Causes Of Disobedience

Superior Essays
Howard Zinn once said, “Historically, the most terrible things - war, genocide, and slavery - have resulted not from disobedience, but from obedience.” In Zinn’s book A People’s History Of the United States, and in history, there are many cases of atrocities that involve disobedience and not obedience. Obedience is when one complies to a certain authority and disobedience, on the other hand, is when one refutes it. Zinn’s statement that disobedience leads to the world’s most terrible things is fallacious because of the many atrocities in history that began due to disobedience and how it has exacerbated many situations. One reason why disobedience leads to the world’s most terrible things is that it causes those terrible things. An example …show more content…
One example of this would be the Indian Removal Act. The Indian Removal Act which was signed by Andrew Jackson ordered all Indians to abandon their land and move westward. This was largely due to a number of white settlers traveling into the newly bought Louisiana territory purchased by Thomas Jefferson. To clear the way for the settlers, Indians had to be removed. This was an extremely terrible act towards the Indians as they have lived in their lands for many years and are now forced to adapt to new lands. However, one group of Indians, the Seminoles, fought back and disobeyed the Indian Removal Act. This is shown in Zinn’s book as, “One tribe—the Seminoles—decided to fight… Violence between whites and Seminoles now erupted… they murdered white families, captured slaves, destroyed property… It was an eight-year war. It cost $20 million and 1,500 American lives” (Page 144-146). Notably, the Seminoles disobeyed the Indian Removal Act and waged war. This war ended in huge expenses and a monumental amount of deaths. If the Seminoles were instead to comply with the act, the atrocity wouldn’t have had so many casualties. As shown, the Seminoles were disobedient which worsened their situation. Another example of this would be in 1919, after World War I where around 100,000 workers went on strike in Seattle for higher wages. This was the year after World War I where worker wages have been controlled very strictly because of the costs of the war. Although their situation was already inadequate, the strike made it worse. The government saw this as a radical resistance against order, or as many would put it: disobedience. This led to the government belligerently handling this by having the army arrest many union leaders and harassing IWW (Industrial Workers of The World) members. This is described in Zinn’s book as, “the IWW idea of the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Native American land and culture were impacted negatively by the western expansion of the United States due to the fact that many lost their land, were stripped of their rights, and some even died. After learning and analyzing the 1800s, it is clear that Native Americans had to fight for the simply things that most people today take for granted. For instance, during this time period Native Americans were constantly having to battle the United States government for land. The U.S. citizens and government pushed the Native Americans out west onto The Plains. On page 80 in the American History: Reconstruction to the Present textbook, it says, “White settlers believed the Plains region was too dry for farming.…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Organized Labor DBQ

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Great Railroad Strike of 1877 became the first nationwide strike, which was caused by the wages being cut. It had occurred during the depression of 1870s, which made it more difficult for the workers. The strike reached to a serious point where federal troops had to be brought in and fired upon the strikers. Close to 100 people died in this strike. The image and reputation of the labor unions plummeted in the public’s eye.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of them took drastic measures such as organizing strikes, using violence and even murder to obtain better pay and work conditions. For instance, the railroad strike of 1877 claimed 100 lives. This strike was caused by a wage cut. Another strike that affected workers and even the American population was the protest at the Haymarket Square, during which a bomb was used. This terrorized the public and the term “anarchism” developed a negative connotation.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The great world war was a war that was pointless, the war caused conflict to all the countries that participated in the war. World war one caused the death of many people the war killed 2 percent of the world population killing 16.2 million soldiers and civilians. The war also cost more money than any other war, the war lasted July 28, 1914, to November 11, 1918. At the end of the war, treaty of Versaille was made to destroy Germany the treaty is said to be the one that leads to world war 2 the treaty did not really help make peace with all the countries. Us also had key players and nations that had goals throughout the entire war the nations also have failers when trying to end the war in pieces.…

    • 1860 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Red Scare Essay

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages

    During World War I, many workers joined labor unions to fight for the improvement of their working conditions. President Wilson, who supported these laborers asked them to wait until the war terminates, then they could tell him their demands. When the war ended, the workers asked for better working conditions,an increase in their payments and less working hours. When the workers’ demands were not fulfullied, there was an increase in labor movements. Millions of workers started striking and caused many factories to close down.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Seminole Indians were also part of the tribes which were ushered out of their homeland in the west. After the ratification of the Indian Removal Act the Seminole tribe encountered the harsh force of the United States. The Seminole fought back in an effort to protect their tribe and their land. Many homes of Seminole people were demolished and their occupants were arrested. The Treaty of Payne’s Landing was signed on May 9, 1832, it surrendered any existing land in Florida owned by the Seminole.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Once federal troops were set in Pennsylvania, “they mounted an assault on the strikers located in the heart of the city that caused the deaths of many individuals” (EU News). Throughout the entirety of the strike, President Hayes continued to send troops city to city, suppressing the strikes and killing the strikers spirits. The reactions that the strikers exhibited ultimately show how American views of law enforcement have changed. The Great Upheaval was the first incident that paved the way of which Americans began to hold their own beliefs towards law enforcement. Though, as the years progress, police brutality cases increasingly worsened.…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Russo-Japanese War, Russia and Japan were battling over Korea and Manchuria. Both countries signed contracts over the regions, but Russia broke them. Japan responded by attacking Russians at Port Arthur in Manchuria. Russians got news of this, and that led to a revolt in the middle of the war. On Bloody Sunday, 200,000 works walked to the czar’s palace in St. Petersburg, but the czar’s soldiers mistook them for revolutionaries planning to attack, so they killed or hurt thousands of Russian works.…

    • 1022 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These wars caused the deaths of many Native Americans and their culture was decimated. As a result of these wars, Native Americans were pushed out of their land. By the time of the American Revolution, Native Americans had been pushed out of Virginia and many parts of North Carolina, Georgia, and South Carolina. The relationship between the settlers and Native Americans resulted in armed conflicts because their cultures were very different. Because they didn't understand each other, they went to war several times.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wounded Knee Racism

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages

    During the time of the battle of Wounded Knee there were also other huge events and things happening such as congress taking Oklahoma from Indians and forcing them from their lands in the east. Battle of Little Bighorn which was a huge battle between Native American tribes and the government where we lost 236 soldiers to Sioux and Cheyenne and the Sitting Bull which ties into this battle because it deals with Sioux tribe and this event then led to the huge massacre in…

    • 1068 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays