Broken Window Policy Case Study

Improved Essays
Some very interesting topics that I have learned in this module are the different approaches and strategies that police use to implement their way of law enforcement. With community oriented policing a philosophy that has become much more mainstream in law enforcement agencies within the past 30-40 years or so, we see how departments began to change closer to how agencies behave today as compared to the professional crime fighters (Gardiner, 2017). I’ve observed how police agencies have used both problem oriented policing and especially Broken Windows Policies interchangeably in different cities and even in different parts of the city.

Broken window policy was enforced heavily in the train stations of the city I grew up in. I recall vaguely in my childhood in the early 2000’s in San Francisco of the metro train cars often being covered with marker graffiti that would not be taken off until months later. Tunnels to the train station were often littered with trash, smell like urine and feces, and panhandlers aggressively approaching people for money. I also remember that it was easier to evade fares than was in the past eight years (many people today however still evade fares, as prices went from $0.50 fares $2.25 for adult tickets). When the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency decided to become “tough on crime,” they began removing graffiti off trains frequently, employing metro police officers to enforce and prevent
…show more content…
We would tell other friends where police were “raiding,” so we knew what stop to get off to be safe. One of my friends who got caught was fined almost $100 (ironically he said the same exact day that he would never get caught). This also created distrust to the police, as many people disliked how police were aggressively and frequently checking people for fares. I saw when police goes “hard on crime,” police legitimacy is often something that is

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Later, Kelling and Coles (1996) further developed the broken windows model by placing it in a broader legal context. They argued that the retreat from order maintenance policing to concentrate on serious crimes was a mistake (Kelling & Coles, 1996). Failure to address order maintenance by the police led to the increase in the level of incivilities. Increased incivilities became the signal for more serious crimes and further deterioration of the neighborhoods. Kelling and Coles (1996) linked broken windows to both community- and problem- oriented policing strategies.…

    • 254 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Response Memo

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Response Memo, Week Three Charlotte Freitag In their policy-shifting report “Broken Windows: The Police and Neighborhood Safety”, Wilson and Kelling (1982) make a case for why they believe proactive policing would help lower crime rates nationally and promote feelings of comfort across communities. They argue that the widespread usage of foot patrolling officers, as opposed to officers patrolling in vehicles, would promote positive civilian interactions and would deter crime, as the physical presence of police officers would dissuade potential criminals from acting out in public spaces (Wilson and Kelling 1982). Their assertions are based on research the Police Foundation conducted in Newark, New Jersey, where they observed how the presence of foot patrol officers shaped the community and its crime rate (Wilson and Kelling 1982). After the experiment ran its course, they concluded that while the actual crime rate was unchanged, residents perceived the neighborhood as safer than it had been before the foot patrol officers began circulating the area…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evidence Based Policing

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages

    One important study that was completed on law enforcement practices was the Kansas City Experiment. This experiment was the first large-scale scientific study of law enforcement practices, it was focused on the practice of preventive patrol, and it was sponsored by the Police Foundation (Schmalleger, 2015). In this experiment, areas of Kansas City were separated into three parts. The first part consisted of no change in patrol, the second area doubled the patrol available, and the third part tried a completely different approach to patrolling, which consisted of no patrolling at all (Schmalleger, 2015). The results of this experiment were unexpected.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In chapter four his book The Tipping Point, Malcolm Gladwell talks about the crime epidemic in New York City in the 1980’s, and more so what happened to turn the epidemic around. With compelling and intricate arguments, he detailed how something called the Power of Context and the Broken Windows Theory managed to turn the New York subways, and eventually the city as a whole around from alarming high amounts of crime to the widespread belief that shooting someone on the subway was a radial notion. This discussion starts out with the brief story of Bernard Goetz shooting four black youths on a subway train in 1984, this story is the basis of the discussion of how that event came to be, and how similar events were prevented in the future. The…

    • 2113 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Broken windows theory is a belief that the environment has an effect to crime and the anti-social behavior of the neighborhood. If the environment is vandalized or is run down that alone would cause the area to be on that is high in crime and with anti-social behavior. The Broken windows theory has been subject to a lot of scrutiny from the public, many point out that they target poor and minority filled communities. The theory itself states that if an environment is broken down or vandalized there would be a higher rate of crime in that area. This would mean that poor and minority areas would be targeted more by police and impacted more than a neighborhood that is economically better and has a lower percentage of minorities living tin the area.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While the outcome of the application of the broken windows theory is debatable, it has been credited by some (for example, Skogan, 1990; Kelling and Coles, 1996) with remarkable reductions in crime in New York City. When New York City’s police commissioner was William Bratton and the mayor was Rudolph Giuliani, the police in NYC practiced such relentless social control that they helped to change community norms (Delisi, 2003). Skogan (1990) points out that zero-tolerance policies related to social disorder, that were implemented in NYC, resulted in a dramatically safer and cleaner city. Wilson, himself, said in an interview that, “A lot of police agencies have responded to this idea of the broken window. Probably the most famous was the U.S.…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This study examined the impact of applying the “broken windows” thesis (Wilson & Kelling, 1982) to a hot spots policing intervention in three cities in the San Bernardino Valley area of California (Redlands, Ontario, and Colton). Broken windows theory suggests that eliminating visual signs of social disorder and neglect will increase residents’ feelings of safety and empowerment to exercise informal social controls, which ideally will help control and reduce disorderly and criminal behavior. Based on the theory, police can play an important role in helping address these signs of disorder. Participating officers were instructed not to ignore any instances of physical or social disorder in target areas, but they had broad discretion in deciding…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a result, there have been an overwhelming amount of individuals in New York City who have been arrested for minor offenses. As previously stated, most of these individuals cannot afford to make bail in time, so they await their trial in jail. Although the intention is to better the neighborhoods, this strategy of policing has had more negative impact than positive. According to the Communities United for Police Reform organization, the use of broken windows policing (which can be defined as aggressive enforcement of minor non-violent offenses by certain individuals believed to reflect disorder) “has perpetuated the abusive and discriminatory treatment of entire communities” (Communities United for Police Reform, 2012) This is why it is important that the City re-evaluates previous policing strategies and their effects, going…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Broken Windows Method

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The theory has instead resulted in what critics say is aggressive over-policing of minority communities” (PBS) Broken windows policing has raised many important civil rights issues, not just those of racism. To begin with, as FRONTLINE observes, most of this type of policing focuses on minority communities, as these tend to house lower income families and be in a greater state of disrepair than affluent white communities. Some people fear these are examples of racial discrimination, not examples of police work, and this fear may be justified. WNYC spoke with teenagers from different neighbourhoods and found that in a high crime area, some teens as young as 14 had been stopped by police as many as seven times.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Crime In Philadelphia

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However, a feature that the majority of people would be knowledgeable about is that crimes is too prevalence in our society. Law and Disorder in Philadelphia represented the prevalence of crimes in America, but the essential social problems in regard to Philadelphia is its high crime rates. The subculture of Philadelphia’s code #1 perceived to make it more problematic to bring justice and peace to its community. Aside the from much needed aid from the government for restoring Philadelphia into a robust state, the cooperation and trust between the police and civilians need to be established for advancement to transpire in reality. Although there may be countless and difficult decisions to be made, it is essential that the government genuinely care about its people and the people could entrust their life amongst other people (e.g. government members, police officers, neighbors,…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Provide brief explanations of the major advantages and disadvantages of each of the three policing eras identified. In this module, we have discussed a few eras of policing: The political era, reform era, and the community era. Throughout Canadian history each of them have their place, and pro’s and con’s to each.…

    • 2067 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police crime Control Strategies Student Ed. Delmar Cengage Learning Retrieved from Teacher, Law (November 2013). Advantages and Disadvantages of Community PolicingRetrieved from https://www.lawteacher.net/free-law-essays/criminology/advantages-and-disadvantages-of-community-policing.php?cref= Retrieved from Diamond, D & Weiss, D (2009) Community Policing: Looking to Tomorrowhttps://ric-zai-inc.com/Publications/cops-w0520-pub.pdf What Works in Community Policing Lawrence, S & McCathy, B (2013…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Issues In Policing

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Police officers are faced with many challenges when it comes to enforcing the laws and the way they choose to enforce the laws. The problems that police officers face can range from various different levels. Some are not as serious as others but they all play a role involving the issues in policing. However, the problems…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Police Subculture Essay

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The accepted definition of police subculture is described as a particular set of beliefs, attitudes, and behaviors displayed by those who work in the field of law enforcement. Such values are typically shaped by the experiences that police officers underwent along with many other factors, such as the partners that they worked with, their leaders, and the criminals that they faced. Although, since most of the time that law enforcement officers spend is involved in trying to control crime, it has made the police become wary of the public and has caused them to develop an “us versus them” mindset (Herbert). There is also the “blue curtain” or the “blue wall of silence,” which is something of a code of silence among the police and it only serves…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Walker (2012) argues that community policing and problem-oriented policing have failed and policy continues to erode. With this in mind, multiple authors believe there is a large need for police policy reform (Braga, 2008; Decker & Rosenfeld, 2004). Since my research is inquiring about the effectiveness of policy, I looked for a current literary reference that is researching a similar topic. Chanin (2014) is researching the efficiency of Section 14141 of the Violent Crime Act of 1994. Chanin (2014) finds that the reform did minimize police brutality while the institutions were under high observation from the Department Of Justice.…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays