Broken Windows Theory

Superior Essays
It is the libertarian belief that a person is the sole proprietor of their bodies, mind, and labors and therefore, are entitled to do what they please with those possessions without justifiable interference. This concept of natural rights is also accepted by utilitarians such John Stewart Mills. If an individual is the sole owner of themselves, then why should anyone interfere with their actions if it is not directly affecting another? For example, if a person chooses to gamble an alarming percentage of their wages away, that is their right; so it begs the question as to why there is a law against gambling in some states? If two consenting adult engage in the exchanging sexual acts for money, should it not be their right if they are entitled …show more content…
The Broken Windows model of policing address three key aspects in crime prevention: neighborhood disorder creates fear, meaning that areas with a higher volume of gang activity, prostitutes, and the mentally disturbed are most likely to maintain higher volumes of crime; neighborhoods can give out crime-promoting signals, the idea that deteriorated houses and disorderly behavior are feared by honest citizens because criminals are attracted to such settings; and police should target low-level “quality of life crimes, meaning that police should address minor problems of an area in efforts to prevent the invitation of more serious crime (Siegel & Worrall, 2012). It is under this theory that if minor disorderly conduct, prostitution, and the use of illicit drugs goes unchecked in a neighborhood, there will be an increase of serious crimes in that area because residents and local authority tolerate such disorder and do not care to control the environment. Thus, disorder and public order crimes should be controlled and discouraged to protect neighborhoods and its residents (Veneziano, …show more content…
Paternalism is the interference of a state or an individual with another person, or in this case the government interfering in the lives of its citizens, under the motivation and justification that those interfered will be better off or protected from harm (Dworkin, 2016). According to John Stewart Mills (1859), the only purpose for exercising powers over an individual is to prevent harm to others and is not warranted to prevent harm to his own good, whether it be physical or moral. Mills considers paternalism to be immoral because it impedes on the individual’s happiness and another could only reason or persuade the individual, not force them, because they are ruler of their own body and mind (Mills, 1859). However, Gerald Dworkin (1972) argued that interference with an individual’s liberty can be justified if it is to the welfare, good, happiness, needs, interest or values of the individual being coerced (p.65). For example, the law requires children to attend school because it is in the child’s best interest to gain an education and gain positive associations with having an education. Paternalism can then be divided into two types: hard and soft paternalism. Soft paternalism is when the conditions permits justified intervention when it is necessary to determine whether or not the individual is acting voluntary and is knowingly doing the action that may harm them morally or physically. Hard

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Walshville, Ontario is considered to be one of the largest cities in Canada with a 2009 population of 170,000 individuals. The population, however, consists of the city proper, three First Nation communities and five communities that were engrossed when the city was first created in 1990. Considered to be a large geographic area, this city consists of a mayor and 12 councilors who are responsible for one of the 12 city wards presented. In order to maintain such a huge region the main economic drivers Walshville greatly benefits from is listed as, their education, tourism, and both commercial and sports fishing. With regards to upholding social order, the city of Walshville has a Police Service Board just like any other city.…

    • 1498 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The broken windows theory was proposed by two men named James Q. Willson and George Kelling in 1982. Their theory states “that crime is disorder and that if disorder were stopped, then serious crimes would therefore not occur.” If the smaller crimes were stopped, it would prevent bigger crimes in the future is how I see it. The simple definition is that if a broken window, left unattended, this would signal that no one cared and therefore ultimately lead to more disorder and even crime. So how did they theory begin in the first place.…

    • 1444 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. How does Sir Robert Peel’s Principles of Policing relate to today’s law enforcement community? Sir Robert peel’s Principles of policing they are relate to today’s law enforcement community, in that way that they are the foundations on which U.S community policing is created. Referring that new metropolitan police force is known as Peelers, created by Sir Robert Peel. These are some of the example policing that we still us in todays law, like police should not use any type of force unless is absolutely necessary.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Similarly, Gladwell says that once a crime occurs, more crimes will occur and they will gradually increase until there is healing in the community. Once the community and the law enforcement come together, the “broken windows” will be repaired and essentially there would be a decline in crimes. It also helped NYC crime rates reach an all- time low. David Gunn, the NYC subway director from the 1980’s was hired to implement the Broken Windows theory on the graffiti problem on the subway carts. His plan was to allow the criminals to graffiti “dirty” subway carts that were not in service.…

    • 1715 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The prosperity proposal contends that crime rates fall when monetary conditions enhance and rise when the economy sours. While this thinking appeared to clarify falling crime rates amid the economic boom of the late '90s, However, with police divisions permitted urban communities to put more cops on the beat, and that their expanded nearness forestalled crime, paying little heed to what those officers were doing. The second is that specific policing strategies, similar to the broken windows approach or problem area policing, were viable. Problem area, or spot based policing, in which divisions utilize ongoing crime information to surge unsafe miniaturized scale neighborhoods with officers, was successful in diminishing crime. Hot spot policing…

    • 294 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Broken Window Theory

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages

    It is human natures to plan for the future; during the process of thinking about the future, people are making their predictions based on the current situation. The ability of imagining the future relies on psychological immune system. Psychological immune system lets people able to make predictions and adaptations of negative events that may happen in the future, but these predictions are not necessary true because the context of society is changing all the time. Also, people’s behaviors and attitudes are adapting to the subtle elements that around us and the education of being individualism. All human beings have their own psychological immune systems, and people use this system to change their feelings; the tendency of blaming others become…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The families of these inmates are not the only ones dealing with the consequences of Rikers Island. There are several financial consequences that the city is facing due to the operation on Rikers Island. Being Rikers Island is an aging facility, the maintenance costs are significant. There is also a transportation cost to the overall corrections system due to the location of Rikers Island. Considering when inmates are transported for court appearances, the corrections department has to budget $31 million each year for transportation costs.…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gang Allowances

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In every state and city there is always those type of neighborhoods that we consider or label as bad and dangerous. But what makes these cities so dangerous? Is it the people that settle in the neighborhood that makes them dangerous or the way media portrays them with the violence and segregations of organizations such as gangs and the crime rates? We see this occurring all around the world marking gangs as the number one problem to the situation. As a result we see many laws emerging across the country that focus on the gang “social problem”.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Social Disorganization Theory Case Study

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited

    When most community or neighborhood members are acquainted and on good terms with one another, a substantial portion of the adult population has the potential to influence each child. Modern Social disorganization theory is more complex than the classical theory. They linked structural aspects of neighborhoods (Poverty, Residential mobility, heterogeneity, and broken homes.) to a neighborhoods ability to institute social control (Interpersonal friendship networks, ability to monitor teens, and public organization) and found it a good predictor of criminal victimization. Placed an emphasis on how disorganization reduced social control and impacted other neighborhood aspects that also enhanced the amount of crime that occurred. This theory statistically speaking, those that grow up in poverty areas generally do not finish school and most likely have parent who did not either.…

    • 1248 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 3 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While police brutality, abuse of power, racial profiling and targeting the poor are arguments against the Broken Window Theory, they are not necessarily caused by it. The police have certain rules of engagement when dealing with suspects that they must follow, however, this is often mistaken for police brutality and abuse of power. The media hype over stories of people like Eric Garner, Freddie Gray and Michael Brown cause stories to be told from a biased and largely anti-police point of view (Gainor). There’s proof that using Broken Windows policing keeps communities safer by getting dangerous criminals off the streets by arresting them for small crimes when the police do not yet have enough evidence to arrest them for more major crimes.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Residential segregation has a big impact on today’s society. It creates a downfall in the equality of many non-whites. While many people chose to live with others of the same race, those neighborhoods may not provide the best opportunities. The problem starts with poor education then unemployment or low income then bad relationships which can lead to criminal activity. Historically, non-whites tend to live in poor neighborhoods in which they have a lot of contact with people involved in criminal activity (Walker, Spohn, & Delone, 2012).…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Cause and Effects of Gang Violence in Saint Louis, Missouri Up until the last two decades, Saint Louis, Missouri has been a rather safe and quiet city. But in 2015, the city experienced more homicides than any year in the past two decades and landed itself among the most dangerous cities in America (Murphy “2015 Was St.”). In fact, just this year the city was named the most violent city in America (“St. Louis Named”). A large reason for the violence is gang affiliation. Another cause for their high violence rate is drugs.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On July 2013, one of the once most populated cities in United States had declared bankruptcy of $18 billion debt (Davey & Walsh, 2013, p. A1). As a result, there were less jobs available and many people had moved away to find a better life. In the article, Most Dangerous Neighborhoods: Detroit Home To 3 Most Violent Areas In America by Kate Abbey-Lambertz (2013), Detroit, Michigan was once most beautiful city is now abandoned. This essay will analyze how the city of Detroit, Michigan became one of the most dangerous city in United States to live in by looking at the theory of broken windows, as well as evaluating target hardening in hopes to find a solution to criminal activity. The theory of broken windows examines how abandonment encourages…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Auto Thefts

    • 2331 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Studies indicate poverty, community structure, instability of the neighborhood, surrounding crime, population density, mixed land use, cohesion and trust all affect crime probability. The presence of police or guardians only affects crime when there is a high concentration of motivated offenders. It is apparent from the research the issues of crime, particularly auto theft, are motivated by opportunity and community structure. Police, through education, may influence opportunity but additional resources and organizations are necessary to affect community structure. We cannot ignore, despite the challenges and limited affect, efforts by police to reduce auto theft.…

    • 2331 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Broken Windows Theory, first introduced in 1982, asserts that disorder and crime are connected and that disorder can negatively impact society, leading to a high incidence rate of crimes, both misdemeanors and felonies. Through order-maintenance policing, disorder can be controlled, creating a safe and orderly atmosphere, instilling trust between law enforcement and civilians, and the crime rate can be maintained at a low rate. While there is evidence that correlation between Broken Windows policing and crime may be more coincidental, it has been asserted that law enforcement feel that the theory presented by Wilson and Kelling is workable and precisely describes the preferred method of urban jurisdiction maintenance. According…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays