his loss and mother’s ignorance of the situation. Depending on which scene is being analysed, the audience can argue whether or not Hamlet’s actions were based solely on attraction or his loss of his father and mother’s…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His lack of action proves hazardous to his own well being as well as others since several characters die because he failed to rid himself of his task sooner. This resentment that soon harbors Hamlet’s soul is directed towards his uncle, his mother, and most importantly, himself. In his most passionate soliloquies, Hamlet seems to be deeply disturbed as he sees the only thing lacking in his ability to kill the King is a worthy man able to handle the pressure associated with avenging his father’s honor; Self-deprecation and conflicting ideas are results of his compiled frustrations with the world and those are a part of his life. Shakespeare uses the themes of disorder, revenge, and motifs of decay and nature in Hamlet’s four soliloquies to help convey that Hamlet is not insane, but his conflicted nature and suffering are huge factors of his…

    • 1593 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    From the moment that Aanakwad fell in love with the other man, the grandfather feared her and became very bitter towards her. “For he was afraid of his wife’s bad temper, and it was he who roused Aanakwad into anger by the sheer fact that he was himself and not the other.” No matter how much the grandfather tried, he could not recapture her love and because of that he lost respect for her. Despite the fact that the grandfather loved her he had to admit that their life together was no longer a happy one. Having to say goodbye to Aanakwad was not an easy thing for the grandfather and he was not satisfied with the outcome, therefore he held a grudge against Aanakwad. For many people, it is easy to place the blame on someone when they are strongly disliked.…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Indeed, Gregor 's family has isolated him in a way that he had no contact with his family. Not only that but the lack of communication Gregor was experiencing also contributed to his isolation. The fact that he could not talk let him no choice but to listen to everything his family was saying about him. This loneliness made him realized how unfaithful his family was. After a certain time, Gregor " would be not at all in a frame of mind to look after his family; instead, he was filled with rage at how poorly he was attended to [..]" (p.91) Taking in consideration that Gregor is dreaming, the reader can understand that the animal state made Gregor realized how he did not want to provide for his family anymore.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics