Ingoldsby And Shaw Summary

Better Essays
Bruno Bettelheim, Daniel Shaw, and Erin M. Ingoldsby Indicate that children react in various ways due to the absence of one parent, in the case of divorce. Both Shaw and Ingoldsby believe that having one parent missing puts a huge stress on a child. They also believe that along with this stress causes the child to have other problems that may also relate to behavioral problems.In the essay there are specific problems that are discussed in the essay are externalizing problems, internalizing problems, and cognitive deficits. Each of these three problems has their own factors and reasons behind them. Bettelheim discusses the conflicts it can cause siblings to have with one parent gone and also a rivalry. All authors discuss a common point which …show more content…
Researchers have found lots of evidence that this problem is found more in girls than boys. Bettelheim explains an interesting point, at every point of a kids life, whether it is a boy or a girl, they feel left out at some moments in life(Bettelheim 281). This point that he is trying to prove is an internal problem that children may have with themselves when one parent may go somewhere but they don't get to enjoy it with them. The internal problems with children start off at a young age, anywhere from the third or fourth grade. In fact, in Ingoldsby and Shaw's essay, they explain a study that was done and teachers say they even see the students who don't a full family more depressed than others. Kids from the age range of 12-16 have been reported with more self- reported distress and depression(Shaw). Bettelheim relates this back to his essay when he begins to talk about a child, who has so many fears about being left out and alone, tend to take there angers out on their siblings. The reasoning behind this is because of how the child feels about their brother or sister are because of the amount of attention they receive from either parent (Bettelheim 281).With this problem that is mostly internal it is shown more in girls because of jealousy, which is mostly seen in younger girls in these types of …show more content…
With the stress that is on the child, it can cause them to go through different stages of life they might not have to go through. In addition to this stress children don't show it like any other adult they have their own ways to show it. Bettelheim explains that children may show their stress by conflicting with their siblings and disobeying others.Shaw and Ingoldsby explained three problems; externalizing, internalizing and cognitive deficit, which each had their own characteristics and ways to be shown. Externalizing was basically described as the delinquency and disobedience that is shown. Internalizing is expressed as jealousy from not receiving as much attention from one parent as a child would like to receive. Finally, there is cognitive deficit which is described as more of an academic and peer issue that children may have. In today's society, we show only the perfect families but we fail to realize every family is not perfect and some people have to go to trials in life. The essay at hand explains a myriad of ways that stress can impact a child, and even though you may not see it, it is still

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Divorce can cause a child many negative effects within their life. “…Evidence suggest that parental divorce (or some fact connected with it) is associated with lowered well-being among both children and adult children of divorce” (Amato 23). Children who have divorced parents can become angry with there parents because of not understanding what’s going on. It can also cause a child to want to act out and have difficulty communicating with others. “Amato and Keith (1991) reports that children of divorce have more difficulty than children in intact families adjusting both socially and psychologically.…

    • 879 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Thus anxiety about separation and parental abandonment is one of the most frequent psychological problems during childhood for children who come from divorced parents. This traumatic event may predispose them to react anxiously in daily departures. “First, these fears result from children’s limited concept of time and their undeveloped thinking ability; second, they are caused by their attachment bonds and complete psychological and emotional dependence on parents.” (Teyber 28) Not only does divorce cause the decline in psychological health but it can be responsible for the decline in physical health as well. The developmental disturbance of children isn’t triggered by merely divorce itself, but instead by other risk factors that are associated with it. These factors include: worst levels of physical health, risky behavior, exacerbated psychophysiological responses to stress and weakening of the immune…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Divorced Parents

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages

    These children have been seen to have more aggressive, impulsive, and antisocial behaviors and more problems in their relationships with their mothers and fathers than children who came from intact two- parent households. (Kelly 1998) The main way children learn about relationships is by watching their parents interact. Therefore, if children see their parents communicate negativity, then they are more likely to communicate this way themselves. Children who grow up in divorced homes usually have less contact with the non-custodial parent and as time goes on the parent child-relationship seems to gradually deteriorate. This creates a break in the parental model that serves as the relationship template for all future relationships in life.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some adult children may try to isolate themselves from an individual parent due to externalizing the issue (Sumner 2013). Most adult children who had an experience with divorce will express a distance from the individual parent. Rhyne 1990, explains that most adult children report their feelings of anger towards the father rather than their mothers. Since most children have a larger amount of affection towards their mothers and feel the sorrow that they are experiencing. Some mothers experience trauma as well through a divorce, which results in the adult children becoming more than willing to support and care for their divorced or remarried mothers.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Relocation, new family structures, and change in income are some key factors that can change for children who are impacted by parental divorce (Bing, 2009). These factors can cause lasting serious effects on the children involved. This may be due to the weak sense of self-control that is brought on by the environment of divorce for the children (Utz, 2012). These broad changes that are brought upon the children of parental divorce can have an influence on the child’s perception of divorce. Some of these lasting effects include changes in their relationship with their parents.…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In this age group children tend to have magical thinking and wish for their parents to get back to together. Also, children may feel more responsible for their parents divorce and see it as their responsibility to reconcile the Divorce. Children 12 and up see the struggle of the parents ' depression, financial changes and etc. causing a child, to show symptoms of depression, rebel,…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Children are stuck in the middle and are at risk for conflict with their parents and people around them. Later, when the children are adult, their sense of morality has shifted, and psychological behaviour is different from another young adult. In a study, conducted by Esme Fuller- Thompson, explained children with divorced parents have more risk of suicidal thoughts with boys being more vulnerable (Thomson). Society needs to understand that as divorce rates are increasing, the children aftermath effect are sticking, and can lead problems in the future. The development of the children is changing due to the parent’s…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Children exposed to a parental divorce are more likely to act out unpredictable and uncontrollable behavior. Divorce also leaves children with emotional problems, negative feelings and less psychological well being than those with intact families. Children experience sadness, anger, loneliness, lower self-esteem, depression, heightened anxiety, worry and lower self-confidence. Lastly, suicide is also triggered from parental divorce. Children are often left with the thoughts that their parents rejected him/her or that they have lost interest in their life.…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is stated that a more regressive response is seen in a child and a more aggressive response in the adolescent (Pickhardt). For any child involved in a parents divorce it disturbs the trust and dependency on parents who now behave in an undependable way. Children coping with a parental divorce all act out in their own way to gain attention from the parents. Children ages one to five may become very clingy, throw various tantrums, refuse to do things asked of them, and become resistant to other caretakers such as a preschool teacher or babysitter. Psychologists say this may be a result of these children trying to get attention wherever they can from whoever they…

    • 2537 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As it is likely that they are lacking social skills, perhaps afraid to talk to others, they may have such kind of behavior. Over- aggressiveness, anxiousness, even fearfulness about being with other children, can lead to peer-group exile. (Don, 1993) This means that children may experience pressures from peers and could not handle their relationship well. In long run, children may be trapped in a single small social circle and loss supports from peers. It is disastrous to have poor relationships…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays