Challenger Shuttle Disaster

Superior Essays
Executive Summary
The objective of this literature review was to study about quality could mean the difference between excellence and disaster on a real life project. Therefore, the literature review discussed a space shuttle project the Challenger shuttle disaster. The first part of the literature review discussed the Vaughan’s (1996) analysis, which found the human errors are one of the main reasons of resulting the Challenger shuttle disaster. Also, by outlining Perrow’s (1999) Normal Accident Theory, it argues that complex interaction system regarded as a technical reason that caused the inevitability of this accident. In order to explore how to improve the quality of shuttle projects of NASA, the second part of this literature review outlined
…show more content…
However, during the shuttle flight, the Challenger was broken apart 73 seconds later in Florida. As a result, this launching of this shuttle exploded and killed seven crew members inside the shuttle. The President of America instituted a special Commission to identify the causes of this shuttle disaster. One possible technical cause was the failure of the O-ring seals of the Solid Rocket Booster on the right of the shuttle due to faulty design of the SRB and insufficient low temperature. The failure of O-ring brought hot combustion gases from the booster and burned through the external fuel tank, causing the Challenger damaged. However, after problems searching, the Commission disclosed a lack of communications between different levels of NASA management. The poor management also accounted as one of the main reasons that caused the shuttle …show more content…
The first one developed by Perrow (1999) is System Accident that resulted from complex interactions of various independent factors, and tight coupling of components, which the “domino” effect conducted. It represents that only a part of the entire system fails, there is not going to have enough time to stop these connected elements that affected by this broken system. The second theory developed by Perrow (1999) is Component Failure Accident, which can be described by predictable and visible linear interactions between different parts of s system, and loose coupling in which discontinues the effect from the failed elements. These theories demonstrate in the Challenger shuttle project, the failures of all chain reactions are associated with System Accident, which are common phenomena in this high technical field. They also describe that the difficulties of taking account of those multiple connecting

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Failure Model In Nursing

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Now that the interdisciplinary team has identified the failure modes, they are now look at likelihood of occurrence, the likelihood of detection and the severity of occurrence if the process fails. Each of these categories is given a score between 1 and 10. For example, when considering occurrence, a score of 1 would mean it is highly unlikely that an event will occur and 10 would mean that it is very likely to occur. A score of 1 for detection, means it is likely to be detected and 10 means it will not be detected and for severity 1 would be less severe and a score of 10…

    • 2663 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Challenger did not explode, although it looked that way. The cold temperatures loosened a seal in the right solid-fuel rocket booster, causing hot gas to pour through the seal. The fuel tank then collapsed and as a result, liquid oxygen and hydrogen created a huge fireball around the shuttle; making it look like the Challenger exploded. The crew members did not die instantly. They most likely died of oxygen deficiency due to the loss of cabin pressure as they were descending. The Challenger stayed intact until about 65,000 feet and then began to fall apart and into the Atlantic Ocean, 19 years ago, the United States had lost three astronauts on the ground, but they had never thought to lose anyone mid-flight. This was NASA’s first in flight tragedy.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This speech was written by Ronald Reagan in response to the Challenger Disaster which took place on January 28, 1986 in the Oval Office. This was done to mourn the seven who died in the disaster. This was spoken to the citizens of the United States along with the families of those who died in the disaster and NASA. This speech was the right thing to do because Reagan addressed the people of the United States, stated his emotions with the disaster, and insured people this lose wasn't for nothing.…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Challenger was a horrible tragedy the american public had to witness, but we as a country will not let it get in the way of our future accomplishments. The Challenger was a spacecraft that exploded on January 28, 1986 while its departure to space along with 7 crew members inside. The president of the United States, Ronald Reagan, then delivered the “Address To The Challenger Disaster” to the nation and the crew members families. Reagan crafted the speech to let everyone know they were grieving for the brave crew members but to also let them know we will not let such a disaster stop us from exploring space. Reagan's credibility is the fact he is the United States president, he makes the speech personal by saying “we”…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, their efforts did not meet the standards listed in the NSPE Code of Ethics. As a result, the engineers share some of the blame in the Challenger Disaster. However, while identifying the key issues and causes of the disaster is very important, searching for a specific group of people to blame will not help prevent future disasters. While it may be tempting to place all of the blame on the management or the engineers or even NASA in general, this approach simplifies the case and is simply erroneous. The only way to prevent future disasters like this one is to…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Challenger Shuttle Era

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Challenger space shuttle disaster was the worst moment in the NASA programs history.It starts as a normal day it was going to mark the shuttles 10th successfully launch.The Challenger was expected to perform as expected after being tested for 11 months there were no doubts about the launch. When the shuttle took off everything was normal, but after 73 seconds it exploded killing all 7 crew members including a school teacher.Marking it as the most horrific moment in NASA history.The accident resulted in the shuttle program taking a 2 ½ year break which they resumed from in 1988.…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    On January 28, 1986, the Challenger Explosion stunned the world which changed NASA forever. All seven astronauts aboard the Challenger died. The Challenger Explosion occurred 73 seconds after blasting off. It was the first time a space vehicle of the United States exploded with crew on board. NASA suspended its 1986 launch schedule until they figured out why Challenger exploded. On the Challenger, there was an area of concern in which there was an amount of ice before takeoff on the launch pad. Overnight, temperatures went to a low of 24 degrees and the wind chill reached a low of 10 at the height of the launch tower which was 250 feet. Icicles were present in various places of the launch pad. The launch of the Challenger was put on hold and…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Apollo 13 Research Paper

    • 1797 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The error occurred five years before the Apollo 13 incident while the spacecraft was in Florida. While the technicians were assembling the Apollo 13 spaceship, one of them dropped the second oxygen tank which caused the pipes that directed movement within the tank to become uneven. Technicians had to set the temperature to eighty degrees Fahrenheit so the liquid oxygen that didn’t fully drain could boil off. Instead of reaching eighty degrees the thermostat went all the way up to one thousand degrees Fahrenheit. This caused the oxygen liquid to boil in hours instead of days which burned off the insulation of the wires. A stirrer was triggered on the way to the moon and created an explosion in the oxygen tank which caused hot gas to go through the service module blowing out one wall. The explosion also destroyed their spacecraft's electrical and life support systems and the Apollo 13 astronauts were forced to shut down the command module (Great Events from…

    • 1797 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Vaughan,Diane., 1996, ‘The Challenger Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture and Deviance at NASA’, Published by University of Chicago Press; 1 edition (April 15,1997).To sum up, the Challenger shuttle disaster was famous for NASA’s unfaithful and negligence over the project in the 20th century. The Challenger shuttle disaster, not only due to its destruction causing the dead, but the poor management at NASA, which damaged NASA’s reputation. Perrow (1999) explores the O-ring seal erosion of SRB was one technical issue that caused the Challenger disaster, and Vaughan (1996) argues that the “change is bad” culture of NASA management was the human issue that caused normalization of deviations. Vaughan (1996) argues that managers and engineers…

    • 193 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Challenger Explosion Memo

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The purpose of this memo is to analyze the accessibilityand ethicsof three technicaldocuments inthe Challenger Case Study: Document A: Ray January 1978 Memo, Document B: Ray January 1979 Memo, and Document F: BoisjolyJuly 1985 Memo. The 1986 Challenger explosion stands as one of the most tragic incidents of space travel in US history. Perhaps the most shockingdetail of the accident is that theproblemthat caused the explosion, issues with the O-ring,had been known for years before the launch. However, due to a lack of effective technical communication and, at times, a complete disregard for ethics, the problem was left unresolved. By simply ensuring that all those involved were appropriatelyinformed through accessible technical communication,…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The critical part of the construction process is to make sure the design that was tested, evaluated, and optimized matches the system being constructed (Blanchard). The Challenger space shuttle was constructed by its design fully. Due to its faulty design, the challenger was doomed to fail. The operational use and life cycle support process indicates how long this system, the space shuttle, will last since it will degrade through time, use, and exposure. Lastly, the system retirement and material disposal process indicates how the system will be dispose once it…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The shuttle was intended for the crew to be able to conduct some experiments in outer space and then later re enter Earth. This was not the case as Columbia went up in flames as it was attempting to come back to Earth. The cause of this was that a small hole formed when a piece of debris hit Columbia during its ascension into space. A small piece of foam broke off from an external tank and struck the left wing of the aircraft. This foam left a hole approximately 20 cm in length on the wing of the craft. As the craft attempted to reenter the atmosphere, the shuttle was moving at such a high speed that a substantial heat was produced. The hole allowed the heat of 1300 degrees to enter the aircraft. The temperature increased as the craft got closer to the ground. This high amount of heat caused the shuttle to slowly fall apart. Eventually, the astronauts lost complete control of the…

    • 1459 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After watching the numerous videos on the Challenger Disaster, it is obvious the management decision lacked communication, connected with a management system that allowed NASA to neglect safety requirements, leading to the cause of the Challenger disaster. The management decisions on the Challenger were rushed interested in the shuttle going into space. NASA concerned by the money aspect than the safety of the astronauts. There were obvious signs the shuttle would run into some problems such as the low temperature and nonfunctional O-rings. If I were placed in a similar situation I would express my concerns for safety and the negative possibilities that could happen if the shuttle launched. If someone speaks up their automatically labeled…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    to 1986 Challenger explosion coming into play, CAIB notes on the similarities are that “both…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The limitations that troubleshooting and repair process can have in an organisation is cost, time allocation, access to building, data security and the skill set of technicians. These can cause the troubleshooting and repair process to become disorganized and start to be a bigger problem for the company than intended, in this unit I will explain the problems that can occur.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays