Carrie Movie Comparison

Improved Essays
In 2013, Kimberley Pierce directed a remake of Brian De Palma’s horror film classic Carrie. The arrangement stays the same, but by using a little modernization, additional character development, and new scenes here and there, Peirce essentially reinvents the same familiarity while making the film her own. Pierce jettisons the focus off of Carrie’s tumultuous relationship with her mother and puts a microscope on Carrie’s desire to fit in. While Brian De Palma’s version focuses on the sexual deprivation of a teenage girl, Kimberley Pierce’s version focuses on the dangers of teenage bullying. Because cyberbullying was a prevalent topic in 2013, it makes perfect sense why this film places Carrie’s school misfortunes at the center. In 2013, there …show more content…
In the 1976 film, every telekinetic occurrence was accompanied by horrific music. This was a forewarning that Carrie White was going to use her telekinetic power for something malicious. Pierce treats Carrie’s discovery of her newly found power likening to a superhero discovering their powers. In the 1976 film, when Carrie White is researching telekinesis the scene is accompanied by horror music. In the 2013 film, when Carrie White is researching telekinesis on the computer, it is accompanied by Hallmark music. The filmmaker does this in order to remove the audience from seeing Carrie White as the villain. If the audience identifies Carrie as the villain, the effectiveness of the movie goes down the drain. If Pierce has Michael Myers music playing in the background the audience recognizes her as the monster. Pierce wants Carrie’s supernatural powers to be seen as neither virtuous nor corrupt. This neutral view of her powers allows the audience to understand that she only used her powers when she felt like she had no other choice. This is a warning to the audience that everybody has a breaking point. Unless the audience had watched the older version of Carrie, they would not have expected her to go on a psychopathic rampage. Consequently, the director is warning teenagers to end bullying because the victim will eventually retaliate …show more content…
By making Carrie White’s mother a sympathetic character, Pierce removes the focus off the tumultuous mother-daughter relationship. In the 1976 version, Margaret White was a woman who hated women and was devoutly religious. She spouted every anti-female scriptural reference she could find, and she didn’t even believe in sex after marriage. This oppressed Carrie dreadfully, and when she campaigned against her mother, it seemed as if she disobeys patriarchy as well. In the 2013 remake, it seems as if Margaret White may be mentally ill. Also, she makes it no secret that she loves her daughter, she tells her several times throughout the film that she loves her. This version of Margaret White also seems to be more serviceable than the previous one. Margaret White picks up and drops off Carrie to school and seems very concerned with Carrie’s well-being. She works at a dry cleaner’s rather than in her living-room, and she dresses a lot more normal than her predecessor

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In 2004, the movie “Mean Girls” was released and caught the interest of many people across the world. Teenage Cady Heron who is played by actress Lindsay Lohan, was homeschooled in Africa by her parents. When she has to move, she gets to experience public school and how it can be so cruel and divide students into their own cliques. Cady quickly finds out how her soon to be new group of friends earned the nickname “The Plastics”. “Mean Girls” is a great example of the Hero’s Journey because it shows every step clearly and how Cady becomes a whole new person trying to maintain two different worlds.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alice the Slave of Bullying Alice was a perfect “cliché” to take all the wrath of her friends. In the book “The Truth About Alice”, the author Jennifer Mathieu describe the character Alice as a perfect victim to be bullying by others. When Alice says “I’m such a cliché, aren’t? Single mother. Absent father.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brave Movie Comparison

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Bravery and Fear are very different, but related in the story of Rikki-tikki. The book is different from the movie in many ways. Rudyard Kipling is the author of Rikki-Tikki. One example of Rikki being Brave is when he follows Nagaina, the evil cobra, into her snake hole. The stories are different and similar in many ways including events, conflict, and character roles.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Outsiders Comparison

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Comparison Over the Three Curtis Brothers: Jahrell Teodoro In the book, “The Outsiders” are introduced in chapter one three boys named Ponyboy Curtis, Sodapop Curtis, and Darry Curtis. These three brothers also classify themselves as Greasers because of where they live, how they act, and how they dress daily. By the looks of these three siblings, I will be comparing them by their Appearance like how they look and dress, their Personality on how they act, and on their personal life including their birth date, friends and similarities. But for now, I will be talking about Appearance.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the confronting documentary, Audrie & Daisy, film makers Bonni Cohn and Jon Shenk depict a completely biased and illusory stance on the aftermath of two teenage sexual assault victims. A range of conventions are expertly used, positioning the viewers to believe that the government and social media have, to an extent, influenced the victimization of Daisy Coleman, and the tragic suicide of Audrie Pott. Through the perpetuation of socio-cultural values and stereotypes inherent in American high schools, the employment of certain film techniques, specifically special effects, and a discerning use of language choices through editing, Cohn and Shenk have carefully manipulated the audience to sympathize and agree with their views regarding the…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Comparing and Contrasting American Horror Story Season 2 and Stranger Things AHS Season 2 is about an insane asylum with many hidden secrets. In that season, many nuns try to cover up what they are doing to their patients. Stranger Things is about a group of friends that try to find their other friend, Will, but they find out that he is trapped in another world. They try to save him before it is too late. Although American Horror Story (AHS) and Stranger Things (ST)have different settings and characters they both have the same genres.…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When you’ve been with reviving one of the most obsessively beloved in modern book that soon became movies. is it better to defy expectations or to meet them? In the movie A Streetcar Named Desire the movie portrays a more accurate plot that help make it a accurate play. It's centered when Blanche goes to visit her sister Stella in a small town in Louisiana.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Women In Horror Films

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Immediately we see both the dichotomy of the virgin vs. sex kitten, innocent vs. deviant, pure vs. impure female image and the religious undertones that drive this binary. This film does, however, stray from what feminist theorists have called the “male antagonist,” as Carrie acts as both the antagonist and protagonist in this film. On the contrary, Carrie does fit the virgin profile while other females in the film fit the sex kitten profile. In order to better understand the reflective theory in the context of this film, let’s analyze the opening scene of the film. As the credits flash upon the screen, viewers are immediately greeted by a locker room full of high school girls, standing around, laughing, completely naked.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Odyssey Essay In the film , “O Brother , Where Art Thou ?” by Ethan and Joel Coen , we are shown a different interpretation of the epic poem , “The Odyssey” by Homer. In this film adaptation , we are introduced to Everett , who is playing Odysseus , and his men, Pete and Elmar. Here, they are represented as criminals who have just escaped jail in hopes of finding treasure.…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1) The objective of this assignment is demonstrate knowledge of diverse cultures, including global and historical perspectives, and to demonstrate an appreciation for aesthetics and creative activities. 2) According to the class lecture, Ancient Greeks found theater to be very important in their culture because it was educational. In the theater they learn to engage in tragic dramas.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The sound techniques used throughout the film contribute to the construction of Norman as an evil person. When Norman is sitting in the parlour with Marion there is no music playing for most of their conversation, that is until Marion brings up the idea of sending Norman 's 'mother ' to an institution. Norman 's reaction to this is not pleasant and he begins to speak of how awful asylums are and how he would never consider doing something like that to someone he loves. The non-diegetic music then begins and intensifies as Norman 's tone and demeanour becomes threatening. This builds tension in the scene, and both Marion and the audience become increasingly uncomfortable and scared by Norman 's change of mood.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bully: A Film Analysis

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages

    "Wtf are you doing in your snapchat videos you look ugly asf with your round ass face you fatass go loose some weight then post something your videos pissed me off the fuck off with your stupid ass all in the camera and shit FUCK. " This is a message that I received on Snapchat just a few hours after I posted a story on how my sibling and I were decorating for Halloween, and in one of those stories I just happened to take a selfie. This is just one example of many people who been told the same thing or maybe even worst. Now I 'm grown girls and reading those words were hurt because I know I 'm not ugly; and yes, I know I 'm "fat" I 'm working hard to fix that about myself and I don 't need a complete stranger insulting me like that. I blocked…

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Callum Watt 000873235-3 Soundtrack Analysis - Psycho In the clip that we are provided (known as “The Murder) we are given a very famous and influential scene from one of Alfred Hitchcock's most critically acclaimed films. Bernard Herrmann, the composer for the movie did a sensational soundtrack with a low budget, and even went against Hitchcock’s wishes of the score to be jazz based. With the low budget instead of using an entire orchestra Herrmann only used strings to create an arguably more tense and dark feel to the movie, Fred Steiner, in an analysis of the score to Psycho, points out that “string instruments gave Herrmann access to a wider range in tone, dynamics, and instrumental special effects than any other single instrumental group…

    • 1102 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anti Bullying Video gets Student Suspended. Bullying is a serious problem in today's society. It is especially found in schools all around the world. To help stop this growing threat in modern society, Emily Gipson makes and posts a video called ‘’Welcome to Lebanon High School.”…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I decided to take a different approach to my critical film review. “Inside Out” is a recently new film that does not actually have an identified therapist or client. However, the main themes of the movie have many parallels to the content that we have been learning in class. “Inside Out” is a Disney Pixar movie that brings to life the five emotions (Joy, Anger, Disgust, Fear, and Sadness) of 11-year-old Riley. Life is seemingly going smoothly for Riley and her emotions.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays