Case Study: The Ethics Of Testing And Screening

Good Essays
Chapter 11 Summary and Case Study: The Ethics of Testing and Screening
The reliability of machines is not always sufficient in the processing of information. As technology is the forefront of processing data, ethical complications manifest from the incorrect interpretation of testing involving diagnosis and health screening. As the results of the test are concluded, additional concerns develop such as the risk of disclosing personal information, the possibility of losing a job, inability to purchase health insurance or lawful prosection. Besides testing for diagnosis, screening for case findings stigmatize the individuals involved in the testing. Moreover, disparagement of a specific population is deceptive when screening case for discoveries
…show more content…
The goals from the patient perspective of testing focuses on the contributing factor; will the results bring a quality of life or do more harm. The central core of the health care professional in the process of collecting data to arrive with a pertinent diagnosis related to the patient signs and symptoms, the results of the lab work and further diagnostic testing depending on the patient diagnosis. However, certain circumstances, over-testing are possibly the result of ruling out certain diagnosis or unnecessary testing that is not required. Over-testing may be due from incorrect or falsified interpreted information received from the patient in a health screening.
Accuracy of testing is a process that requires a continuous review to improve testing processes.
Inaccurate testing will possibly contribute to an increase in cost that will become a problem to the healthcare institution. Also test resulting in false positives or negatives hinder not only the institution but also involve grief for the patient. It is necessary that interpretations of tests are reviewed by qualified individuals knowledgeable in the field. There should also be a collective agreement of the findings within the health care team. In addition the risk of testing should be proportionately communicated to the patient including the benefits, dangers and outcomes from any procedure.
Therefore, informed consent is very
…show more content…
Mary actions in falsifying the results of her friend’s test were unethical. As the case study discuss, Mary was aware that some of the test used to detect drug use was insufficient. However, the moral way for Mary to address this issue would be to either use another form of testing to validate the findings or to bring the faulty use of the equipment to Management attention.
Are there any cases for which Mary would be justified in telling her friend that he had tested positive and should push for a second and more accurate test?
Unfortunately, it is not Mary place to disclose the information of the test to her friend. If the friend did inquire about the results, she should advise him to contact the employer. Because of HIPPA regulations, the disclosing of information to any individual outside your scope of practice is unlawful. However, Mary possibly can indirectly provide the information without jeopardizing her position as an employee for the laboratory.
Is Mary ethical in working for a company that lets workers lose their jobs without sufficient

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Communication within a healthcare system involves communication among the healthcare providers and between the provider and the patient. The problem could involve either miscommunication or lack of it, which results in errors such as mis-documentation, inaccurate diagnostic tests and treatment options and non-adherence by the patient. When healthcare providers do not effectively communicate, it is impossible for them to provide effective care. In addition, practitioner- patient relationship is important because the patient needs to be able to understand the problems and take part in the decision making process. This motivates the patient to adhere better to the care plan and to consult the healthcare provider whenever there is a problem, without any hesitation.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Do No Harm In Nursing

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Once the action is reported by the party, a group of people such as risk management, quality improvement team, and many others gather to analyze the situation that occurred. Taking all factors and even possibilities into account the team will have an appropriate solution to prevent the reported action in the future. Having the ability to report any possible and actual errors in order for them to be analyzed and configured to provide better care is a critical aspect of healthcare. Without the availability to advance safe practice, not only will safety of the client suffer, but also the client’s trust in the nursing profession will…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Despite taking managerial steps and spreading well-known awareness of these difficulties in the health care field, current management plans and strategy recommendations are not effectively working to provide excellent care to the patients. These could be due to the challenges of cost, quality, and an aging population. Thus, the time has come for a adopting new dimensions and use new strategies more unselfishly, policy-focused approach to modify the inconsistences between management and policy makers in healthcare administration (Lantz, 2008, pp. 291-298) The health care systems in the U.S. face a several problems and serious challenges related to access to the care, quality, cost and use of infrastructure. Therefore, the field of health care leadership in demand for guidance and ideas for transformational change.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gathering data about a particular outcome, and attaining detailed information only found in patient medical records can be difficult and costly to obtain. Outcome measures reflect the needs that are important to patients and should be therefore be developed with patient needs and preferences in mind. It is also important to remember the impact social determinants of health and differences in patient population when developing health outcome measure. The last measure of quality improvement is patient experience measures. These measures offer feedback on the patients’ experience based on care they received.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Emily Munson Case Study

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages

    First, she believes it is partially her fault because she did not lock up the medicine cabinet in a timely manner. Secondly, Emily does not have solid proof of the stealing, and does not want to jeopardize her relationship with Sandra if she is wrong. Due to the…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Safety In Healthcare

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There are also factors that could sway to results of the study. If participants decide not to take maters seriously by not reporting an injury it could cause an imbalance of data. Overall conclusion The hospital employees are what make healthcare possible for people in need. In order to keep hospitals running there needs to be professionals to work without having risks on their safety. Occupational safety of the healthcare professional is of importance to not just them individually but everyone.…

    • 961 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In investigating medical errors, sustained while in a healthcare setting, particularly those related to the administration of medication, the finding was that often these errors was because medications and other solutions taken from their original containers and placed into unlabeled containers. The recommendation is to label all medications, particularly those taken out of the original packaging. Alarms in clinical settings are to alert caregivers of potential patients’ problems, but often malfunctioning of these can cause harm to patient. The Joint Commission hope to reduce the harm associated with clinical alarm systems. The organization hopes that with proper management and regular maintenance of these, this will reduce harm to patients.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The collegial model stresses the practice of informed consent and communication between physician and patient. In the unfortunate case of Canterbury versus Spence, had the patient believed he was properly informed about the procedure, there likely would not have been a suit. Not only do patients suffer when they are ill informed of the procedure they will undergo, but doctors face many consequences when the information provided is lacking or misunderstood. Doctors are constantly made to fear that the patient will seek legal retribution when outcomes are unexpected; the threat of a malpractice or negligence suit is constantly looming about. “Failure by a doctor to properly provide the…

    • 1882 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Vaccines: Article Analysis

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is also unethical to let a human die in a trial of a new drug, but they are not comparable because one was intentional and the other accidental. The author is trying to use ethos and pathos to make you question the motives and the testing of vaccines. Perkins is also trying to make readers feel sympathy for those who suffer from vaccination testing, and use that sympathy to arise anger towards corporations. The…

    • 1319 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Mike Lynn: Whistleblower

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Cisco and ISS also had a responsibility to protect their own data and also the data of their clients to whom they provided cyber security. In future maybe the company would’ve changed its way without being exposed to lawsuits and hackers. Mike Lynn left them in a really bad situation as they had to change or modify their systems to avoid problems that were created by the leakage of company information. Mike Lynn may have done the right thing but it was still illegal and harmful to the company. It’s extremely illogical for a company to reveal its own secrets and flaws at a conference where they know it can hurt them very badly.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays