Imaginary Indian Stereotypes

Great Essays
Social identity, the classification and organization of heterogeneous people based on physical characteristics, is perhaps, one of the most prominent abstraction used in modern discourse. The need to belong to a group has increased; though identification has played a role in how we perceive ourselves and those around us, unfortunately at least one group is put at a disadvantage due to the categorized label that society condemns them off. In Charles Cunningham’s article, To Watch the Faces of the Poor’: Life Magazine and the Mythology of Rural Poverty in the Great Depression, Cunningham speaks of middle-class population wanting to be seen as “the pioneers” (Cunningham 207) as opposed to “blacks” or “white trash” due to the images presented by …show more content…
(Crosby 490) This domesticated, pseudo-Indian is therefore not what the First Nation community and culture are truly about, but a fictitious, romanticized interpretation; an illusory view of the indigenous. Through Crosby’s anthropology course, Crosby discovered how much more the professor knows about indigenous people, ceremonies, ritual and moral than herself who is of Haida/ Tsimshian decent. The eugenic during the first half of the 21st century ranked races and classes as superior, providing scholarly warrant for the privileged white middle class, not to mention the warrant for abusive control and deadly persecution of Indians and other classification. Similarly, Cunningham discussed about the eugenic that Life magazine further emulsify to categorize race and classes to benefit one group, while the other group gets a label that categorizes them of something they do not desire to be associated …show more content…
The construction of an identity is founded and reinforced by the population’s status while at the same time demeaning others, depicted by Life magazine’s interpretation of the “middle-class anxiety about becoming poor, and therefore degrading in [societies] eyes”(Cunningham 207). Cunningham zooms in on the enlarged social gaps that Life tries to increase through racial and social segregation, depicting the white trash as “inherent in their inbred genes or in their profligate ways” (Cunningham 201), while the presentation of blacks as “beneath justice”(Cunningham 204) enforcing that their conditions “should not-be improved”(Cunningham 201). Life Magazine openly demonstrates the creation of “identity”, leaving readers in recognition or disgust; at the time of the Great Depression, when no one was immune to economic hardship. Whites who failed to meet economic standards were often ridiculed as “blacks”, while blacks would much rather prefer to be perceived as “poor” than as “negro”. The degradation of one social class is therefore balanced by the promotion of another, similarly, Delph-Janiurek signify the need to gravitate towards classification as opposed to the distinction between genders by using the tone and pitch of

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The reading assigned is centered around the discussion of social identities given to the reader by Gwyn Kirk and Margo Okazawa-Rey. In this article the discussion of social identities are geared toward the identities we give ourselves and the identities society gives us. Kirk and Okazawa-Rey give plenty examples of how the social groups we tend to place ourselves might not be the same group society places us in. One example used was immigration in the United States. In many places all over the world most people identify with where they are from as their main “identity.”…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This article relates to the Big Picture Question as in the article is talks about how a Indian- American women was considered to be a “high threat” because she had money troubles and visited family abroad a lot. This goes to show how people are stereotyped around the world for their color and are considered to be a risk just because of the things that they do. An Indian-American women's traits were “considered undesirable and threatening when the person possessing them is a South Asian American woman” (Pg. 3). This goes to show how people really do think of different colored people as different as just because of her travelling overseas a lot, she was considered a threat. This is a huge stereotype as not every brown-skinned person is a threat, even though many happen to consider them to be so.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Different social classes come with different perspectives and challenges, usually the belief is that higher society is much happier than those in the lower rank, but not including race into the equation does not give all sides of that story. By evaluating parts in Cane by Jean Toomer, Passing by Nella Larsen, and Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston the untold story of class and race is becomes clear. Color and classism have gone hand in hand for many years and evaluating the lives of characters that are considered the lowest of the low and yet made it up the totem pole brings up an important discussion. The conflicting ideas of race and class actually encourage racism and ruin the lives of characters in the black bourgeoisie.…

    • 1738 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kathleen J. Fitzgerald 's study about the meaning of ethnicity to Americans who get back the native lives and characteristics is tentatively informed and elaborately narrated by those people, whose ethnic journeys she has explored. Her wide-ranging interviews disclose the dominant enthusiasms that keep her informers on course in the face of the demanding biographical archaeological sites many must take on along the way and the cynicism they come across on the path to becoming Indian. This book also makes available another important lens from end to end examination and understanding of the ever-changing American ethnic background. The author studies the rare prospects of the ethnicity of Native Americans.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    These identities can be harmful as they can limit our freedoms and individuality. They can also have more serious implications and can limit one’s ability to lead a normal life as well as threaten their own safety. Kwame Anthony Appiah discusses the struggles of living as an African American in some of his writing, including being defined as and by his race. In his excerpt “Racial Identities”, Kwame Anthony Appiah describes the struggles of living under modern racial stereotypes, suggesting that racially charged social identities can have detrimental effects on one’s individuality and one’s ability to be a functioning member of society. African Americans do not all share the same identity.…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Classism is assumed to be determined by the amount of money a person has. A person’s wallet seems more visible than their heart. In the novel To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, the reader is told about a young girl, Scout, growing up in South Alabama in the 1930’s during the Great Depression. Her father is a respected lawyer who is assigned to defend an African American accused of raping a white girl. The trial for the case finally comes up, and the man’s legal status is decided.…

    • 1148 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Identity” can be seen as a person’s perception of themselves, however, it is becoming more prominent to define “identity” in a social way or how people express themselves based on the demand for acceptance by others. Chris Cunningham, in “To Watch the Faces of the Poor”: Life Magazine and the Mythology of Rural Poverty in the Great Depression”, details the desire for middle-class citizens to be viewed as or compared to “the pioneer” due to the positive reputation given by the media (200). Cunningham describes the effects of labeling through the changing attitudes of citizens towards each other once they were segregated into socio-cultural groups (200). Tom Delph-Janiurek takes an innovative look at the masculine-feminine discrepancies in “Sounding…

    • 1278 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    S. E. Hilton’s novel and popular film The Outsiders expresses a variety of internal and external conflicts including the main conflict in the novel, which is the division and struggle among social class. The two groups, Socs and Greasers, are drastically different, but also similar in a variety of ways. Socs and the Greasers are merely adolescents struggling with personal and social complications that unfold within society. As the greasers are portrayed as low-life scum no-good-for-nothing-dirt-bags, and on the other hand, Socs are depicted as privileged rich kids who catch all the “big breaks.” What determines to where each member of society belongs which group is the individual’s appearance and finance.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Aboriginalities essay “How have settler constructions of aboriginal people affected aboriginal peoples?” The settler voice towards aboriginal peoples, has ingrained constructs i.e. stereotypes, into society. These stereotypes have inflicted harm and severely affected aboriginal people throughout history and to this day, but in what ways and through which medians do these coloniser interpretations express themselves in society? And what are the responses of the aboriginal peoples who are concerned?…

    • 1026 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Native American culture had always intrigued me, even more so when I discovered my grandma was involved in it. My family doesn’t see my grandma often; she lives about four hours south, and it’s usually a one time a year occurrence. Last year my family and I went to visit her. When we got to her house, she was huddled around a group of her great grandchildren in the living room and was telling a story. She was a great storyteller, for she was a part of a time when stories were passed down verbally rather than written.…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Native Americans have endured harsh and cruel punishment since the establishment of the United States of America. Native Americans were murdered, raped, stolen from and placed on a reservation. Now Native Americans have to deal with their culture being stolen as well. The country is divided on this issue. Countless Americans feel it is okay to steal another race’s culture and exploit it for financial gain.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Stereotypes

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Everyone in their life has stereotyped another race or ethnicity. Some can be general knowledge and some can be things we have heard about them either from the media or an encounter you had with a someone part of the race or even ethnicity. Racial stereotypes are false images that people hold about all members of a particular race or ethnicty. In America, we have different racial groups and as well as ethnicity. Racial groups can be defined as a group of people that is said to be different from others because of physical or genetic traits shared among them in the group while ethnicity can be defined as a group of people that shares a common culture, religion or language.…

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In the film Ethnic Notions, African-Americans were poorly portrayed in many different forms of negative stereotypes from the past. These stereotypes were that of a mammy, coon, Uncle Tom, sambo, pickaninnys, and the brute. Even though these racist caricatures were popular in the past unfortunately some forms of them still exist today. The mammy was portrayed as black older woman who was fat, obedient,eager, and loyal.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Analysis Of White Trash

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages

    White trash has become a massive history in America dating back from the colonial period in Jamestown to the present day. Isenberg, in her book about the ‘white trash’ and as ‘the face of a white trash’, explains the unpleasant fine points of our national identity, tying to the America’s social hierarchy and how America has never offered an equal opportunity to all white comers. She gives us a very powerful insight about how the imagery of the class system and the consistency of prejudice is evolving over the years. She also traces on the white stereotype from its root of the British belief that the working class was indeed a separate race from the middle and the upper class who were considered as lazy and stupid. The two major points that Isenberg makes a really convincing claim to us an audience is on the very true face of the class system and the ‘White Trash’ which sheds a light on the history of political demography beginning…

    • 1052 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the United States today we often hear the levels of social order referred to as white or blue collar of the working class, upper, and lower classes. The theme of social classes is most evident in “Male Desire Female Disgust; the Reading of Hustler” when Laura Kipnis states:” the body is a privileged political trope of lower social classes”. Another…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays