Columbus Day Debate Summary

Improved Essays
when historically he has been known to be problematic. In his conclusion, he urges teachers to read more historically-accurate, yet still age-appropriate texts to their students. J. H. Bickford III is an assistant professor at Eastern Illinois University. He has a Ph.D in social studies education and a B.A in history, making him a credible source when it comes to historical misrepresentations in children’s literature. In the context of the Columbus Day vs. Indigenous People’s Day debate, this study is a great asset, as it shows that America’s idolatrous view of Christopher Columbus likely begins at a young age.

ANGLIS, JACLYN. “#NotYourCostume, #NotYourMascot and #NotHappy: New Generation of
Native American Activists Use Social Media to
…show more content…
Moya-Smith discusses how Native Americans are often reduced to symbols and stereotypes, and how it has affected him throughout childhood. Unlike the Native American activists before him, Moya-Smith turns to the media instead of protest when trying to make a difference. He started a series of Twitter hashtags to use around the autumn months (when he believes cultural appropriation is at an all time high due to Halloween costumes and eurocentric Thanksgiving narratives) such as #NotYourCostume, #NotYourMascot, and #ColumbusDay. In his Columbus Day tweet, he writes “We, Native Americans, are not opposed to Italian American pride. We’re opposed to a fed. holiday named for a murdering thief”. Moya-Smith’s words are poignant, especially in regard to the name change debate, because they come from someone who has been directly impacted by racism and …show more content…
The University of Utah’s student government teamed up with the Inter-Tribal Student Association to draft a bill to present to the Utah State Legislator, working with Natives and non-Natives alike. Their efforts drew in activist groups and supportive college students across the country who showed up for the hearing and packed city hall. However, when the bill came to the Senate, it failed due to what the authors see as “racially charged opposition”. On a note of optimism, they also note that the bill, although defeated, brought many students together and “laid down the groundwork for future legislation regarding Indigenous Peoples’

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Critical Analysis: Charles C. Mann wrote 1491: New Revelations of the Americas before Columbus after finding inaccuracies in his high school textbook. The inaccuracies within prompted him to reexamine contemporary historical beliefs. Mann’s 1491 is a social demonstration, utilizing modern theories to explain pre-Columbian societies. Furthermore, 1491 is a journalistic representation of Mesoamerica and the Aztecs, Inka, Maya, and other Inuit communities of the Americas.…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Can history books be trusted? Many textbooks just skim the surface or contain other bias. Relying on one source of information can be risky. The story of Christopher Columbus is one specific example Recent evidence of the use of violence and slavery, the forced conversion of native peoples to Christianity, and the introduction of a host of new diseases proves that Columbus should not be celebrated.…

    • 201 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Columbus Day Dbq

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Every year kids around our nation take off from school on October 10th, Columbus Day. In parallel with this annual vacation day for most in the United States, children are also taught about a heroic explorer, who courageously stood up for his belief, that the world was round, rather than flat, by asking many monarchs for the opportunity to prove his belief by finding a shortcut to the Indies, and then proceeded to discover the Americas. Yes, children nationwide are captivated by the story of this brave explorer, Christopher Columbus, who was responsible for finding their continent, and for giving them a day off. However, one key part of the voyage and adventures of Christopher Columbus is left out when children learn about him, namely that…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It's that time of year again; pumpkin spice lattes, Halloween decorations, and the national recognition of a man responsible for mass murder, pillaging, and enslavement. It's no secret that Christopher Columbus was a horrible man, or that he didn't even "discover the new world", yet every year on October 12, he is recognized for his "accomplishment". It seems as though more and more people are unwilling to celebrate Columbus, even going so far as to put an axe in the head of his statue. While there has been opposition of Columbus Day for many years, there is only a handful of cities that refuse to recognize it.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that Europe is credited for discovering a new world for several reasons. Although Columbus wasn’t the first European explorer to reach America, his expeditions enabled the first meaningful contact of Europeans with America. This contact ushered in a period of ventures and the colonization of lands that ended up lasting for hundreds of years. That said, Europe had a profound impact in the modern development of the Western society. Not surprising, Christopher Columbus played a strong role in this accomplishment, and also for the massive dispersal of the Christianity.…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Have you ever wondered who Christopher Columbus was before he discovered the Americas? As a young boy, Columbus always wanted to sail. This fueled his passion to attempt and sail around the world. He worked fervently and ceaselessly to gather support and funds for his voyage. Christopher Columbus had worked his entire life on a journey that he didn’t know would change the world.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Compare and Contrast In the United States the second Monday of October is a “Holiday”. The holiday is Christopher Columbus Day, many schools are closed, offices, and government buildings. Some people agree and disagree about whether he deserves to be honored or not. He has done many good things for the world like finding the Americas ,and he was brave for sailing the seas to find the “New World”. The author of the article “Columbus Doesn’t Deserve a Holiday” thinks otherwise.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Christopher Columbus in 1492 sailed the ocean blue, sparking the age of exploration. When he landed in the Caribbean, Columbus gave hope and dreams to many people as well as kings. Dreams and ideas were not the only thing generated from this period of time. Technology, currency, trade, expansion, and the spread of ideas were a result of this exploration of the new world. The world was altered in many ways some better then others, but like the historical context stated "Many civilizations in the New World were utterly and completely destroyed, while other civilizations remained intact, but transformed culturally, politically, and socially".…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Columbus Day is an unnecessary holiday that, for some reason, we still honor today. The holiday is also an affront to the indigenous population. The false sense of patriotism is wrong to memorialize. The whole day is based off of a fabrication of the true events. When children are in elementary school, they are taught that Christopher Columbus was a hero, to shield the truth.…

    • 166 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In 1492 Christopher Columbus “discovered” the Americas. In 1937 the current president, Franklin Roosevelt, declared it a national holiday. New information now makes us debate whether or not we should celebrate this holiday. If you would’ve asked me a year ago I would have no reason to argue this holiday’s existence, but now I think we shouldn’t celebrate this holiday. This holiday commemorates his “discovery” of the Americas.…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although Columbus Day is a national holiday honoring a famous historic figure, many people take it as an opportunity to hang out with friends, finish homework, or even catch up on sleep. Columbus was known for many brutal attacks and events in history such as multiple rapes, enslaved people, and deaths. It is also well-thought that Columbus was the first one to discover the Americas , where many people don't know that the native Americans where the first to arrive in America. Instead of rewarding Columbus for all of these brutal and terrifying actions, we should abolish Columbus Day because of all of Columbus's lies and mislead ideas. When Columbus came to the Americas, in addition to bringing multiple slaves, he also disrupted their lifestyles.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis: Christopher Columbus was a man responsible for the decimation of three major civilizations, as well as the ultimate genocide of the indigenous peoples as a whole, one of the largest in human history. Columbus alone committed an array of horrific acts, using the Indians as sex slaves and extorting them for labor, stealing their land and goods, and hunting them for sport and dog food. His choices and treatment influenced how other would later view and deal with the Indians, eventually leading to their near extinction. Most of us know very little about the people who roamed our lands before we “discovered them”, and instead praise one man’s inaccurate claims. and that is why we should replace Columbus Day, which credits a man for deeds…

    • 1500 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    No More Columbus Day Remember the rhyme you were taught about Christopher Columbus? That was all a lie. In fact, he was a cruel man and did you know he did not even discover America. Christopher Columbus day should not be celebrated and recognized as a national holiday in the United States because his whole “being a great hero” was all just an act. He did not discover America and he was not even kind to the natives that he saw.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the chapter ‘Forget Columbus’ of the book ‘The Inconvenient Indian’, the author Thomas King writes about his point of view on the forgotten history of the Native Americans. He conveys about the tales made up about the natives and americans engraved in the history to mainly appeal to the white audience. The author starts the chapter by telling how insignificant was the discovery of the land of natives made by Columbus. According to him the only reason why he was given credit and recognized because his story as Columbus sailing the oceans, travelling across with interesting adventures and going through hardships with a letter to the Emperor of Indies by the King and Queen of Spain captured the imagination of the audience and met the expectations…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laurence Bergreen, Columbus: The Four Voyages (New York:Viking Penguin , 2011) 423 pp. Christopher Columbus, the man who “discovered” America is one of the most controversial people in world history. With his adventurous self and crew, they arrived on numerous amount of islands which determines Columbus as a brave and so-called heroic explorer. Laurence Bergreen, a historian and biographer wrote,“Columbus: The Four Voyages” which analyzed Columbus’s actions and decisions during his travels. Turns out Columbus isn’t as heroic, courageous and honorable as everyone thought.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays