Muhammed V. Assisted Suicide Case Summary

Amazing Essays
The court will likely hold Muhammed as a LPPF, and deny his cause of action in defamation against COMQWEST. In order to establish a defamation action, the defamatory article must be an intentional publication with set of false factual statements which caused injury to the victim. In this case, COMQWEST’s article has met the requirements, however, the court will likely hold Muhammed as a LPPF, so that he has to prove the COMQWEST acted with actual malice in publishing the defamatory article, that is, with knowledge that it was false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not. Muhammed is a LPPF because, first, he was involved in two public controversies, the legalization of assisted suicide and the gubernatorial election; second, …show more content…
Kevorkian’s proposal, Muhammed sought to influence the outcome of legalization of assisted suicide. According to Muhammed’s interview “we all dressed in those skimpy little hospital gowns that cover nothing in back and wrapped chains around us to signify that Dr. K and the laws he advocated would leave the terminally ill exposed to die against their will.” The purpose of this protest was to persuade the White House not to legalize assisted suicide, and appealed to the public to prohibit assisted suicide. Therefore, Muhammed’s participation in the protest against legalization of assisted suicide in front of the White House was voluntary injection, because he was voluntarily injecting himself into public’s eyes and seeking to influence the outcome of that …show more content…
Even though Muhammed participated in the discussion by using his screen name of “DignifiedDying”, people can easily find out his full information by looking at his interview with the COMQWEST or his biography which posted by Muhammed himself on COMQWEST. Thus, knowing that he has already identified himself under his screen name, Muhammed still willingly participated in the discussion. Moreover, COMQWEST is a website with more than 500,000 plus members, although the chatroom allowed only 40 participants, all members of COMQWEST were able to view the discussion. Thus, Muhammed’s participation in the discussion has inserted himself into the public’s eyes. Furthermore, the online discussion was intended for people to debate about Connor’s recent controversial policy, and Muhammed’s purpose to participate in the discussion was to debate against those who disagreed with Connor. Thus, his participation could potentially affect the audiences’ voting decision, and consequently influence the outcome of the election. Therefore, Muhammed’s participation in the online discussion about Connor’s recent controversial policy was voluntary

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Defamation on Social Media Should Be Sued Defamation is an action of creating or spreading the wrong statement about someone. The defamatory statement is not in the form of opinion but in the form of fact. In order to claim a statement is defamation, the statement must be communicated to public. “Can You Be” (n.d.) explained that defamation is classified as either slander which is the spoken defamatory statement or libel which is the act of making written defamation. Defamation on social media should be sued because it spreads negativity to the society, trespasses someone’s privacy and destroys the future of someone.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The two cases discussed above are a good example of understanding the differences between the defamation and the remarks made out of normal or ordinary meaning of words. In the case of Berkoff vs. Burchill, the case specifies that a specific meaning was separated and the preliminary issue is in need of finding whether the meaning is capable of being defamatory. Mr Price QC, while defending his clients states the characteristics for defamation as a solution to publications damaging any individual’s reputation. But the term reputation can be comprehended in multiple ways. Any individual held as a figure of fun is automatically defeated in his claim to seek damages as a achieving plea for a comment or even if compensation he receives will be…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I chose to write my paper on Euthanasia which is also called assisted suicide. This is where physicians and doctors can help a person take deliberate action with the express intention if ending a life to relieve intractable suffering. So when they chose to end their life they use this was because it is known to be ending a life in a painless manner. There are many different countries where assisted suicide is against the law, and it is illegal to help someone kill themselves regardless of what their circumstances are. In the UK the maximum sentence for someone who helps with an assisted suicide is 14 years in prison and in the USA the laws vary in every state.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The government should not interfere in the most intimate and personal decision of citizens—the choice to end their lives (Rudden, Lawrence). The government likes to interfere in many of our personal lives, from spying to keeping tabs on all of our personal information. why should we let the government tell people with a terminal illness that they do not have the right to self-termination. The state of Oregon enacted the Death with Dignity Act in 1997, which made it the first state to legalize physician-assisted suicide. However, the U.S. Department of Justice has challenged the law on the grounds that prescribing drugs to be used in an assisted suicide is not a legitimate medical purpose for those drugs (Rudden, Lawrence).…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Enouen argues the immoral aspects of assisted suicides and the dangers of unused drugs. Bowden argues for the rights of all people to choose what path they want to take when patients become terminally ill, showing respect for religious conservatives who choose not to take it but not appreciating them for pushing their values on others who go against them. A common ground can be reached between both of these authors. Although Enoun is a pro-life educator and Bowden is a pro-choice advocate, assisted suicide can be made legal, or acceptable, if the lethal drug can be given only to patients who, themselves, deem fit to take it; and, after the drug is prescribed, if the patient decides not to take it its whereabouts are monitored so it does not fall into the wrong…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Persuasive Speech The Right to Kill a Human Specific Purpose (Goal/Objective): To educate my classmates on why Physician- Assisted suicide should not be legalized. Thesis Statement (Content Overview): Death is a hard concept to swallow through physician- assisted suicide it becomes even more difficult one will lack trust in a doctor- patient relationship, economical motives, and lack of depression diagnosis. INTRODUCTION (about 1 min) – should include the following “I will apply dietetic measures for the benefit of the sick according to my ability and judgment; I will keep them from harm and injustice. I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect”( Tyson). This line from the Hippocratic Oath is what doctor pledge to do for their patients and protect them against.…

    • 1539 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Somerville, a physician and an ethicist, suggest that if physician assisted suicide were to become legal “we would have the duty not to treat people who attempt suicide” (Boudreau and Somerville 5). The fear of suicide becoming a normal event in our society exists in the people who oppose physician assisted suicide. However, the biggest issue that emerges when so much attention is brought to the subject of PAS is the “suicide contagion” phenomenon. Jacqueline C. Harvey, Ph. D., a bioethicist, defines suicide contagion as a phenomenon in which “exposure to suicide leads to an increase in the likelihood of suicide” (Harvey 111).…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In regard to physician-assisted suicide, this practice would go against the preservation of life because its viewed as a direct killing of someone. Physician-assisted suicide would not be justified because it 's the taking of a life despite the patient voluntarily request. According to the American Medical Association, the association of professional physicians states, “Physician-assisted suicide is unethical and fundamentally inconsistent with the pledge physicians make to devote themselves to healing and life” (Vaughn 293). They live by the oath to preserve life of the patient and do everything in their power to keep their patients…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I. Incitement of imminent violence The first issue is what constitutional argument could be made against Tax’s conviction under the Sedition Statute. Under the US constitution First Amendment, laws that limit freedom of speech are unconstitutional. However, certain types of unprotected speeches that advocate violence, fighting words, hostile audience speech, obscene speech and defamatory speeches can be regulated. Fighting words is a speech that is more than annoying or offensive and causes a genuine likelihood of imminent violence by hostile audience. The speech must advocate illegal conduct, not just an abstract.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Active Euthanasia is the practice of injecting a patient with a lethal dose of medication for primary intention of ending the patient’s life (Meier, Emmons, etal 1). Physician assisted suicide plays with morals of the patient and even the doctor (“25 Surprising Physician” 4). The practice of ending a life can be a tricky process. The doctors want to make sure that the patient realizes what they are going to do. Most doctors would not mind euthanasia, and 24% of…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays