CHEO Case Study Essay

Improved Essays
Under the terms of the settlement, Transgenomic agreed to provide CHEO, located in Ottawa, and all other Canadian public sector hospitals and laboratories, the right to test Canadians for Long QT on a not-for-profit basis.

But Lipkus said the settlement's impact is much broader than the five genes and particular syndrome at issue in the lawsuit. "This agreement defines a practical pathway that will allow Canadian public hospitals and labs to conduct genetic testing without legal roadblocks from gene patents."

The settlement model is important because public hospitals want to offer full panels of genetic testing without cost. As for the patent owners, the model allows them to avoid taking on the public sector by granting non-commercial licences to non-profit public institutions.

"When you have companies that
…show more content…
"He turbocharged the whole thing and put us in touch with CHEO and the entire genetic network community."

Gold's interest in gene patents originated in 1998 when he wrote a report on the patentability of human genes, a highly controversial legal issue that remains largely unresolved, particularly in Canada. He has since advised governments and health organizations on the issue. He was also involved with the Myriad litigation.

Gold knew that CHEO had a genetic team that was at the forefront of genetic testing and running into the gene patent problem with some regularity. He referred the lawyers to the hospital.

"The genetics department were genuinely frustrated by the situation and saw this as an important issue for the hospital and medical care generally," Lipkus said.

In January 2013, the hospital retained the lawyers to investigate the possibilities on a pro bono basis. Gold was able to include funding for research associated with a possible test case in one of his grants.

"For the next year, we spent tens of thousands on student research and working through the patents with the geneticists," Lipkus

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    MSTT met with Sherwin and Natalie discussing Daniel's diagnosis. Natalie explained to MSTT she found it hard to believe Daniel was diagnosised with ADHA and that is why she did not allow him to take the medication that the psychartist prescribed. Sherwin and Natalie agreed the ODD diagnosis is more accurate once MSTT explained the behaviors associated with the diagnosis. Sherwin and Natalie expressed to MSTT some to the behaviors they witness first hand with Daniel which coincide with his new diagnosises. After MSTT educated Natalie and Sherwin on the new diagnosis the conversation changed because they wanted to know if they can sue the psychartist for falsely diagnosis Daniel and placing him on medication which he did not need.…

    • 210 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Calfee believes companies own our gene patents but at the end patients are the beneficiaries. Gene patents…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With the etiology of the syndrome widely unknown, proper detection is difficult, as is the base being tested against for genetic similarities. If more individuals with EDS, of all subtypes, are globally compared, this can lead to phenomenal identifying results that relate subjects to one another. Yet testing is expensive and is a leading cause in why genetic testing is a last resort for most, especially recessive types that are unaware they carry a known gene. While some argue genetic testing is more accessible than ever, most insurance companies do not cover it, hence making such testing a privilege for the wealthy. As of 2017, most insurers according to Genetics Home Reference are willing to cover costs of genetic testing if strongly advised by a physician for medical purpose with strong medical reasoning.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New York Times says that many people are automatically enrolled into this scientific research when they donate blood or give bodily samples, even after surgery. Bioethicists’ often take,…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When it comes to talking about controversial topics such as politics or religion it is no surprise that people will not see eye to eye on the topic. Therefore, it’s no surprise that gene patenting, the act of patenting genes of DNA to be legally owned by private firms or universities, is also a controversial topic that others, including authors John E. Calfee and Michael Crichton seem to have different opinions on. Crichton, who is against the idea of gene patenting believes the research is harmful, while Calfee believes otherwise; stating there is something to gain from patents. In “Patenting Life”(441) written by Michael Crichton he discusses the cons to gene patenting and expresses his own disapproval toward the subject.…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since 1973, the year abortions were made legal, there has been more than forty million abortions (“Stats Before Roe v. Wade” par.3). Roe v. Wade has brought changes to American society since it came into effect in 1973. Roe v. Wade has come a long way since before it was a case, when the case was made into a law, and even has an effect in today’s society. Roe v. Wade was able to change the way women obtained abortions before 1973.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    HIPAA Research Paper

    • 132 Words
    • 1 Pages

    The current guidelines of the United States HIPAA policies are limited for genetics. To better improve this, the HIPAA policies need to resemble the United Kingdom’s laws regarding genetics. According to the General Medical Council (n.d.), in the United Kingdom if a patient refuses to give consent a healthcare professional can release information without their consent. One must care for the patient first, then protect the other person from harm. When releasing genetic information, the person’s identity can not be disclosed.…

    • 132 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Crichton V. Calfee: The Gene Patent Argument Michael Crichton and John E. Calfee both discuss the topic of gene patents in their respective articles, “Patenting Life” and “Decoding The Use Of Gene Patents.” However, the similarities end there as their opinions are the direct opposite of one another, with Crichton expressing extreme displeasure at the idea of gene patenting while Calfee is in support of the practice. Firstly, Crichton believes the patenting of genes as a whole to be a mistake. He believes the practice to be a result of the United States Patent Office (PTO) “[misinterpreting] previous Supreme Court rulings” (Crichton 441).…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic discrimination involves the use of genetic information by employers, insurance companies, and others to discriminate against or stigmatize people. After detecting the disease incredible repair work can done…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Myriad Genetics

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the afterword, Skloot discusses the commercialization of human tissue, the patents on various genes, and the fact that the companies who own the patents dictate what research is done on the genes. This is troubling for the reason that it limits the time in which scientists find a cure the genetic disease. One, in particular, is Myriad Genetics, the owner of the license for the BRCA and BRCA2, which is the main cause of breast and ovarian cancer. Skloot exposes her distaste for the unethical business practices of Myriad Genetics by citing a court case filed against them, saying, “Myriad has been accused of creating a monopoly since no one else can offer the test, researchers can’t develop cheaper tests or new therapies without getting permission from Myriad … In May 2009 the American Civil Liberties Union, several breast cancer survivors, and professional groups representing over 150,000 scientists sued Myriad Genetics … scientists involved in the case claimed the practice of gene patenting has inhibited their research” (Skloot 325).…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Equal Pay Act of 1963 is defined as “a labor law that prohibits gender-based wage discrimination in the United States.” (HISTORY, DATE) The purpose of this law is to provide equal pay to both men and women that perform the same jobs instead of having women feel like they are of lesser equal to men especially when they are performing the same job. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is defined as a “federal law that prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of sex, race, color, national origin, and religion.”…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Prenatal genetic sequencing is a scientific procedure that predicts the risk of developing an illness later in life, and/or shows potential traits such as athleticism and intelligence in an unborn child. These predictions of illness and potential traits come from analyzing fetal DNA found in a sample of the mother’s blood. A very important and main concern for prenatal genetic testing is for preparation of treatment for a predicted illness in a child. Also parents are often interested in these predictions simply for having an indication of what they are getting themselves into. Prenatal genetic testing is a rising topic in present ethical conflicts.…

    • 2208 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, due to the hardiness of HeLa, other cells were contaminated by HeLa. Victor McKusick had one of his postdoctoral fellows, Susan Hsu, obtain blood from Henrietta’s family so that genetic markers could be compared to HeLa, which could be used to find contaminates of HeLa. When Henrietta’s family had their blood drawn to be genetically tested, they thought they were being tested for cancer. McKusick published his findings along with a family pedigree, name, and the genetic data. Although the Lacks family voluntary participated, it was not informed consent because they did not have the information nor the capability necessary to understand why they were tested.…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In light of my qualifications for the Masters Education Program of Genetic Counseling situated at Virginia Commonwealth University, it is significant to understand the spark that lit the conflagration of my interest in the field. Genetics as a whole has proven to be a profound influence on my life until this point, as it has for many others, but contrasted from others in its influence on my mindset and desire to understand the world that surrounds humanity. The questions of why people behave, look, feel, or develop in a certain manner as opposed to another has always proven to be definite fascination in my life and through genetics the opportunity for finding the answers to such questions was revealed in its entirety. The reason for suffering…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This opportunity allows doctors and scientists to investigate the working of human DNA and potentially find cures for the most deadly diseases known to man. There is potential for greatness in this field of study; it’s just the people unwilling to support it. The future of medicine and treatment of diseases relies on the advances made in human genetic engineering studies. The Human Genome Project, an organization devoted to determining the sequence of chemical base pairs that make up human DNA, completed a “rough draft” in the year 2003…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays