Public Schools Vs Charter Schools

Superior Essays
The United States of America has the largest most robust economy in the world. America has the most advanced military in the world and serves as a beacon of hope and peace around the world. One would expect the United States to also be at the top of the list when it comes to our public education system; unfortunately that notion is false. Among thirty developed countries, the United States ranks 25th in math and 21st in science (Lessons in Education). As our economy is becoming more dependent on technological innovation, our position in the world in regards to math and science education is very weak. The hard working taxpayers of the United States pay near 10,000 per student to be education in our public school system (Lessons in Education). …show more content…
Charter Schools receive public funded like traditional public schools, however; they can me more flexible and enact their own rules and techniques for teaching. Charter schools are most commonly found in low-income areas with failing school systems. They offer a choice for low-income individuals who would have other wise had to send their child to a public school. Critics of charter schools, most notably the teachers unions, argue that charter schools waste money that could have otherwise been spent on traditional public systems. They also believe that this “choice” that is now available, creates competition amongst schools, which will not have a positive overall effect. I strongly disagree with the critics and believe charter schools are part of the solution to fixing our public education problem. The primary benefit of charter schools is that it allows for education leaders to be innovative (Rotherman). An individual can apply to start a charter school and if approved, that person can design a curriculum that he or she believes will be successful. Traditional principles cannot do this because they have to adhere to stricter guidelines. The entrepreneurs of charter schools learn from failing public schools and create schools that will be beneficial to certain types of students. No student learns the same, so charter schools enable students with different learning needs to attend a school that best fits them. Charter schools create a customization in public education (Rotherman). Unlike traditional public schools, if a charter school is failing they are closed down relatively quickly. This gives them an incentive to set high standards for their students and produce educated children. Public schools don’t have this incentive because most failing public schools remain open. Because charter schools must preform well to stay in existence, many outperform public schools. Another

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    America’s education system is no longer one of the best in the world. Americans may act like education is the most important asset a person can earn. However, our country is falling way behind many Asian and European countries because children are lacking education in almost every subject. Benjamin R. Barber, author of “America Skips School”, explains what really is wrong with our education in in his essay. The article explains what is wrong with America’s educational system because we are focusing on other inputs but, not school. The United States needs to start putting more focus towards education and schooling. In the article “In Praise of the F Word” Mary Sherry explains how much a teachers and parents can positively impact children’s education.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    America's standard of public education has fallen into a deep decline over the last decade. School should be better constructed to teach kids how to prepare for adult life and the real world. Many of the things taught today in school have little to no value to students after they graduate. Curriculum should involve very crucial life skills such as people skills, critical thinking, and financial management. Our Education System barely does anything to cater to those needs, which sets kids up for failure later in life.…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Generally, the charter school is known for going there because students choose to. Stereotypically, some people think that it is a type of school for people with a lot of money. Some might even think that it is a school for kids that get kicked out of public schools and have nowhere else to go. Controversial and experimental teaching styles. It has also been thought that charter schools have more funding than public schools, but little do they know that it is the other way around. The issue with the charter schools is that there is not much funding which causes the school to be aggressive and entrepreneurial (Charter Schools Are a Bad Idea). After the first charter school opened, much has happened in the charter schools across the United States…

    • 1251 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Almost nothing good comes from public schools. I hear that public school is a place where fights, drugs, shootings, and terrible teachers can happen. Only one thing good comes from public schools, all kids can go to get some education and parents can go to work then. I see schools as necessary but need more improvement. Parents have to deal with their kids bad attitudes that they can pick up from school. In some places, schools don’t have good security and shootings happen. Some teachers do not do their jobs well, making kids not receive good education. I see public schooling as bad today because parents cannot shelter their kids, dangers threaten their lives, and they do not receive good education.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has been a few decades ago since charter schools were established, with the main purpose as to ensure the improvement in the public school system. Furthermore, charter schools were intended to give teachers more freedom and innovativeness in instructing students to attain greater academic achievement. Thus, these schools have provided much improvement in the quality of education that public schools can offer.…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The school board has done much to ensure that the children of this rebuilt educational system are provided with the best education available. In the privatizing of schools, most have become charter schools. Charter schools, like public schools, are free to attend. The funding for the charter schools comes from the government and they are held to certain government standards. If these charter schools fall short of their expectations, the charter school can be shut down. The concern with the charter schools is the standardization of the curriculum. The parents of the students want to know that their children are getting the same education that every other school is providing. The other issues surround how confusing choosing a school can be; especially when the school the parent wants their child to attend has no openings. Charter schools only have so many vacancies for students. Many of the public schools in New Orleans are still struggling. Those who cannot afford to attend a private school or could not enroll in the charter school ends up at public school. Even ten years after Katrina, the school system is still in a rocky, limbo. Despite the education system not being absolutely perfect, it has improved by leaps and bounds in the last ten years. More schools will start to emerge in New Orleans, that will be the model schools for the other charter, private, and public avenues of education. The changing-of-hands from the government to the privatized sector is working. They are closing the achievement gap and not only creating model schools for themselves but also for the rest of the United States. This approach to education reform might not work everywhere in the U.S., but it has to have it’s own place in other…

    • 1264 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I did not agree with the ideas in the pro-charter schools article I read due to prior knowledge and experience. After the discussion with the anti-charter school readers, my opinion stayed the same. The other students gave me more information as to why they are not working currently. A student from the anti-charter school articles said that charter schools would work in theory, however in most situations, the administrations are corrupt. They are making much more money than the teachers. Others also made points about curriculum choice of the teachers and how it’s possible for them to be teaching unnecessary or inappropriate material. These ideas stood out to me that charter schools may work in theory, however, currently they aren’t reaching…

    • 200 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Charter Schools are an alternative way to traditional public schools. These types of schools do not have the same restriction and regulation that traditional public schools do. Therefore, they have the “freedom to be more innovative while still being held accountable for advancing students ' achievement.” (National Alliance for Public Schools) Since the charter schools are still public schools they accept all children, no tuition charge, and no special exam to attend. This helps parents that don’t want to enroll their children in traditional public school or private school. There are advantages and disadvantages when it comes to knowing if a charter school is truly improving education.…

    • 1532 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The charter school movement has been the most prominent and controversial education reform in the United States in the last twenty years. Similarly, rapidly shifting demographics in the United States have been the source of much research and attention. The convergence of these two trends is under-represented in scholarly literature. Given the dramatic growth in charter schools, authorizers and diverse populations in the past two decades, more research is needed to understand what conditions are associated with the most effective authorizer practices and how authorizers differentiate their practices for at-risk populations. There is also need to update the authorizing literature in general and, particularly, to examine multicultural authorizing…

    • 688 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the entirety of charter schools is compared to the entirety of traditional public schools, teachers of charter schools are actually less educated, experienced and content with their careers. According to researchers at Public Agenda, during the 2011-2012 school year:…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We are in a race. Countries all around the world are fighting to dominate the global market. Japan, China, and India are taking advantage of the changing economy and the lack of American tenacity. It is our job, as Americans, to revitalize the American work ethic and propel ourselves into first place. Globalization aided by increased connectivity calls for heightened competition. The automation of skilled and unskilled jobs threatens the American workforce. The economy is changing to accommodate a high standard of excellence. As the world changes around us, we too must adapt so as not to be left in the dust. Currently, our public education system is falling behind, ranking 14th globally (Leppi). Many experts are emphatic that the reform of…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    national average”. This fact is stating that going to a public charter will give everyone a better chance at graduating and proves that's going to a charter school more will graduate also that their graduation rate is one point higher than the U,S national average. This fact shows how going to a charter school will improve the chances of bettering someone's education because one of the thing you need to better one's education is to graduate high school which is very important and this next fact will show what else is an important reason why someone should go to a charter school especially if they want to better their education afterwards “DC public charter schools have closed the citywide student achievement gap between black and white students by 25% in three years”. This fact states that public charter school in DC closing a learning gap that is creating by socioeconomic status which means they have more funding for books, technology and trips that could help students learn better. This fact connect back to the topic how public charter schools lead to a better chance at education because by closing the achievement gap thing like college will notice the students test scores which is how college determine if the student is ready for college also what class they should take once they get there. This next fact will also help prove that…

    • 1408 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The charter school movement has expanded and gained power from 1997 to 2015. Although they are publicly are freed from many of the rules and commandments binding traditional public schools in a venture to increase student fulfillment. While teachers themselves have established up many charter school programs, teachers are also some of the most laud critics of the charter school development. A close look at the connection between teachers and charter schools disclose why this movement is such a highly discoursed issue.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Immediately after Elementary school, I transferred to a strict charter school and remained there for four and a half years. Though the charter school was known for its academic achievements and its high test rankings, the academic success wasn’t enough for me. I craved a more wholesome learning experience. I realized halfway through sophomore year that the academics were only half the battle. I lacked the ability to communicate efficiently with others. The move from a tight-knit school of 650 students to a public school with 2,000 students was terrifying. My grades through junior year dropped as I got a sense of how the real world is; teachers don’t repeat the assignment, grading errors don’t fix themselves, and I had to learn how to fight…

    • 326 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Charter schools are becoming a greater debate as they continue to grow all over America. Charter schools are a nontraditional public schools that are funded with public money and have been freed from district regulations and some state laws in exchange for greater accountability to achieve performance results set forth in the charter (Spellings 1). Charter schools are just like any other school but just with a different name. Charter schools are a waste of money and are not helping better children’s education like they were intended too.…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays