Colin Powell and Maria Montessori have opposing viewpoints on how students should be educated. Colin Powell believes that students should be taught with a strict structure, while Maria Montessori has a more lenient approach to teaching. Powell thinks that students need to have a strict structure in order to succeed in school. Students need to learn structure in order to give their teachers and caregivers total obedience and respect. However, Maria Montessori believes that you should treat the children as you would treat yourself. If you are polite and respectful to the children, then they will be polite and respectful back to you. She believes that students imitate how their teacher behaves. The most effective learning environment is one
…show more content…
The children who don’t grow up in a structured environment are more likely to drop out and go to jail. On line 70 of “Kids Need Structure” it states, “And by the third grade, the kids who didn't have that structure and minding in the beginning start to realize they’re behind, and what do they do?... They act it out, and they’re on their way to being dropouts” (Powell 10). This evidence shows that these children need to have structure, otherwise they will start failing and just stop wanting to learn. It is crucial that the children want to learn, otherwise they will not learn and start failing. This could be avoided if they start learning structure at a young age. On line 73 it of “Kids Need Structure” it states, “If you're not at the right reading level at third grade, you are a candidate for jail at age 18, and we have the highest incarceration rate because we are not giving our children the right start in life” (Powell 10). This quote shows that if the students don't learn structure, they are much more likely to go to jail, or get in trouble with the law at a younger age. The two quotes listed above both prove that children’s futures can be disastrous unless they learn structure while they are young. Education and structure both start at home, and without a proper start at home, they can fall …show more content…
There are many reasons why this is true. One of these reasons was because it had a one-hundred percent success rate. The drill sergeant teaches the students structure, which helps them learn a skill, become mature, and learn to respect adults. Children need to learn structure; otherwise, they will start failing and they might go to jail. It is also important that mothers start to teach their children structure as soon as they are born, in order to help them succeed when they are older. All students need to learn structure in order to excel in school. Structure will help students do better academically. That is why the most effective learning environment is one where students have a strict
The children who don’t grow up in a structured environment are more likely to drop out and go to jail. On line 70 of “Kids Need Structure” it states, “And by the third grade, the kids who didn't have that structure and minding in the beginning start to realize they’re behind, and what do they do?... They act it out, and they’re on their way to being dropouts” (Powell 10). This evidence shows that these children need to have structure, otherwise they will start failing and just stop wanting to learn. It is crucial that the children want to learn, otherwise they will not learn and start failing. This could be avoided if they start learning structure at a young age. On line 73 it of “Kids Need Structure” it states, “If you're not at the right reading level at third grade, you are a candidate for jail at age 18, and we have the highest incarceration rate because we are not giving our children the right start in life” (Powell 10). This quote shows that if the students don't learn structure, they are much more likely to go to jail, or get in trouble with the law at a younger age. The two quotes listed above both prove that children’s futures can be disastrous unless they learn structure while they are young. Education and structure both start at home, and without a proper start at home, they can fall …show more content…
There are many reasons why this is true. One of these reasons was because it had a one-hundred percent success rate. The drill sergeant teaches the students structure, which helps them learn a skill, become mature, and learn to respect adults. Children need to learn structure; otherwise, they will start failing and they might go to jail. It is also important that mothers start to teach their children structure as soon as they are born, in order to help them succeed when they are older. All students need to learn structure in order to excel in school. Structure will help students do better academically. That is why the most effective learning environment is one where students have a strict