Commentary On The Book 'Just Like Us' By Helen Thorpe

Improved Essays
The theme of illegal status hovered over a subsequent fragment of the population in the US, who are living in the country and deprived of all legal rights that are bestowed to legal residents. In her book “just like us”, Helen Thorpe delves in depth into the matter by analyzing the lives of four girls - Marisela Benavidez, Yadira Vargas, Clara Luz and Elissa Ramirez- who are bound by the same background, age, and perspective, trying to live the American dream as Mexican-Americans girls. Thorpe emphasizes the legal status of the four girls and analyzes how that influences their lives regarding opportunities, goals, and perspective. Among the four girls, Yadira and Marisela are the ones lacking proper documentation. The two girls face many issues …show more content…
The girls were in their senior year of High school and shared the same background; all of them are Mexican Americans, but only two of them had proper documentations. A couple of months before the prom night all the four girls had ambitious aspirations for a university education, and a career that matches their ambitions. Growing up in Denver which, at that time, became a traditionally home for many Latinos, all the four girls were together since Middle school through high school. Their senior year was a critical stage of their lives as they were preparing to apply to university, but only two of them could get a scholarship to pursue their dreams. ‘’Just Like Us’’ starts by describing the prom night as the four girls were making their preparation for the night party. Afterward, all the four girls without exception could make it into college. Marisela and Yadira succeeded to attend Denver University through a private donor named Cinthia Poundstone. At the time goes by, the two illegal girls seemed to struggle to adapt to their new school where whites were the dominant component. In the end, all of them succeeded to graduate, but the matters of illegal status remained unsolvable for the two undocumented …show more content…
While they were preparing for their senior prom, the excitement had consumed them and overshadowed the complication they would face when applying for college. Thorpe describes how the four girls were on the same path and were so close to each other over the years: “all the girls had forged their bonds from myriad nights like this-from years of secrets, squabbles, and private jokes, years of outmaneuvering their Mexican parents, years of figuring out adulthood and America” (Thorpe 19). The day before the prom night showed how close they are; the day after, in contrast, left them to face their destinies in which their heritage and their legal status play a crucial part. The two undocumented girls on that night didn’t give too much attention to their eminent problems and sought that night as a short recreation: “the prom had served as a temporary distraction” (Thorpe 19). At this very night, the girls enjoyed their graduation and had fun and everything as they danced laughed and had a perfect time as regular high school student do. But then they started to discuss their future and their plan for college. At that crucial moment, the two undocumented girls start over again to be preoccupied with their legal handicap: “but once it was

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    My sister, Amber, conceived my nephew, Trey, at 16 during her sophomore year, resulting in her flunking out of high school, therefore, I did not have anyone to forewarn me or even give me a fairytale. At the end of my first semester of high school, she scored a job at La Petite Day Care as a long term sub. Amber came home every day with exhilarant stories about her favorite student, Sally.…

    • 863 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Things seemed to be going my way; I also made it on the Varsity Cheerleading team; both my sisters were extremely proud of me. During that school year, my class voted me into student council for the middle school. When freshman year rolled around I was nervous because it was a huge change from middle school. I luckily had both my sisters to help me through the first couple weeks. I gained more friends and I was overjoyed that I could go to an actual high school dance.…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They went through a lot of chaos during the time they dated, but they still managed to hold on to each other. Their relationship status was very complicated, but they decided to put their hard feelings to the side for a phenomenal prom night. While she thought that she was about to experience the greatest night of her life, she was taught the biggest life lesson by the one she loved most. On April 22,2016, Sarah started to prepare for her fairy tale night. She informed Lawrence that she was going to attend prom with her friends.…

    • 1031 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Adrianna Hernandez is a kind, hilarious sophomore at Chino Hills High School. She is known to many as a loveable goofball. Adrianna hopes to pass that persona on to her two younger sisters who are seven years old and one year old, or at least the ability to not care what other people think and to be their true selves. Adrianna has been finding out who her true self is during her time in high school. A big part of that has been discovering and continuing to participate in the Theatre program at CHHS.…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the party, she talks to the whole class. She talks about how she wants to have a baby the following year and that she would need a full time job if she wanted to go through with her plan (she didn’t have a full time job at NAMS). As a result, she says that this would be her last year with us if they didn't offer her a full time job. That being said, she picks up a stack of papers from her desk in the corner of the room, she says they are awards for students who did good this year, everyone got one. We all had some laughs as some of them were funny and some that were meaningful.…

    • 943 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    She was a student at Kang Won-rae Dance School and learned dancing from Clon. She traveled four hours to Seoul every weekend to perform as a backup dancer for singers such as Park Mi-kyung (ko) and Hong Kyung-min. Her parents were originally against her working in the entertainment industry, but changed their minds when they saw how much Yezi was advancing, and she moved to Seoul in her second year of middle school. Yezi auditioned at LOEN Entertainment after one of their trainees saw her videos posted on Cyworld. The videos were the two most popular on the social network at the time, and showed Yezi singing and dancing.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Wendy then decided to attend Vanderbilt University because it offered a high ranking nursing program, and it was close to home. At eighteen years old, 1980, Wendy began her first year of college. The next four years went by in a flash. Her freshman year, she worked harder than she ever had in her life. She spent hours on end studying.…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the days leading up to prom, Andy asks Rachel to go with him: “Rachel is one of the war ninth-graders invited to go to the Senior Prom; her social stock has soared.” (176). Rachel finds security in being with Andy. She has a higher social rating, more people know who she is and she has a boyfriend. Rachel hangs out with the foreign exchange students and him in front of everyone, and she loves the…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gavriel M. Cruz Dfm6 Have you ever been in a one mythical promenade? There will never be as haunting as that night. It’s every high school teens’ dream to be on a prom and we surely made that day wonderful. Whatever we did, we made sure that it’ll make us happy. For one evening; we were teenagers that lived like were going to die tomorrow, and most of all; we enjoyed everything that we can never do again after we graduated.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So, my junior year when the time came to sign up, I didn’t even hesitate! I had never even seen a Distinguished Young Women program before, but it surely wasn’t just the happy, laughing candid photos I had seen on Instagram. I stressed, cried, sweat, and stressed some more for the weeks leading up to the program. But, by some miracle, I went home with a medallion, flowers, and enough scholarships to pay for this year that night. So began the preparation for the state wide competition.…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics