Childhoods And Killers In Truman Capote's In Cold Blood

Improved Essays
Truman Capote, the author of In Cold Blood, had an intense and meaningful relationship with both murderers of the Clutter family, Perry Smith and Dick Hickock. Readers of In Cold Blood do not have a full, unbiased view of the crime because of Capote’s relationship with Perry and Dick. In order to create a more sympathetic view of both Perry and Dick, but mostly Perry, Capote manipulated the story and information through examples and backstory to show the killers as sympathetic people instead of cold blooded murderers.
Readers are not seeing the full story from an unbiased eye when reading In Cold Blood because of how close Capote was with both Perry Smith and Dick Hickock. By showing the childhoods and backgrounds of both Perry and Dick, Capote created a sympathetic audience for the murderers. Readers have an unbiased eye when quotes are used from Alvin Dewey, Perry Smith, or Dick Hickock, but the way that Capote chose to write the story, including the addition of Perry and Dick’s backgrounds, created a biased view of the Clutter murder case. Capote included the entire letter Perry Smith’s father wrote about Perry for Kansas State Parole, which was boasting about why Perry was a good man and what caused him to commit crime, creating a certain view of Perry onto the reader. Perry’s father describes that Perry’s mother “dr[ank] and step[ped] out…. [and that Perry was] a
…show more content…
Because of the feelings Capote felt for Smith he would often times manipulate the text to make the reader feel bad for Perry, sometimes even more than for Dick. By including details about Perry’s background and his sense of regret Capote is creating the illusion that Perry was not at fault for the murders and felt bad for what he did. The readers of In Cold Blood are actually victims of Capote’s portrayal of events based on his biased opinion of Perry Smith and Dick

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Perry seemed to be greatly affected from committing such a heinous act, he obsesses over it. Dick on the other hand, wants to forget about it like a student would want to forget a bad exam. In regards to Perry’s constant worrying about their situation, Dicks responds with, ”What is it, honey? That other deal? Why the hell can 't you forget it?” (Capote 142). We are also given other instances after the murders that showed the difference of their state of minds and their behaviors. They were not only on different terms after committing the murder, but also beforehand. While preparing for the murder and safe stealing, Perry wanted to purchase some masks to conceal there identity. This was something that Dick opposed, he wanted believed masks were unnecessary as they would leave no witness alive. This detail greatly served to show, the difference in there morality. Capote also believed that Perry never meant to kill the clutter. In an interview with the New York Times, Capote was asked wether he believed if Perry and Dick were surprised about their own action, he responded with, “Perry never meant to kill the Clutters at all. He had a brain explosion. I don 't think Dick was surprised, although later oh he pretended he was. He knew, even if Perry didn 't, that Perry would do it, and he was right. It showed an…

    • 1199 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    When reading In Cold Blood it is quite apparent that Perry feeds on Dick’s affection, because he has no one left. Perry ‘s mood is easily triggered by memories from his scarring life. For example in the film when he and Dick are in the car driving and a truck is coming toward them, Perry begins to embrace himself for a crash since what happened to him on his motorcycle. Dick often refers to Perry as suga and baby. He also is always reassuring him with a sweet tone, thus Perry is swindled into trusting him. The relationship between Perry and Dick could be questioned to be closer than friends because n one scene when Dick is writing bad checks to get pants for Perry’s “wedding” he states that all they need is a ring and they would be good. Another underlying theme that is reoccurring is the significance of family, and how it affects a child. This is apparent when the detectives discuss the possibilities of the mental state of the murders while at the crime scene. The detectives discuss a report made six months prior to the Clutters murder about how four killers who killed without apparent motive like the one presented before them. They said the report stated how the killers felt physical inferior, sexually inadequate, or in their childhood a parent was missing. These things all described Perry and Dick both it…

    • 1823 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Truman Capote’s novel, In Cold Blood, he uses juxtaposition to emphasize the differences between the two murderers. In the first representation, he writes in the perspective of Dick Hickock. He explains how Dick thinks very highly of himself and uses Perry Smith to better his own self image. In the second representation, he writes in the perspective of Perry Smith. Perry is made out to be more sympathetic than Dick. Capote’s use of strong choice in language and his tone throughout the novel, helped capture the reader’s attention and get them to interact with the…

    • 1208 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout the entire writing process, when conducting interviews to the residents of Holcomb or the murderers themselves, Capote “[transcribed] conversation without using a tape recorder” and claimed to have “95 percent accuracy” (Plimpton 3). While certainly impressive, it raises questions about many of the smaller details that Capote chose to write about. For example, many of the dialogues and scenes may have been made up, to help strengthen his argument against capital punishment. One such conversation can be found right before Perry and Dick were sentenced to death. Two men were discussing the penalty that they deserved, and while one argued that death was the only option because they “killed four people in cold blood” the other argued that hanging both of them was “pretty goddam cold-blooded too” (Capote 306). Whether or not the scene actually occurred, this was one of the many subtle ways Capote infused his opinion into the novel. It reveals that the title of the book is actually referring to the killing of Perry Smith and Dick Hickock, whom Capote believed were unjustly killed. Additionally, Capote describes as what he perceived as unfairness in the trial throughout the last section. He references how the lawyers “did not desire to serve”, and how some of the jury members had a personal connection to Mr. Clutter (Capote 257). Perhaps Capote’s biggest attempt to convince the audience that the two men should not have been put to death was when he included what the psychiatrist would have said in the courtroom, had he been allowed. The law in Kansas only allowed doctors to respond yes or no to whether or not a person was sane, and the psychiatrists confirmed that Dick and Perry were both sane at the time of the murders. However, Capote ingeniously included what the psychiatrist would have said. He classified Dick as “above average in…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On pages 107 to 113, In Cold Blood by Truman Capote features two specific narratives during the same span of time. Characters Dick and Perry recall the visit to the Clutter family through separate streams of consciousness, eventually revealing the contrasting personality traits between them. As Perry begins to discuss the peculiarities of the murder, more so the fact that suspicion of the two has not yet risen, Dick expresses his immense lack of interest in the matter. Capote portrays both accounts through separate styles of writing. For example, Capote reveals the depth in Perry’s character by maintaining a constant structure in each sentence. The author’s variety in diction…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Through the use of rhetorical strategies, Truman Capote manipulates the reader’s emotions by portraying Perry Smith in In Cold Blood as a sympathetic character. Perry Smith, along with his partner Dick Hickock, murder the Clutters, a well loved family in the town of Holcomb, Kansas. This small town consists of people, who immediately outkast the murders because they only understand their own lives, and nothing outside of Holcomb. Although there are two murderers, this rhetorical analysis will solely focus on Perry’s traumatic childhood. To share an outsider’s point of view of the situation, Capote uses simile, alliteration, and theme to influence the reader to sympathize with Perry, rather than to condemn him.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One cannot be good or bad without being both. There is much use of emotional examples and informed opinions that prove this statement. Capote quotes Perry’s sister when she claims, “He can seem so warmhearted and sympathetic. Gentle. He cries so easily” (Capote). This quote influences a question out of the readers, how could someone who seems so good turn evil? It emphasizes the good inside Perry’s bad. The contrast between good and evil is a great one, but no true person is truly good or evil. As Burdon said, “It is a constant struggle as to which one will win. And one cannot exist without the other” (Burdon). When Perry’s sister describes him being warmhearted, it is probably true, but him being coldhearted is also valid. Her positive comment alludes Perry in good times, not his bad. There is also an informed opinion stated, “The crime was a psychological accident, virtually an impersonal act” (Capote 244). By saying this, Capote defends the argument that the killers were simply cold hearted. It influences the reaction of the readers as well as the Holcomb community. Relating to Burdon’s quote, the evil in this case was the mental problems that beat Perry and DIck’s good side. Their seems to be focus on mental illness as the justification for the murder. Many of the characters also seem to sympathize towards Perry, being that he had a bigger mental illness than Perry. Not only that but he seemed aware of his mistakes, which shouldn 't justify his actions, but influenced the readers into understanding him more. His good side shined through his…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is no coincidence that Capote ends his account of this captivating mystery with Dewey. Of all of the surviving characters of In Cold Blood, Dewey is arguably the most affected by the case. Capote reveals that Dewey’s dream of living on a farm were ultimately not realized, due to Marie’s uneasiness to live “in that sort of isolation” as a result of the Clutter murders, a case with which she had become all too familiar (341). Dewey himself was unable to bring himself to watch the death of Perry Smith, and “shut his eyes” when he was ultimately hung (340). A man who had worked four years to catch these murders, was still unable to stomach the sight of killing them. Capote employs Dewey’s family and sensitivity to the murders in order to create sympathy in his audience for…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his novel In Cold Blood, Truman Capote explores a significant controversy in the American justice system: the death penalty. He carefully describes a dramatic incident in Holcomb, Kansas when four members of the respected Clutter family are killed. When the murderers, Perry Smith and Dick Hickock, are finally caught after an extensive investigation, they are given the death sentence. Through a historically accurate and compelling novel, Capote criticizes capital punishment by humanizing Perry and Dick, suggesting their sentence to be unnecessary, and exposing its brutal nature.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Truman Capote’s first non-fiction novel, “In Cold Blood”, recaps the events around the murder of the Clutter family, by focusing on the two murderers, Dick Hickock and Perry Smith. Throughout the book, Capote acknowledges the perpetrators without a bias perspective, he does this by giving the backstory of both Dick and Perry. Capote does not just focus on the murder, but instead introduces Dick and Perry as two people who made a horrible mistake and deserve sympathy. However, if you sympathize with them is completely up to you, the author does not force you one way or the other. For example, most people began to sympathize with Perry Smith, probably because throughout the book Capote subtly blames Perry’s murder on his own childhood. It’s also…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Cold Blood shows how the criminal justice system has flaws and inequality. Both Dick and Perry were aware that the actions they took were wrong, because of this they ruled out insanity. But throughout the book the reader questions Perry’s state of mind. Capote reveals many details about Perry’s past. In the book he uses appeal to emotion in order to create pity within the audience towards Perry. He illustrates well that Perry came from an unhealthy atmosphere. He also makes the reader see the difference between what the Mr. Hickock and Smith think about “normal.” In Part Two, Perry talks about a yellow bird, like a “[...]a warrior-angel,” that “bird” seems to come to his rescue when he finds himself in dangerous situations. This metaphor can be considered a hint of insanity within Perry’s mind. During the court trial we see how the jury rejects the appeal of fact that Capote does not. Capote gives the readers what the jury did not want to hear, “Perry Smith shows of definite signs of severe mental illness.” Dr. Jones talks about how Perry wasn’t thought the fixed sense of moral values. Perry Smith was different from Dick Hickock in a way that even though they committed the crime together, their state of mind wasn’t. The judge completely refused to question Perry mental stability, because he saw murder as black and…

    • 1445 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Despite being a known murderer, when the name Perry Smith is heard a feeling of innocence is felt. Truman Capote, a writer of many breathtaking novels, creates an intriguing impression of Perry Smith, a main character and murderer in In Cold Blood, by outlining his broken childhood, personality and actions, and the sympathy he feels for Smith. Capote shares a deep connection with Smith by their similar upbringings. Capote rarely saw his parents growing up, and after their divorce he went with his mom, as well did Perry when he was put in the same situation. Both of their mothers drinking habits went out of control, and made their life more unstable.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Capote uses rhetoric effective in making the reader feel some sympathy towards Perry Smith. In the book, In Cold Blood, Capote adds two letters from Perry Smith’s family members. In one letter, Perry’s father talks about Perry as a child, including how Perry was the only one of his kids to really love him, how Perry would stick up for the little kids that were bullied in school, and how “[Perry] was well liked by all the neighbors, and their kids” (146-147). The same letter also talks about the rough upbringing that Perry had. Perry’s mother and father split when he was young and his mother was a drunk who didn’t care much for her children. Perry was bullied by many kids in the many different schools he attended due to his family situation. None of this screams a pleasant or decent upbringing, which was Capote’s entire point of putting it in the book - to make the reader feel bad for Perry. And as the article, “Critical Essay on In Cold Blood”, states, “[In Cold Blood] is ultimately a condemnation of society’s treatment of its children.” Capote develops this idea later in the book by outlining the effect his early life had on…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Manipulation is all about reading between the lines and recognizing the lies for what they are” (No Author), Truman Capote wanted to gain the the reader's pity and remorse for Dick Hickock and Perry Smith. At first, capote just wanted to tell the facts of the case to the world but he became attached to Smith. In the novel, In Cold Blood, written in 1965, Truman Capote, a well-known author, asserts that the Clutter family was murdered and that Perry Smith should have the reader's’ pity by using first hand accounts, the murder, and the murderer's story.…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That statement is basically the only time in the whole book when Capote would be speaking directly to the reader. Throughout the remainder of his work he uses tone and journalistic seriousness to create a feeling of tragedy and sadness that relates the reader to the characters in In Cold Blood. Capote is able to capture the readers attention and pull them into the story as he talks about how Perry and Dick became criminals and how criminality leads to…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays