Charles Murray, What's Wrong With Vocational School?

Improved Essays
Leaving High school isn’t the same for everyone. Some leave knowing what they want to do at the end, while others have no clue. Charles Murray expresses his disagreement that too many kids are going to four-year colleges. In his essay, “What’s wrong with Vocational School?” Murray States that Vocational schools should be more of an option to people rather than having everyone go to a four-year college. He explains that many that go to a four-year college are unqualified, basing it on their IQ levels or lack of interest in attending. Murray believes that it may also be a waste of their money if they are just going for the LIB art major which may lead them nowhere and leave them with nothing but loans. Although Murray does make a good argument …show more content…
Some leave knowing what they want to do at the end, while others have no clue. Charles Murray expresses his disagreement that too many kids are going to four-year colleges. In his essay, “What’s wrong with Vocational School?” Murray States that Vocational schools should be more of an option for people rather than having everyone go to a four-year college. He explains that many that go to a four-year college are unqualified, basing it on their IQ levels or lack of interest in attending. Murray believes that it may also be a waste of their money if they are just going for the LIB art major which may lead them nowhere and leave them with nothing but loans. Although Murray does make a good argument that four-year college may not be for everyone, I disagree with him, saying that vocational school would be a better option and that not everyone is qualified, therefore I do think that everyone that whoever chooses to attend college is able to and should attend. For instance, a four-year college may be for someone who has a clear vision of what they want to be in life. However, like Murray said, “some large proportion of students on today’s campuses -- probably a majority of them -- are looking for something that the four-year college may not provide” ( Murray 2). He believes that four-year colleges try to do too much, a more practical option would be vocational schools. A two-year college would be better for someone who’s still figuring it out or wanting to do something in the Arts department or for someone that would like to learn technical specialties. With the focus of figuring it out and attending college to get a degree. Although, In either case, going to College doesn't guarantee stability for anyone. However, it could be beneficial in the real world when compared to an individual who has no college experience.The reasons are best explained by, Murray who says, “The fault lies in the false premium that our culture

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Charles Murray’s “Are Too Many People Going to College” makes key points as to why so many students now go away to college and why they should consider not attending the four years of continued education. Murray discusses many aspects such as why so many students feel the need to further their education, when to focus on the liberal arts in a child 's education, and whether all students have the mental capacity to attend college. He then questions if acquiring a degree is necessary for all jobs and comments on the labels that come with not pursuing a higher education…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A man who obtained a B.A. degree in history from Harvard and a Ph.D. in political science from Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Charles Murray wrote an opinion piece with the title “What's Wrong With Vocational School,” published in The Wall Street Journal. Murray argues that not every high school graduates should go to a four year college and waste their time. Murry starts with giving his opinion, citing convincing facts and statistics, and employing very few emotional appeals; however, at the end of the piece, his attempts to appeal to logic ultimately weakens his argument. Charles Murray is an American libertarian, political scientist, sociologist, author, and columnist.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many of the reasons that come into play with this decision is money, time, and careers. Most of the time college attendees are unemployed or in a low paying job which makes it difficult for them to pay off what’s needed for their courses along with adding to their debt. Also, when done with school many students don’t even go into the career types that they majored for. These points of course cause people to stray away from the idea of tackling a higher education. They begin to think what is the point of doing what they do if it doesn’t get them where they want to…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “What’s Wrong with Vocational School?” by Charles Murray is a great article that highlights what ails the education system and the United States of America’s economy. Murray prods the readers to question why the vocational schools are not taken seriously in the United States of America. The American higher education system has been overrated to the extent that all parents would like their children to end up in the best colleges and universities even if their IQ does not allow them to excel in them. Murray is addressing parents and students and urging them to rethink their attitude towards vocational education in order to improve the society by joining them in groups. The essay is aimed at outlining and explaining the reasons why vocational schools is just as important as college and why it should be recommended as an option to the youths in the United States of America.…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They become dependent at this moment in their life that they don’t realize what they are doing is wrong. They can’t slack off in that point in time. They don’t realize they have to keep working that hard even after they get to college. Yes, college is harder than high school but to reach your four-year goal, you have to keep on track. I think that Jon is on the same side as I am on this topic. He gives you a whole article on examples of why he’s saying what he’s saying. He talked to and got many statistics to prove it. He talked to a kid named Alex Nichols. He’s a student that thought he’d get his bachelor's in four years but later realized that wasn’t going to happen. He even found surveys to back up this information, the Higher Education Research Institute at UCLA did a nationwide survey of these…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Like Garrison assesses, going to college isn’t necessarily going to guarantee your happiness or tell you what type of human being you ought to be, but it will set you up to be able to explore the nature of human life and its meanings for you. (Garrison, p.289) Whether it is a degree in Associates of Applied Science or Liberal Arts Degree, college will prepare students for the “responsibilities or mature citizenship through the disciplines of a broad, rich and extensive curriculum.” (Garrison, p.290) In addition, it teaches one to be an “effective participant in society,” (Garrison, P. 290), which, for some, is very important, and for others it’s hard to want to change. Garrison says, “To be educated is to be changed, to be enlarged and reoriented as a person. To change is hard. Most of us resist change, or being changed. “(Garrison, P. 291) However, if you’re exposed to it long enough, you will eventually crack and want to change for the better. The more and more I go back to school, the more and more I enjoy it. But I suppose that comes with the growth of…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Call me somewhat hypocritical or call me a parent just prepping her kids for another four years of schooling. I remind my kids often how important college is. Although I do not believe everyone needs it. Why do my kids need it? Well, maybe they don’t. If I find out my son has a niche for a trade then trade school it is. If my daughter has a passion for hair then that’s her calling. In his writing Leonhardt states, “Education helps people do higher skilled work, get better jobs with better with better paying companies or open their own business”. Although there can be tons of truth to that, there are exceptions. I know personally tons of business owners who never went to college. I know plenty of people who are talented in areas and have utilized their talent into profit. Graffiti artist who have taken their skills…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Liberal Arts Education

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In America, a liberal arts degree seems to be such a demand. High schoolers are pressured to apply to many different colleges and pick a high paying/achieving degree that takes at least four years to achieve. But if you dig a little deeper into why college seems to be so important, is it really necessary to go to college for four years? Will a liberal arts degree actually benefit you and worth the years it takes it attain one? The articles “The New Liberal Arts” by Sanford J. Ungar and “Are Too Many People Going to College?” by Charles Murray go into much detail about this topic. Charles Murray expresses in his article that a liberal arts education should not be so important to everyone and that for many people, it can be very difficult and…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Charles Murray’s What’s Wrong with Vocational School he claims that only a certain percentage of high school graduates are going to college and will pass. Murray is trying to appeal to the students with high IQ’s and tell them that going to vocational school might be more educational and the students will learn more while getting jobs that pay more sometimes six figures. Murray also argues that sometimes going into the work force after high school is better than going to college because a certification can always be overlooked on certain jobs rather than experience is looked at on every job interview. Murray uses ethos, logos and pathos along with several other rhetorical devices to explain why college is not always the best choice.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College degrees seem to be the only and sure-fire way to get a job in today’s society. However, there are people who believe that if the idea of having a college degree was not so heavily forced onto our youth, than there are definitely other ways to not only prepare for a career but be qualified as well. Some of those individuals that believe this are Charles Murray and Jacques Steinberg, authors of, “Should the Obama Generation Drop Out?” and “Plan B: Skip College” respectively. Murray believes that going to college is not a bad thing, he stresses the need to replace the necessity of a college degree to have a chance to obtain a good job. Steinberg does believe that not attending college and gaining skills necessary for jobs are more important…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Generally, students look forward to going to college after high school. It gives them an opportunity to expand their knowledge and find themselves. But, for some, college does not benefit them. They go to college and simply do not take advantage of their degree. This statement is supported by the quote that “it is estimated that in the U.S., approximately 50% of students who start college never graduate” (page 680). This is because they are either not prepared academically and financially, or simply do not have a drive to learn. In addition to that, even if they do go,…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some seniors in high school still do not know what they want to be in the future and some others are just careless when it comes to the future, even if they are going to graduate in a couple of days. Some of the high school graduates who are planning on going to the college are just going to figure out themselves. Why go to college if you are just figuring yourselves out? Why not just take a year off for that? The graduated high school students should not be forced to attend college because some students present financial problems, lack of motivation, and lack of interest.…

    • 830 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Now on the surface this may seem like a step backwards as to why people don’t want to go to college, but it’s a reason in and of itself. Some people have a path in life they want to go down, and college may not lead them any farther or closer to their goal so they decide not to go as they find no use for it at the moment. I myself am very capable of going to college, yet the way my career works doesn’t require that I go to a college, only that I provide for myself and my family with enough time in my day to pursue my passion as an artist. Not every reason for not going to college is purely logical or explainable. Sometimes it’s as simple as, “I’m not going to college because I just don’t want to go to…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For many college students, obtaining a degree carries with it the guarantee of employment. To be young is to be idealistic. Many students chose a path of study believing it will guarantee them employment, yet a degree in art history is nowhere near as applicable as a degree in law or medicine. Students should be culpable for their own choices, but I believe that the college education system often presents all areas of study with a sort of romanticism; it seems to say that, with the right amount of hard work and dedication, you can make a successful career out of any major. For many people, this simply is not…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are several reasons why students decided to drop out of college – poor counseling, work opportunities, family and financial responsibilities. Often times, due to the lack of money to pursue a college, vocational or technical training are some of the main reasons why most students are forced to work after high school or attend college on a part-time. In some cases, parents cannot afford to pay the education of their children in college, therefore, parents might send their kids to study any short career, or they just make them find a job. Sometimes, students drop-out because they do not receive enough help from parents, or schools; which it would help them set a higher standard and will more likely to achieve more in life. Although people want to succeed in life and become professionals, they have to work a full-time job, in order to support themselves. Rose states that many struggle to get an education “even though the majority of students upon entry do say they want to complete a certificate or degree, many, in fact, shift to shorter term goals, in some instances because of inadequacies in a college’s services and curriculum, but also in response to personal needs, family demands…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays