Stream Of Consciousness In Charlotte Perkins Gilman's The Yellow Wallpaper

Superior Essays
Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wall Paper” uses stream of consciousness from a patient’s point of view to describe the effects of the ‘rest cure.’ The narrator’s description and opinion of each character provides the audience with a base to interpret them for themselves. Each character reinforces the normalized domestic beliefs of the 19th century to an extent. In this story, the narrator represents women during the 1880s, therefore her husband represents men and their relative to her circumstances. “The Yellow Wall Paper” presents John as the embodiment of the socially accepted patriarchal authority permitted to dictate a woman’s life through the abuse of male authority in conjunction with his occupational authority, in …show more content…
As the head of the household, John acts as the voice of reason, meaning his opinions dictate what everyone in the household should do. Perhaps because of his position as a physician, John centers his reasoning on rationality, believing only what his mind can grasp. Due to this narrow-mindedness, John limits his wife in several ways. He defines her by her illness, though throughout he claims she is physically unafflicted. He criticizes her and claims she is imagining her illness, thus invalidating her opinions considering she is not in the same position he is. Instead of referring to her illness as what it is or even considering it could be a more complicated mental illness, John is more comfortable describing her ailment as “a slight hysterical tendency.” This is unprofessional since John is not examining his wife objectively, as he would any other patient. Instead, his bias towards social acceptability distorts his perception of reason. This contradicts his position as the ‘voice of reason’ since he is considering his own needs as he treats his wife. The most detrimental aspect of this is that his wife knows that as long as “he knows there is no reason to suffer,” he will consider the situation handled. Considering she views him as the voice of reason, she expresses herself relative to what her husband considers reasonable. This shows that the conventional ‘voice of …show more content…
Even when the narrator feels uncomfortable in the house, her husband invalidates her concerns. The narrator claims “if [she] had less opposition and more society and stimulus-,” in which she leaves the thought unfinished because the idea that her opinions are worth less than her husband’s is ingrained in her thought process. The importance behind this halt lies behind the fact that only the narrator knows this information on account of the fact that she is writing in secret on a paper that only she has access to. Since she feels compelled to abstain from including her solution in full, she demonstrates the authority her husband has on her even when absent. Clearly she views his judgment in higher respects than her own even though her health is in question. According to her husband, “the worst thing [she] can do is think about [her] condition.” The fact that John does not allow her to have a say regarding her own condition and treatment demonstrates the superiority with which he carries his intellect due to his social standing. He not only dismisses her ideas because his position as a physician gives him the authority to override her solutions, but because he does not view her on his same level. In addition, John transitions from treating his wife as a patient, though unprofessionally, to treating her like a child he does not believe capable of taking proper care of herself. Though

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    When men refuse to listen to women’s thoughts on their health condition their health will decline. Increased cases of ignorance leads to the social expectation that men are more intelligent than women and women’s intuitions hold no value. “John does not know how much [Jane] really [suffers] he knows there is no reason to suffer and that satisfies him.” (3). John believes Jane is fine although she is enduring pain, because he dismisses her feelings. Humans possess the ability to emphasize, however humans are incapable of experiencing one another's pain.…

    • 822 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By using the world little, this derogate the narrator’s integrity of being a woman. In addition, by saying “she shall be as sick as she pleases” shows how a child sometimes makes up and self diagnoses their sicknesses to get out of certain situations. This statement then leads him to diagnose his wife with temporary nervous depression. Her husband fails to care about the opinion of his patient when she begs him on numerous occasions to visit relative and by being able to write freely in her journal. John doesn’t want her to write stories because he thinks it may have an influence on her depression, however this is the only way that the narrator can express and reflect herself.…

    • 1524 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She explains that women do not have a sense of leadership or solidarity to be able to compete with “The One” and are contempt with being in second place to men. Since John identifies himself as being more intelligent and rational, he thinks he knows more than his wife about her own conditions, which exemplifies why she never defends herself against him. Gilman states “…but really you are better, dear, whether you can see it or not. I am a doctor, dear, and I know. You are gaining flesh and color, your appetite is better, I feel really much easier about you” (Gilman 666).…

    • 985 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The narrator is confine in a house and is forced to do nothings because is recommended for her mental illness. Gilman reveals to the reader's how quickly it is for insanity takes hold on a person when it is misunderstood. Isolating a person from the rest of the world make matters worse. The unnamed narrator`s husband ,John, plays a major role in the process of the narrator going mad .“ ...he scoffs openly at any talk of things not to be felt and seen and put down i figures...you see he doesn't believe i am sick! (Gilman,1)” John believes that his wife is not really sick because he couldn't see the illness physically.As he is both her husband and a physician, johns`s word carries ultimate authority for the speaker.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He treats her as someone inferior. Many times John just brushes off the fact that she wants to leave from her imprisonment, but is denied by the fact that she should trust him because he is her husband and alas, he is also a trained physician. The other characters in the story ignore the fact that she is “insane”. The fact that her depression is treatable in other ways, it’s the treatment that is slowly destroying her. John’s assistant and the narrator’s sister do nothing to halt her abuse.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She also complains about her husband John, who is a doctor that thinks that her sickness is cause by her writing and thinking of these crazy fantasies. John feels that since he is a doctor he knows what’s best for her. Her treatment requires that she so nothing active and especially forbidden from working and writing. The narrator illustrated “Personally I disagree and believe that congenial work, with excitement and change would do me good,” (Gilman 76). The narrator believes that she would actually be better if she was writing again or doing some type of activity but because she doesn’t want to stress her Husband John out, so she will do what he wants.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    John’s way of treating the nervous condition he believes his wife has gone horribly wrong, but as her husband, he was really trying to help her get better, not make her any worse but her condition ends up worsen. The problem with John is not that he doesn’t love his wife, but is that he doesn’t want to listen to her and he feels because he is her husband and doctor he knows what’s best for her overriding her own opinion. John believes that he is so certain that he knows what’s best for his wife that he disregards and belittles her own opinion about her well-being, also forcing her to hide what her true feelings really are. He consistently talks down to her and makes her feel as if she is a child herself. He calls her a “blessed little goose” (Gillman) and under minds all the suggestions she makes, such as refusing to switch bedrooms when she asks so as not to grant her “fancies” (Gillman).…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The way that John treated the narrator’s depression went particularly wrong, but his intentions were to actually help her not make it worse. The narrator states that “he loves me dearly, and hates to have me sick.” telling the reader that even she knows he wants to help her heal (7). But since John knows no other than the male “superior” role, being her husband and doctor, he believes he has that authority over her, where he chooses what is best for her without even asking her for an opinion over her own health. John declines the narrator’s smallest wishes, just like when he refused to switch her bedrooms when she asked. Although he never intended to do her any harm, his ignorance is what ended up harming her, which comes hand in hand on why he is not an actual “villain” but his mentality and unequal relationship brings him to not understand her or her problems fully.…

    • 987 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because this story is written from the perspective of the woman, it is easier for readers to assume that the man is oppressive and controlling. Once again, John only insists that she do certain things because he cares about her. He does not want her to write or imagine things because he feels like it will worsen her condition, he asks that she exercise so that she can maintain her strength, and he keeps her mainly isolated in a room at the top of the house so she will focus on getting better. This makes John seem tyrannical, but in reality, he does everything out of his longing to help his…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This is shown by the actions and characteristics of John to his wife. John ignores her requests and doesn’t care of her well being. Since John is referred to a physician her should have taken better care of his wife and realized that solitary confinement was not the cure. John should have ignored being a physician and focused on being a supportive husband to his wife. This story helped explain how the gender inequality impacted women and how they felt inferior.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays