But Not Too Gay Trope Analysis

Improved Essays
The trope used to help characters cover is called "But Not Too Gay", where out LGBTQ+ characters are present on shows but scripted to be highly covered versions of gay people. According to the TVTropes website one fundamental method to enact this trope is to limit or completely eliminate the gay characters from having their romance on screen. The website states that audiences will be uncomfortable, " by shows of affection and sex scenes with gay and lesbian characters, no matter how tame they may be" (TVTropes). What this creates is an idea that to be socially acceptable gay people must not do not show, or even participate in, forms of romantic or sexual affection with their partners; which means you " can have gay people and gay couples but …show more content…
Through constructing lesbian sex to reflect male desire the characters ' queerness is covered effectively and therefore is a suitable form of representation for straight audiences. The hypersexual nature of these scenes illustrates that the focus is on female passion, not romance or sensuality, which would allow their actions to come off as an element of a loving relationship. If female on female sex were presented in a manner that reinforced them as a couple it would defy the trope and make them too gay. Characters who are too gay are considered to be "flaunting" and become part of the Queer category. Flaunting as described by Yoshino is the act of overtly exhibiting one 's homosexuality to society. Flaunting is the direct result of the requirement to cover forced upon LGBTQ+, either overtly or covertly. Normative society is accustomed to homosexual people hiding the more obviously gay elements of themselves and their lives and therefore as a whole feel that one 's homosexuality is flaunted when it is presented in its not covered form. In Covering flaunting illustrates LGBTQ+ people 's attempt to be treated as equals in society by not hiding. Yoshino states, "People can tolerate two homosexuals they see leaving together, but if the next day they 're smiling, holding hands, and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    In the 1953 western-musical parody Calamity Jane the butch heroin, Jane Canary (Doris Day) undergoes a makeover, by imitating Katie Brown (Allyn McLerie), to become a feminine female; thus engaging into a heterosexual romance with Bill Hickock (Howard Keel) (cf. Mizejewski 185). Katie Brown an aspiring, burlesque singer and dancer, whom Jane mistakes as the famous hyper feminine Adelaid Adams (Gale Robbins), helps Jane to transition from a masculine cowboy into a real and proper woman, by confronting Jane with her own inadequate gender performance. Bill Hickock as the embodiment of a hyper masculine male authenticity shames Jane “to consolidate [a] normative, ‘feminine’ identity” (Savoy 169) in order to shape her character specifically to a “gradual conformity to heterosexual expectations of the feminine”, according to “what her culture regards as the ‘real woman’ (Savoy 165). I claim that Jane Canary’s object of affection is an arbitrary choice, according to gender normativity and that in fact Jane’s secret love is Katie Brown.…

    • 425 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In Understanding Film Theory, queer theory is defined as: ”An approach to social and cultural study which seeks to challenge or deconstruct traditional ideas of sexuality and gender, esp. the acceptance of heterosexuality as normative and the perception of a rigid dichotomy of male and female traits. ”1…

    • 47 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Misrepresentation affects us all to some degree. Maybe one night you didn’t get enough sleep and you were grumpy all day. That’s an unfortunate misrepresentation, but what about if the media displayed you as a grumpy person every day? “It Ain’t Easy Being Bisexual on TV” by Amy Zimmerman seeks to describe the current state of bisexuality’s representation in the today’s media by analyzing a popular TV shows. Daily Beast, a liberal leaning website, published this article in August of 14.…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Brooklyn Nine-Nine Satire

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It’s a rare and precious gift that needs to be appreciated.) And because this is a sitcom and the writers and cast are precious people, we don’t have to be afraid for the queer characters. They’re not going to die or lose their significant others by some tragedy and we don’t have to be afraid of any suicides or severe accidents or of an apocalexa happening – they’re safe. They’re out and they’re proud and they’re…

    • 902 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The bisexual menace revisited” by Kristin Esterberg explores the concept of bisexuality as an identity or behavior and how it compares and contrasts with monosexual identities. Dr. Esterberg holds a Ph.D and is the elected president at SUNY Potsdam. It is worth noting that her spouse is a woman who works at SUNY Potsdam as well. The first portion of her essay explores the paradox in which “bisexuality seems to be both everywhere and nowhere” (278).…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Janet R. Jakobsen’s essay, Queers Are Like Jews, Aren’t They? Analogy and Alliance Politics, discusses in depth what it means to queer something and to do Jewish. Jakobsen explains the relationship between these two actions and encourages the process of “thinking through the possibilities of playing off multiple norms” (p 82). She is able to do this with the help of a reading by Stacy Wolf on Barbara Streisand’s queer performances. I will look closely at Jakobsen’s argument about Barbara Streisand’s nose and her decision not to change it, while also specifying Jakobsen’s interpretation of how Streisand differs from Sander Gilman’s account of “The Jewish Nose.”…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stereotypes In Tv Shows

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Stereotypes of gender and sexuality can be strictly seen in American television shows such as: The Family guy, The Simpsons, The Rescue Heroes and many more. Even though all the shows guarantees for entertainment and keeps our thoughts from our day to day stressful activities for a moment; nonetheless, it also occupies our bran and shatters our thinking hat which we then fail to see the extreme gender and sexual stereotypes depicted throughout the series. The show I have chosen to focus and pin points the stereotypic act is from “The Rescue Heroes and The Family guy.” The first series is about a group of males who travels around the nations rescuing lives from both natural and man-made artificial disasters.…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Sexual orientation and gender are controversial when applied to pop-culture and reality. Under these assumptions is when Hollywood plays a role in movies and shows to show superiority or inferiority among a group of people. Omi quotes, “White men could seduce racial minority women, but white women were not to be linked to minority men,” (545). The struggle of class in society deeply affects the idea given as who is superior and whether race defines a person as whom they are. Gender in pop-culture is controversial because it is shown stereotypically in a set of class.…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In pop culture, the sexuality of women are often depicted as a binary: either as a slut or a whore, or pure and innocent. Adelina Anthony’s and Margaret Cho’s performances challenge these representations with their comedic performances and being open with their sexuality. They disidentify with hegemonic cultural representations by working with and against dominant representations such as sexism and classism. They use humor such as sarcasm to make people see how absurd about people’s stereotypical views on sexuality. Furthermore, the alternative representations that Cho and Anthony offer are an unabashed performance of who they are as part of the LGBTQ community.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Invention Of Homosexuality

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The way this practice disappears people that identify as queer is that it classifies their sexual practices as deviant; “sexual deviance in terms of unorthodox sexual desires” (195). Wilkerson also says,” Even less recognized is the strategic value of sexual stereotyping and other sexual harms as significant in perpetuating inequality in any oppressed group” (195). The more stereotypes are promoted the more it oppresses and divides a certain…

    • 1203 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We live in a world where homosexuals are mocked by society. Going back in time when attitude based on homosexuality varied by era and region in Medieval Europe, this is when all sexual practices were allowed until the 12th century came along and the development of christianity changed the views on sexuality. Death by landscape starring Lois, emplifies homosexuality at a young age, whereas, Lolita starring Humbert represents a pedophile pursuing a young minor also referred to in the book a “nymphet.” When an individual begins to get involved in a relationship it is natural they label what they are sharing with their companion as “LOVE,” which in this case I declare as “LUST.” As an individual starts pursuing another, their sexuality comes into question, their social well-being is impacted and they often mistake Love with Lust.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We keep close the people that we love, and we try our best to avoid the people that we hate. it’s extremely easy for them to surmise whatever they want to about the “Gay Lifestyle” or “Gay Agenda” or whatever customs firsthand, you have no real way of knowing what to believe and what not to believe. So by putting their lives out there for the world to see, they are essentially helping bridge the gap between them and the people who essentially don’t know any better.…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gender studies refers to masculinity and femininity in a cultural standpoint without referring to the biological side of things. It deals with the breakdown of binaries, which refers to typical “masculine” and “feminine” behavior. We can see how society has embedded and emphasized typical behaviors relating to gender in A Doll’s House. A man is supposed to be the leader of the family and usually makes the most money in the family. The woman in the relationship is supposed to take care of the kids and put her work and desires second to her needs and wants.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Bisexuality is an identity and orientation that is often overlooked and completely dismissed by not only society, but the entertainment industry as well. But, through quirky songs and constant plot lines, the CW’s original show Crazy Ex-Girlfriend is fighting both bi-erasure and the stereotyping of both gay men and bisexual men while also creating an atmosphere where they aren’t the butt of the shows jokes. Crazy Ex-Girlfriend features a same-sex relationship with Josh Wilson, or commonly referred to as ‘White Josh’ who identifies as gay and Darryl Whitefeather who has newly discovered his bisexuality. The relationship displayed on the show not only is fighting bi-erasure with each episode that Darryl’s love life is featured on, but also combating the stereotypes that are often attached to both bi and gay men through these characters very existence. Although it is not a plot line that is immediately introduced, Darryl’s sexuality or the questioning of it at least, comes into play halfway through the shows first season.…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Billy Wilder’s Some Like It Hot, is one of the more popular comedic works of its time. The movie showcases genres of romance, crime and comedy while creating an obvious juxtaposition of male and female characters. The movie highlights central themes regarding gender and sexuality. Marilyn Monroe’s character represents the quintessential cinematic female fantasy, as she represents the seemingly all too innocent, naive, sensual and sexual female representation that she has been largely popularized by. In spite of the movies light comedic angle it showcases some relevant beliefs on the pervasive attitudes around female relationships, sexuality, gender norms roles and values.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays