Business Case Study: Clevertech Inc.

Good Essays
Situation 2: Trade Secrets The main individuals (stakeholders) that could possibly be affected by this decision would be OpenTech (The company as a whole, as well as employees), CleverTech Inc. (Again, company as a whole as well as employees), and the decision-maker (myself). There are many legal implications and potential risks that arise if CleverTech Inc’s trade secrets are used within any of OpenTech’s products. Many detrimental risks would arise to OpenTech if a connection were to be found. Also, the decision-maker could face many legal risks posed by CleverTech Inc. It should be strongly noted also that CleverTech Inc. did not take the precautions of claiming superimposing intellectual property over their designs. Being that CleverTech’s …show more content…
In the case of law, “reasonable efforts” must be taken by the company in order to fully make a strong claim in court if there was dismissal of trust between the company and its relative employee (Evans, 2012). CleverTech did not focus on claiming full intellectual rights over the the designs and ideas; however, with their management consistently reminding employees about the importance of their trade secrets - this may suffice in the court of law that needed precautions were taken. If CleverTech somehow found OpenTech to be using their trade secrets in a design product, CleverTech may be in a fair position to submit a lawsuit against OpenTech (Evans, 2012). This could be highly detrimental to the much smaller company, OpenTech. Likewise, if CleverTech does not win the lawsuit, OpenTech’s decision to use the trade secrets and make them OpenSource and available to all could put CleverTech out of the race to market. Ethically, the obligation lies with the current company you work for - not a potential competitor or inflictor. Even if it seems that no harm could be done by creating an unrelated product using CleverTech’s design, the OpenSource aspect may be detrimental to the company the decision maker pays obligations too. It should also be noted that the decision maker could also be potentially sued in the dismissal of trust established by CleverTech (Martin, …show more content…
The decision maker may gain great benefits from joining OpenTech, but also faces the serious risk being sued by CleverTech if there were to be a connection found between the companies and their respective designs. Also there is an underlying moral obligation that follows the decision maker in which if OpenTech makes CleverTech’s trade secrets fully transparent, CleverTech may suffer greatly in its quest to reach to market. The repercussions from not reaching to market fast enough may put CleverTech, and all of its employees in great risk, even though it may benefit OpenTech greatly. OpenTech also may suffer if CleverTech decides to also attack it with a lawsuit. This could put the small company, including all of the employees/the decision maker, in a great

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Mike Lynn: Whistleblower

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Cisco and ISS also had a responsibility to protect their own data and also the data of their clients to whom they provided cyber security. In future maybe the company would’ve changed its way without being exposed to lawsuits and hackers. Mike Lynn left them in a really bad situation as they had to change or modify their systems to avoid problems that were created by the leakage of company information. Mike Lynn may have done the right thing but it was still illegal and harmful to the company. It’s extremely illogical for a company to reveal its own secrets and flaws at a conference where they know it can hurt them very badly.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Business Ethics Essay

    • 1119 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Companies generally want to maintain their ethical values when conducting business. Nonetheless, companies still end up having to recall their products even if their intention was not to sell an unfit product. Violating general product safety is considered unethical because the business is causing harm to undeserving people and going against their principles. Some companies many change a material or component of their product to a cheaper version in order to increase profit. While this act may be in the ethical realm, if the change in manufacturing makes the product less safe, then it is putting the customers in danger—therefore being unethical.…

    • 1119 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    To prevent future occurrences, Walexron should not chance any safety issues, no matter how unimportant they seem. They should put safety first, which will show their consumers that they put them first. Employees should not be able to hold enough stock in the large company so issues that like those of Lis and Denaly would not affect other stock holders. While the situation is unfair, if their share of stock was held to a minimum the situation could have gone undetected. In the future Walexron should enlighten their employees on the issues of insider information.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For one reason,this can bring unwanted negative media attention that may be harmful to their reputation and bottom line;since they are probably still looking for an investor,if they don't get one more layoffs may occur. Another reason ,since Allen has already been fired so any attempt at a lawsuit would infinge on Allen's First Amendment right of freedom of speech. I believe this relates to the utilitarianism theory(book) which in this situation is the one that produces the greatest benefits,in this case several employees not getting layoffs because the company didn't get negative policy from the media,and was able to get an investor;and Allen was able to use his first amendment right but not without consequences. How can ExtremeNet’s leadership best respect the rights of Allen Lopez and ExtremeNet? Explain the impact of your ethical decision on Allen Lopez and the company.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Despite all of their potential benefits, IT outsourcing entails risks that could lead to undesirable results opposite of the expected advantages (Bouchaib Bahli, Suzanne Rivard). capabilities in the long run since there is too much dependency on external sourcing. The major risks related to IT outsourcing are described below: 1. Security and Confidentiality risks: The vendor can access all the confidential information and any other privacy resources that the organization usually regards as classified and personnel. This is a huge risk issue since it touches the security and the staff rights of the company.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Protecting one’s intellectual property can be used to prevent competitions or anyone else from using the names of your products or bands, your inventions, the design or look of your products, the things you write, make and or produce for their own profit without your consent. Keep an intellectual property a secret until it’s registered if it’s not protected by an automatic right. Once it’s available publicly, a non-disclosure agreement can’t protect an IP as it only prevents and stops another from telling anyone else about it or using it for themselves. Understanding your rights and how the law can help you is vital and essential in securing and protecting your business’ future success. The creator’s right on the intellectual property prevents others form copying or otherwise exploiting the work actually produced by the creator.…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ramona's Pringle Summary

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This principle should be applied in this scenario- with tech developers and victims. Communication on all levels needs to take place in order to evaluate the ethical and legal aspects of Stalkerware. With greater discussion from both sides, there could be an interrogation of Stalkerware's existence which could result in a limited profit growth. However, profiting off at the expense of an individual's safety whilst violating their privacy is a dangerous means of business practice; not only has it inflicted damage on victims but also will, in turn, hurt the business as well. Having more communication between the two parties can result in more technologies being constructively created while ensuring the safety of individuals who won't be subjected to online domestic…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A consumer wants to know what information a company is holding, without giving hackers a way to view that information. This culminates into creating a false sense of security to the consumer. The data that Google provides may be useful to a consumer, but it 's exponentially more dangerous in the hands of a hacker. To solve this Google needs to institute stronger safety protections when using My Activity in Google. Google should allow this service only on computers that a consumer has verified access on before.…

    • 1502 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Madoff Fraud Case Study

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Again, if an investment firm was planned and created to perpetuate a Ponzi scheme, one can only take the blue print from BMIS and make improvements to it. However, since this question is asking for a more comprehensive answer, we need not just look at the firms’ organizational controls but we should look at other agencies and or auditing firms as well. First, the most important organizational control to implement in a case such as this one is a whistleblower program. However, one might argue; if the top is corrupt and did not formed an independent audit committee to oversee the organizational structure and controls there is not much one can do from the inside. Since the article inferred that collusion was rampant throughout the firm.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Owen may be upset to find out about Luke knowing all along, however, the ethical thing to do is to keep company information private. We can also apply the Utilitarianism method to conclude that the most affected or harmed by this situation would be the company since Luke’s decision may lead to other consequences. If more people find out about the change in property value, then more people would be opposed to the announcement. Luke cannot guarantee that Owen won’t tell others either voluntarily or involuntarily, as in someone over hearing him speaking about the situation. With that in mind, Luke should keep to himself what he knows.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays