Causes Of The New Deal

Good Essays
The Great Depression was a period of time in America when many people lost their jobs and the unemployment rate in America peaked at 25% for whites and 50% for blacks and latinos. People were struggling to even receive one meal each day and the overall situation of these people was very grim. One long term cause of the Great Depression was the fact that stock market brokers would buy on margin, where the broker pays 10% and the bank pays the rest, and speculation, a risky move where brokers buy a stock because they have potential to raise in price so they sell it within a short span of time. Another long term cause of the Great Depression was the immense panic that caused a high demand for withdrawals in banks, which then caused the banks to …show more content…
The AAA was a program that paid farmers to stop farming so that the crops they grew would increase in demand and therefore, increase in price. This proves that the New Deal was a success because farmers were given compensation for overproducing and could again sell their crops for a reasonable price and make a proper living. The Social Security Admin was also another program that proves that the New Deal was a success. The Social Security Admin gave financial aid to elderly, disabled, and children that may have lost a parent. This proves that the New Deal was a success because the elderly could be taken care of and could quit their jobs, therefore opening more spots for middle aged Americans to take their place and become employed. The FDIC was another program that proves that the New Deal was a success. The FDIC provides insurance of up to $5000 given back if the bank failed to give citizens their money back. This proves that the New Deal was a success because people were now more confident in putting money in banks which in turn allowed the banks to give out loans to others and keep the cycle going so that the bank failures that caused the Great Depression will not …show more content…
Document 3 shows a table and graph of the government’s spending, deficit, and debts. As years passed the debt and deficit continued to increase and the government’s financial situation continued to look increasingly detrimental. This proves that the New Deal was a failure because the government’s debt continued to grow and caused America to be in debt every single year. Document 4 is a political cartoon that portrays America as sick, FDR as a doctor, and Congress as a man in a maid costume. America is trying all these New Deal remedies but remains sick and FDR is continuing to spend more money and create more programs. This proves that the New Deal was a failure because the cartoon implies that Congress is serving the President, which is not supposed to happen, and the America remains ill despite using all of the remedies that FDR continues to spend money on. Document 7 is an except from an online history book. It describes how all of the New Deal programs were discriminatory towards blacks, stating that the AAA forced many blacks of their land for whites and blacks that had jobs were given lower pay. Whites were also given priority over blacks for job opportunities. This proves that the New Deal was a failure because the New Deal was intended to help everyone in America but actually hurt

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    According to the article “The Great Depression Brings Economic Crisis” from the book Great Events, The Stock Market Crash of 1929 caused one of the largest economic depressions in the history of the United States causing many American families to lose nearly all of their money. When this occurred, the United States government did very little to help the citizens of the United States leaving families and the working class to fight for their survival. The Stock Market Crash of 1929 changed the lives of the United States working class as the crash caused money loss, job loss, poor living conditions, lower wages, and struggles for food across America for the working class during the 1930s. The Stock Market Crash of 1929 caused several losses for…

    • 1472 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Small farmers were run out of their businesses and some were even ran out of their homes due to insufficient funds. Housing construction was getting higher and higher to be able to pay for it so by the 1920s it had fell drastically. People thought that borrowing money was going to be the “Gold Rush of Stocks” so many people were trying to get money. Rapid growth in bank credits and loans had a major effect into the fall of the Stock Market. Margin millionaires had lost all of their money by the time the Stock Market fell due to stocks being overpriced and people could no longer afford to pay for them.…

    • 1206 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The American economy began to see a drop in consumer spending as well as stock prices continually rising. Because of this there was a lack of sell towards specific goods and production began to slow, specifically in automotive industries and big factory companies. As months went on we come across the date October 24, 1929 or what is best known as Black Thursday. Black Thursday was “When panicked sellers traded nearly 13 million shares on the New York stock exchange and investors suffered 5 billon dollars in losses”. Due to this major event in history many investors were totally washed and out, and left with absolutely nothing.…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Poverty increased greatly among the Hispanics and African Americans, households of women, and working class adults between the ages of 18-34. If not for the stimulus package of 2009, the impact of the Great Recession would have been a lot worse. Federal deficits created a program placing a debt ceiling that triggered a spending cut in order to control spending which in turn affected the poor. This was by far the most dramatic employment contraction since the Great Depression. Even after the economy stopped shrinking in 2009, its growth was not strong enough to create the jobs needed to keep up with the population growth, or the backlog of workers who lost their jobs during the…

    • 1857 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    America has gone through many hard times before, but never has it suffered a burden as profound and extensive as the Great Depression. The Great Depression was a dark period of groundbreaking decline in economic activity in the United States that lasted from 1929 to 1939. This impacted the lives of millions of Americans ranging from wealthy business owners to families living in poverty. Not only was this depression an economic catastrophe, but it was a social and political catastrophe as well. Over the course of these few years, consumer spending and investment dropped significantly which in turn caused steep declines in industrial output and increased levels of unemployment as failing companies laid off workers.…

    • 1391 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There are 7.125 billion people in this world and more than 3 billion of these people live in poverty (“11 Facts About Global Poverty”). Poverty leads to hunger, disease, and death, and because of poverty, many people are forced to live in poor living conditions and sometimes on the street. Poverty is the result of economic issues and affects many lives. The biggest problem that my generation is going to face in the future is the economy. The weakening economy will be my generations largest challenge because many people will struggle to obtain employment, pay off debt, and must face the current lack of wage growth.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There were many factors that led to the Great Depression like the stock market crash, bank runs, the dust bowl, and the new deal. The Great Depression was an economic downturn between 1929-1939. Many people lost their jobs and did not have enough money to keep a roof over their head. Only the rich could manage while the poor suffered. Both the rich and poor were scared, and the rich even hid their money so no one could take it from them.…

    • 1946 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Great Depression Dbq

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The Great Depression began in 1929 and lasted almost 10 years; It was a time period when the America had the most severe economic. The majority of American left their home with dream to earn money to support their family; even teenagers left school to get a chance to work in order to find a better life on their own. People who found a work during the Great Depression would have a bad living condition provided. The owner housed them with a shanty, barn, or even an open field. However, the wage dropped dramatically since the large amount of workers came for works, even if the whole family had work, the money would not be enough to support them.…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This will make it easier for others who need jobs to find them. Working families would have more time for community life and their life will be much less stressful. Americans would start to reclaim the middle-class by having more money readily at hand. This money will allow them to buy products on a daily basis that they may not have before and this is beneficial for the economy because the money will be recirculate into the local financial districts. Another primary reason that raising minimum wage is good is that raising it is good for the economic recovery and the shift will get the economy back on track, spending power has to be in the hands and readily available of those who actually spend in the local economies.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After Black Tuesday, millions of shares became worthless and investors who had bought on margin were “wiped out”(1). During the 1920s, Americans were always wanting more and more which lead to them buying things on credit that they could not afford to pay back. The greed of the American people led them to make reckless budgeting decisions that got them in huge debt that would weaken the American economy. The uneven distribution of income among the working class also contributed to the depression. According to Sarah Carroll, the average person’s wages stayed the same, despite the climb in prices for goods (3).…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays