Civil Disobedience: A Comparative Analysis

Decent Essays
Civil disobedience is peacefully protesting against certain laws or refusing to pay fines and/or taxes. The selections titled “Civil Disobedience” by David Henry Thoreau, “Non-violent Resistance” by Mohandas K. Gandhi, and “Letter from Birmingham Jail” by Dr. Martin Luther King all show themes of civil disobedience and peaceful protest. The first article, “Civil Disobedience” is written by Henry David Thoreau. Throughout this article it describes the fault in our government and how it is too controlling. This fits the theme of civil disobedience because it does not have an angry tone and calmly talks about how the government could be better. In the text it says “That government is best which governs least”, this is saying that when the government …show more content…
Gandhi titled “Non-violent Resistance” is also an excellent example of civil disobedience. There are many good statements about how citizens should stand up for what they believe is right which represents civil disobedience. The author writes “but through the other method of combating injustice, we alone suffer the consequences of our mistakes and the other side is wholly spared.” this explains that if people do not stand up for what they believe is wrong in the government, they will suffer the consequences. It also makes sure to get a point across that this should be done peacefully and not with violence which fits the definition of civil disobedience. Lastly, “Letter from Birmingham Jail “by Dr. Martin Luther King fits perfectly with the theme. As we all know, Martin Luther King is an excellent example of civil disobedience and has changed the world in a peaceful manner throughout his protests and speeches for equal rights. He said “we know through experience that freedom is never voluntarily given by the oppressor.” This describes that it is hard to try and gain more freedom because of our stubborn and judgemental government. He used civil disobedience and had hope that things would change for the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Civil disobedience is widely known to play an important role in the formation and progression of the civilized world. Resistance to unjust laws, if done peacefully, impacts the free society positively because it urges a government to distribute freedoms generously while simultaneously maintaining balance within the legal system. Henry David Thoreau stated, "That government is best which governs least" in his essay titled Civil Disobedience. He explained the vital role civil disobedience plays in society while demonstrating how it can be easily distorted to mean that a good government doesn’t govern at all. Thoreau’s case was pertinent to the predicament of slavery during his time, highlighting the “moral tinge” to the idea of fair government.…

    • 748 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil Disobedience is a term that varies among different people. In the mind of Henry David Thoreau the definition of Civil Disobedience requires you to have at least three things. You must be able to identify an issue at hand. You must be willing to take action for that issue. You must be prepared to take responsibility for those actions.…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Thoreau used the word “civil,” he meant “of or relating to citizens.” In modern usage, the term “civil disobedience” implies non-violence,…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil disobedience is defined as members of a community choosing to actively disobey laws in protest of a cause. As proponents of civil disobedience, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Gandhi advocated for those following their causes to complete acts disregarding unjust laws put in place to draw attention to their separate causes. This method of fighting for a cause emphasizes understanding of the necessity for change, that people are actively defying the law to draw attention to the unfair systems in place. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. used this to promote his movement of racial equality as compared with Gandhi’s movement for the separation of India from Britain. Both of their similar philosophies resulted in a degree of success, “the peaceful…

    • 1015 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As stated in “What Civil Disobedience Is”, “Civil disobedience is an act of protest, deliberately unlawful, conscientiously and publicly performed” (Cohen 39). In most cases, civil disobedience is caused by an individual transgressing an unjust law in favor of a higher, unwritten law. Usually, civil disobedience occurs in a non-violent fashion as well. For instance, King proclaims that protest will be done “peacefully, openly, cheerfully, because our aim is to persuade” (qtd. in Cohen 40).…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Am I jus for my disobedient acts? I must be jus for each one that I have ever committed. Civil disobedience is a fracture within the law therefore there must a relishable reason to be disobedient. Yet the reason to go against the state would be due to negligence. Justice is associated with the concept of everything plays a natural role, coming from Feinberg and Gross.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The lasting impact of the Stonewall Riots originates from ideals in the Transcendentalist era. Transcendentalism was an American movement in both philosophy and literature, lasting from 1836 to 1860. Beginning as a movement for reform in the Unitarian Church, it branched off from William Ellery Channing's’ views of an “indwelling God and the significance of intuitive thought” (American Transcendentalism by Donna M. Campbell). Transcendentalism was a belief system that showed the significance of every individual, and valued self reliance along with openness. Ralph Waldo Emerson was a key author during this movement, and is considered the father of Transcendentalism.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In many recent occurrences, American citizens have demonstrated their ignorance towards the definition of civil disobedience by rioting and looting. In order to protest issues in an effective manner, the definition of civil disobedience must be known. Many high ranking historical and modern day figures tend to agree that civil disobedience must have a just cause, it must be an action that disrupts the status quo in some way, and finally, the civil disobedience must be proportional to the impact of the injustice on the rights and the lives of American citizens. In order for “Civil Disobedience” not to devolve into aimless complaining, the civil disobedience must develop out of an injustice perpetrated on a person, a group of people, or a society.…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    So many people have practiced civil disobedience; too many to count. Martin Luther King, Jr., Henry David Thoreau, Rosa Parks, Malala Yousafzai, Harriet Tubman, and many others all took a stand in what they thought was right, even though they could have been killed for their actions. In Martin Luther King Jr., “Letter From Birmingham City Jail”, he tells that somebody has to accept the consequence of their actions. Along with Martin Luther King Jr., Henry David Thoreau in “ Civil Disobedience,” he took the punishment for what he went up against because of what he thought was morally right. But what is so amazing about this, is they were selfless through it all; they did it so others could be helped.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Civil disobedience occurs when one intentionally breaks a law, often to protest said law. It was this form of protest that caused King to be detained at the Birmingham jail. He had been arrested for parading without a permit, after he was denied a permit by the city of Birmingham. (King, 841) It is very important to King, if this act of civil disobedience is to be morally justified, that “one who breaks an unjust law must do so openly, lovingly, and with a willingness to accept the penalty.” (King, 841)…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both of the essays “Letter from Birmingham Jail” by Martin Luther king Jr. and “Civil Disobedience” by Henry Thoreau (1849) showed their understanding about civil disobedience multiple times. Their purpose of their essays was to argue for the right to disobey authority if there is social injustice. In “Letter from Birmingham Jail”, Martin Luther King Jr. took direct action rather than waiting, potentially forever, for justice to come through the courts. King also analyzes the duty and the responsibility of the citizens to protest and to takes action against corrupt laws of the government.…

    • 588 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil disobedience is the act of opposing a law one considers unjust and peacefully disobeying it while accepting the consequences. Looking at American history, it is clear for many to see that peaceful resistance is a core aspect in forcing change to occur ie. women’s suffrage, civil rights, anti war, gay rights, the labor movement, and etc. Without peaceful resistance, change would not occur. Change is rooted in the shadows of peaceful resistance, it’s what has never failed this country in making a difference.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Civil disobedience is an peaceful act of disobeying a law or demand of a government or higher power. Nonviolent protest has been demonstrated since the ancient Greek times to the segregation of blacks and whites to today’s media. In various literature several authors had characters demonstrate the act of civil disobedience, however, this act has also been demonstrated by real life people such as Rosa Parks and her refusal to give her seat up for a white man. Film is another way civil disobedience has been presented. Gandhi and Battle in Seattle, for example, are docudramas that were set on the topic of protest against laws placed by the government.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his discussion "Civil Disobedience," Henry David Thoreau begins by saying, “I heartily accept the motto, that government is best which governs least” (Thoreau 305), and after that reveals that his actual conviction is “That government is best which governs not at all” (Thoreau 305). In Civil Disobedience, Thoreau declares that the government as an establishment prevents the work's achievement for which it was made. It exists for the sole motivation behind guaranteeing individual flexibility. Civil Disobedience is the method for conveying one's convictions. Thoreau characterizes the demonstration of Civil Disobedience by clarifying the considerations and feelings that ought to guide it, and these incorporate having a feeling of rightness and good inner voice.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Civil Disobedience, Henry Thoreau questioned whether a citizen should “resign his conscience to the legislator” and stated that “the only obligation which [one has] a right to assume is to do at any time what [one thinks] right”.[1] Moreover, he advocated for a “right of revolution”, which should always be exercised when we disagree with the law.[2] These two ideas are at the core of what is known as civil disobedience, or the belief that we should peacefully disagree with the regime if its laws seem unfair or contrary to our views. During his lifetime, Mahatma Gandhi used civil disobedience to show his disagreement with the British presence in India.[3] Both thinkers, Gandhi and Thoreau, were imprisoned for protesting a government decision…

    • 280 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays