Chinese Room Argument Analysis

Great Essays
Register to read the introduction… When an animal is said to be deliberating or conceptualizing among other things it is said to be thinking and this thinking is said to be taking place within its mind. When a computer is processing information on route to its end goal it is said to be computing. Computing however is a term sometimes used in the realm of animals as well. In math class the teacher may instruct her students to “compute 5+5=x” and the students, without the aid of technology, may mentally compute the equation. Thinking however is a term that, at the moment, is used strictly when referring to animals, mainly humans. Computing within computers is considered to only contain the principle of syntax as opposed to thinking which contains both syntax and semantics. I believe, along with Searle, that semantics is necessary in order to be said to have a mind and therefore be said to be thinking. Searle’s Chinese Room argument articulates this …show more content…
The many modes of processing thought listed above can be further rendered down to the firing of neurons, which as well can be said to be a binary system; consisting of being in the state of firing or not firing. There still remains however a very substantial difference between the two fundamental actions. That difference is rooted in the equipment used to engage in the two respective actions. Searle believes that no computer program will ever obtain intentionality because a computer is not composed of the same biological components as the human brain. This wetware that is the human brain may in fact be necessary for thinking. The wetware of the brain is in many ways inferior to the hardware of a computer and this difference of capability further divides the concepts of computing and thinking. The efficiency of thinking is not nearly as variable as the efficiency of computing. The rate at which a computer computes is determined by the quality of its core processors, the software, the amount of RAM etc. Each of these components are easily upgraded or downgraded and advancements in the fields related to the individual components are happening frequently which consistently increase the quality of computing power that exists. The rate at which someone is able to think about a particular topic is dependent on past experience in which they mostly have no control over and the DNA that they were given at birth. The brain is not subject to upgrades or downgrades in a similar fashion to that of a computer. It is true that learning can upgrade the quality of thought and prolonged lack of exposure to intellectually stimulating environments can somewhat downgrade the quality of thought but these factors resulting changes are far less drastic than that of a computer. Thinking is generally subject to many loose limits for the vast majority of people; limits such as the speed in which thoughts can be processed, the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Moods are also not a factor with Artificial Intelligence. Artificial Intelligence do not get angry, lazy, sleepy, etc. Therefore, Artificial Intelligence is many times more efficient and practical than their human counterparts. As you can tell from the information presented in graph, revenue generated by artificial intelligence exploits will increase by an extreme amount in areas and countries all across the world. However, most of the gains in revenue will more than likely increase the most in Asia Pacific and North…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mac Vs. PC

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages

    PC owners and supporters are aware and display the fact that their computers are more flexible and are able to complete various tasks. PC computers are portrayed to be nearly as impenetrable as Mac computers when it comes to viruses and malware. Moreover, they are on the cheaper side of the computer spectrum and that is a humongous lure for customers looking to purchase a computer. However, these claims are not always factual as they are perceived. Although Macs are becoming vulnerable to malware occurrences as well, they are still such a minute portion of the computer world that the numbers are incomparable.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hinrichs argues that the brain, which created the mind, is a computing machine. The brain is not like a computer, it simply is a computational device, but it is a different type of computer. Hinrichs provides a valid point, a brain, or a particular subdivision of the brain, is able to create an awareness of its own states or functions. This proves that our minds may act like a type of computer but it takes part in a kind of self- monitoring, allowing the brain to create a window into certain aspects of its own functioning. Then there’s Searle, who argues that machines cannot think instead he believes the brain is biological.…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What makes the digital computer different is that the computer can only hold the information that is programmed within it. The most important difference between a computer and the human mind is that you cannot ask a computer to learn or imagine, because it doesn’t have the ability to think freely. You can do the programming into the computer and command the computer to learn whatever it is you want the computer to know, but unlike the human mind, you can’t ask the computer to learn on its own, to imagine what it desires, because it has no desire, no emotion, no understanding of meaning. Imagine a circumstance where you ask both a human and a computer to describe a rose. The human (depending on the age of this person and how much time this person spends outdoors) will be able to describe the rose as it would imagine a rose to look like.…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It’s entirety relies on a hardwired algorithmic system. It may be able to adapt, but it will never reach the adaptability levels a human naturally has. No matter how hyper-connected and powerful artificial intelligence may be, its no…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    The interest of technology is considerable more than intellectual excursion into a new method of organizing and characterized data. The modern area technology is characterized by immediate access of information resources. It would be easier for the treasure budget if it is were armed with the knowledge that the top managers are satisfied with the services and would therefore consider further development an innovation for the improvement of the “The computer are not only large quantities but it is only seconds may scan or analyze millions of records and compile statistics on topic”. Many kind of origination use computers for such purpose. The computerized processing of the data seems magical to untrained eye.…

    • 2550 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These inventions were major steps forward for the human race; they were also unfortunately occurring between intervals of thousands of years from one another. While new inventions were occurring in much faster intervals, it was still an extremely slow process. Of course, this is because humans had to establish a base in order to build upon it. It makes sense that working from a base is easier than working from scratch, and therefore, more technological inventions began to appear over shorter periods of time. Each invention began to change and evolve society into a more convenient and healthy state.…

    • 1627 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the development of technologies, computers are cheaper and faster. However, the computer like Raspberry Pi Zero is very different. It is attracting me at the first time I read about it on a website. It is the art of making something fancy to normal, at a big size to a very tiny one. I am attracted of the art that they bring high technology to everyone, included myself.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the organ in this case became the receiver of all other things, it should distinguish across the matters, but restricted by the form of organ, the matters of organ is unable to recognize the circumstance other than itself. The generic and specific difference cannot be evaluated because the one form would allow only access to some particular matter. This exclusion violated the rational faculty’s property of having infinite access to all. Therefore, this possibility is rejected. The possibility that the rational faculty’s knowledge of its organ came from some other intelligible form differed from the form of organ is also refuted.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What is technology? Technology is the making, modification, usage, and knowledge of tools, machines, techniques, and methods to solve a problem and to achieve a goal. Technology rapidly advancing every day to create a more efficient human life. However, technology is advancing rapidly to the point where it is becoming too intelligent, unpredictable, and uncontrollable. Advancing technology has many benefits, but people are missing out on the risks it also brings.…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays