Collegial Theory In College

Improved Essays
A problem shared by many colleges and universities across the nation is the battle between coaches wanting their most talented recruits to be accepted to the institution, and admission offices following rules set by the university or national governing boards for all applicants. This problem only grows when the ever-stressful conversation of scholarship and financial aid is brought into the mix. It is unethical for an admission office to lower standards for a specific population of students, no matter how badly the student wants to attend or how much a member or the university faculty or staff wants a student to enroll at the university. The Muskingum University Athletic Department continues to put pressure on the Admission and Financial …show more content…
Robert Birnbaum provides a definition of the collegial theory authored by Sanders (1973), which identifies collegiality as “marked by a sense of mutual respect for the opinions of others, by agreement about the canons of good scholarship, and by a willingness to be judged by one’s peers” (Birnbaum, 1988, p. 87). Birnbaum continues to provide characteristics of a collegial system that closely line up with the ideals found in the admission office at Muskingum University. For example, interaction between employees is informal, decisions are made by consensus, which doesn’t require unanimity, all members of the group are equal and everyone has an opportunity for their voice to be heard on all topics of discussion (Birnbaum, 1988, p. 88-89). The direct supervisor to the staff and vice president make it clear that each employee is valued, which creates a very strong sense of community amongst the staff. The collegiality present in the admission office can also be credited to the size of the staff. Including administrative and support staff there are sixteen total members of the enrollment staff. This makes it possible to have almost constant face-to-face contact, shared values, teamwork and communication between all working …show more content…
Collegiality is not present within their staff or the cross-campus relationship with the enrollment staff. It is my observation that unlike the enrollment staff, the athletic department does not have a leadership that views all individuals as equal. Because of the absence of collegiality, the two departments do not have a shared sense of community. They do have a shared goal and must work together, year in and year out, to recruit students to Muskingum. It is crucial for all pieces of the recruitment, admission and financial aid process to follow NCAA guidelines for the livelihood and persistence of all athletic teams. If regulations are violated, an investigation can occur and sanctions placed on the department. Mark Nagel, professor of sports and entertainment management at the University of South Carolina said, “some Division III teams are moving from the old approach of winning being secondary to it being the primary mission. Those schools have looked at athletics and said, ‘If we do a little more here and invest a little more there, we have a chance to win,’ and everyone likes to win (New, 2016). Every coach has pressure placed on him or her to reach recruitment goals, be a role model for their team, and win. As Nagel said, everyone likes to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Many universities guarantee students athletes for a good education and to help pursue the sport they dream to succeed on; however, these students physical and mental state is being affected because of certain circumstances given by these institutions. For instance, Football athlete’s specifically, are suffering not only because of overtraining, but as well because of the pressure and the responsibilities given by their colleges. Because football has become a huge profit for America’s universities, it has also become the main priority for them and has increased the burden on their students. The way the institutions are controlling these students in order to succeed in any way is only harming them. It is injustice for these students to experience…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Therefore, I want to coach the way I do because athletes are counting on us coaches to do what it takes to win and become intentional about why we coach the way we do. Most importantly our choices will have a lifelong impact on the athletes we…

    • 2368 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This past summer I learned through coaching that I had a very big influence on the players I coached. This made me realize that I have to set an example for those kids at all times. From that, I also had to change some of my behaviors on and off the field. I had to show honor and respect, similar to being a student athlete when you are expected to honor the team agreement that you sign at the beginning of the season, which is normally your coach 's philosophy on how the team is going to be run. Except now, I am a coach.…

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Work Reflection

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Being on a college wrestling team will teach me how to be persistent to work hard to achieve my goals on and off the matt. I've had a lot of experience being on teams with a lot of great history and successful coaches. Being mentored by an outstanding coach and professor at…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The players were familiar with his goals for the team and for each one of them. Notably, they derived this information his inspirational tactics. Having noted his aspirations for the team, Coach K’s players worked hard and followed his commands. Undoubtedly, such conditions resulted to numerous wins and successes that saw Coach K become a legend coach at the…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental Attitudes In Sports

    • 2365 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Most successful athletes do their best to prepare themselves mentally before a big game by imagining themselves performing their best. They create…

    • 2365 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The increasing competition to get into an established school is a major factor that often presses students to cross the thin line from merely doing well in school to resorting to deception in order to succeed. Jessica Terrell 's article, "Driven To Cheat: Students Say Pressure to Achieve is Intense," observes that because colleges are "deluged by more applications than ever, the most selective colleges are, inevitably, rejecting a vast majority, including legions of students they once would have accepted." The increasing competition to get into a college or university pressures students to go above and beyond to stand out from other applicants and combat the perpetuating decrease of the acceptance rates. As students pile up on AP classes and extracurricular activities, the sheer amount of workload they tackle on a daily basis places a substantial burden on them to do well. In an extremely competitive academic environment, students are often left desperate to to take shortcuts in order to manage their hectic schedules.…

    • 1096 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As leader of a residential college at Yale University, William Zinsser describes the different amount of pressures that students struggle with in college in his essay, “College Pressures”. Because of his position at the university, he constantly noticed the students around him and the anxiety that was radiating off them. He believes that economic pressures cause students to feel anxious about paying back student loans after college. However, parental pressure leads students to make decisions that their parents would be happy with because of the feeling of guilt and wanting to please them. Peer and self-induced pressures are also mentioned in Zinsser’s essay.…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    They put so much work in for however many years they attend their school, and now many of them are demanding some sort of compensation. Athletes all over the country have fought for what they believe is their right to be paid. It has become a highly discussed topic in today’s media and will continue to be a popular one until some sort of agreement between the NCAA and its athletes is reached. This topic has sports writers split down the middle on which side to cling on to. Some argue that since athletes are already given a scholarship and often times so much more, they do not deserve any more for what they do.…

    • 2419 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If you try to transfer to a new university it can be a problem to get in the college or to get financial help because many students depend on financial aid from the government and the most import thing for that is grade. Sometimes, bad grades might even harm your relationship with your family. Another problem is that poor grades tend to diminish students’ interest in whatever they’re learning. In order to avoid bad grades in the college every student should focus on organization, management of time and study skills. It is necessary for every student to learn how to manage their time in the college.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays