The Failure Of Standardized Testing In Public Schools

Great Essays
Imagine a third grade girl about to take her first standardized test. She is nervous about the test because it is not a normal classroom test. Over the past month, her teacher has reviewed everything that she and her classmates have learned the entire year. As she looks around the room, she observes other nervous peers. Unfortunately, standardized tests have grown more frequent in schools at all levels, and “when future educational historians look back at the last few decades of U.S. public schooling, they will surely identify a system in which students’ scores on annual accountability tests became, almost relentlessly, the prominent determiner of a school’s success” (Popham 45). Because people believe that schools do not educate students …show more content…
Better predictors than a grade point average, the scores from a standardized test that everyone takes show who is more ready for the next step, whether that includes the acceptance to the next grade level, college, or graduate school. (Kuncell 1081). If everyone takes the same test, no matter what school they attend, the score that a student obtains provides comparisons to other students who took the test. On the other hand, a person’s grade point average can be inflated, depending on what classes that person took and the difficulty of the classes; they simply do not represent an unbiased or consistent picture of a students’ academic performance. The course requirements also change from school to school, so everyone taking the same standardized test assists others, such as school administrators and college admissions counselors, to determine who is a better student, and who has more potential at the next phase in life. Based on these scores, standardized tests have three central …show more content…
This bias mainly originates from test questions themselves because some of the questions have a context that is understood only by a specific group of people. For example, if a problem on the SAT asked a question that had a context about pirouettes, some people, such as those unfamiliar with dance, might be confused by the question because they do not know what a pirouette is. They have not been given the opportunity to learn about pirouettes because there might not be a ballet school near them, they might not have enough money to attend one, or they do not have any interest in ballet itself. This question is unfair to these children who do not understand and are confused. They cannot answer these questions based on what they already know if they do not even know about it in the first place. Minority students cannot break the mold of scoring low on tests if they do not understand the context of questions that they are being asked, so they can only do as well as their experiences can take them (Gilmore 396, 397). Therefore, opportunity helps students score higher because of the bias. Gender also helps to decide the score. On the SAT in the years 1998 and 2000, the average gap between males and females on 117 math questions was roughly seven percent

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In Chicago’s popular daily newspaper Chicago Tribune, an article titled “Should Colleges Care So Much About ACT/SAT Scores?” interviewed two upcoming college freshmen asking them whether they supported or opposed standardized testing being a part of the admissions criteria. The article communicates two opposing viewpoints on the topic to emphasize the pros and cons of standardized testing as a part of the admissions criteria. According to the first student, Rob Garcia, the use of standardized exam results allow admissions officers to have a clear criteria to rate applicants from; their critical thinking abilities. Garcia adds “It is tough enough for college admissions officers to sift through thousands… of applications that may seem almost identical. It would help if these people had some criteria to rate each student, based on each applicant’s skills and thinking ability” (Garcia 3).…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Annually, numerous educators express despair and frustration when attempting to prepare students to take standardized scholastic examinations. Educators are constantly pressured by school administrators to ensure their students excel when these tests are administered; however, in the African-American community, the stress, frustration and pressure felt by educators is heightened three-fold. Many educators strongly believe these standardized tests are racially biased against minority and lower income students (i.e. African-American, Hispanic).These educators are correct; numerous studies indicate that, although minorities tend to produce lower scores during standardized testing, the results of these standardized tests do not accurately depict…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized testing, the modern day war against students. This shouldn't be the attitude towards test whose “sole" purpose should be to provide fair assessments so that educators can make high stakes decisions in the admission process for individual students, to help improve teaching and learning, and to generate important data from which policy decisions can be made. However, the purpose of standardized testing whether it be the ACT or the SAT has evolved from an equalizer of opportunity to a biased tool of segregation which strips students of their identity and ability and disguises them as a barcode on a sheet of paper.…

    • 103 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    SAT DBQ Essay

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages

    More exact forms of predicting a student’s grades include using high school class rank and high school grade point averages. Taking this into account, Source D states that, “...high school grade-point averages…as opposed to general aptitude as supposedly measured by the SAT--- correlate more highly with freshman grade-point averages than does the SAT”. High school grades represent how well a student may have done over the course of their whole high school academic year, just as college grades represent how well a student may have done over the course of their whole college academic year. Consequently, the SAT is not able to represent a college freshman’s grades as accurately since both high school and college mimic one another, unlike the SAT which only tests certain aspects of a student’s intelligence. Along with predicticting first-year grades in college, “...females on average score 35-40 points lower than males on the SAT I, but receive better high school and college grades” (Source G).…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    SAT Needs Change

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Standardized testing like the SAT, in my opinion, have the capabilities of testing a student’s abilities. However, the flaws that this exam contains further distance its intentions of the college admission process of finding the best students. As a result I…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Imagine being stuck in a bare, silent and chilly room for several hours, nothing but a #2 pencil and a testing booklet to keep you company. This was the reality for many children as, a few days ago, high school students in America sat down to take the PSAT, just one of the many standardized test they will take and have taken throughout their academic careers. A standardized test is a type of test where students are given the same range of questions in similar testing environments in order to judge and compare their scores. Standardized tests are being administered more and more as of late, due to increased funding and acts such as the 2001 No Child Left Behind act which encouraged the use of standardized tests in school. However, there has been much controversy around whether forcing students to take more standardized tests is a good thing, as there is evidence that they are biased, inaccurate, and do the education system more harm than good.…

    • 1081 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    These tests are created to judge every student equally, regardless of their course load or average, interests or abilities. Students begin taking standardized tests shortly after they enter the public school system, so from a young age they are tested on whatever the state or country feels is important. The issue, however, is that standardized tests place a large emphasis on the ability to memorize facts, develop good test- taking strategies, and complete tasks in an extremely quick manner. These skills have not only become outdated and less important because of the development of new technologies, but it is unclear how these skills are actually assessed. Standardized testing encourages conformity as well by forcing students to “stay on track” or not be distracted by related topics.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Special aid programs for families of students provide students with a much needed personal security that will allow them to focus on their studies and not what they have to live with when they go home. There are hundreds of ways that the standardized tests can be improved to not only increase test scores but student health. Yet, despite the multiple improvements that can be made, standardized tests remain biased. Although standardized testing can be capable of measuring student intelligence, there little attempt to improve the test to correct bias. The test carries an immense influence on colleges and society in general, but the test’s importance in society is unprecedented, as a single biased test is capable of changing the future of students.…

    • 367 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized Tests How many countless hours have teachers and kids struggled over ACT packets and practice SAT’s for a mere three hours of filling in bubbles? President Barack Obama said, “teachers should not be forced to spend the academic year preparing students to fill in bubbles on standardized tests.” In high schools all over the U.S. teachers prepare student for these impractical tests, to measure how smart someone is. These standardized tests, however, don’t take into account many other things such as work ethic, willingness to be involved, and student’s effort.…

    • 1712 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standardized Testing in Schools Standardized testing has been an inevitable part of life for countless Americans, making them question the validity of their life choices since the third grade. When taking standardized tests, one encounters some obvious drawbacks. Any student who has been forced to take one of the hundreds that exist can recount the tales of stress and feelings of inadequacy that linger after every test taken. Standardized testing does not benefit students because it objectifies certain race/ethnic groups, it doesn’t measure the test taker’s mental capacity or progress, and it is not worth the unnecessary problems for students.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    SAT Argument Essay

    • 1808 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The SAT “is a sternly worded dinosaur of a test, graded in an arbitrary manner with outdated equipment…the only reason people take it is because they have to.” Children begin taking standardized tests in pre-kindergarten and by the time they are high school seniors, they’ve taken an average of 112 standardized tests (Strauss 1), all with one purpose: to measure and quantify intellectual ability. However, there is a growing mountain of evidence that suggests the SAT is a poor measurement of potential college success. The SAT is regarded as one of the more important tests, as it is used primarily to measure a student’s potential college success. For high school students the SAT is the gatekeeper of the future.…

    • 1808 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lelac Almagor, author of “The Good in Standardized Testing” says, “Without standardized testing—and lacking any other basis for comparison in their own educational experience—the students’ families had no way of knowing what [Almagor] had assumed was obvious: that eighth graders... on the other side of town were well past working on multisyllabic words or improper fractions. They had no way of knowing that their hard-working, solid-GPA kids were already far behind.” Almagor’s writing shows how standardized testing can actually be helpful to several families to show them how their child is doing in school. While this may be the case, standardized testing still creates more inconveniences for students, teachers, and parents. If the tests take up too much time, create “winners” and “losers”, but don’t support the student’s education, are standardized tests even worth their trouble?…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Low-income students, unlike their more affluent peers, don't have the money to spend on expensive test-prep classes that teach tricks students can use to increase their scores” (Burd 6). The SAT and ACT contain many questions designed to trick students, and without expensive test prep, it is difficult to answer those questions correctly, which results in an unfairly low relative score for low-income students. Also, minorities may not be comfortable enough with the English language. When a Mexican student named Marilyn took a multiple-choice practice test, her score was much less than what her teacher had come to expect from her based on her overall grade. “Even though Marilyn has been in the county for five years and can no longer take a modified test for English learners, words like ‘escalate’ or ‘initiate’ on the standardized tests make her nervous…in other respects, she does really well…her critical thinking and problem-solving skills are very strong” (Rizga 13).…

    • 1225 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Testing is a big part in schools and inequality of education affects testing scores in the United States. In recent years, most ages in schools are scoring the best scores ever in history on standardized tests. These ages include nine year olds, 13 year olds, and 17 year olds. Although, the problem is that this information is coming from schools where the majority of children come from middle-class income families. Inequality in schools really starts to be a problem when a school contains more than seventy-five percent of children living in poverty.…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The same issue of economically advantaged students scoring higher on the test because of more opportunities to exam prep than…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays