Without a doubt, Boyd’s theories are, and will remain, relevant to the U.S. warfare doctrine. Even as we transition in the type of warfare we will face, his theories are still aiding us in our fight against the entire scope of adversaries. I could not agree more that our newest generation of Marines want the “why”. Where we see the problem arise is that the older generation of Marines see the “why” as contradicting our core value of discipline….instance obedience. When I was a Battery Commander, I always gave the why to my NCOs and I wholeheartedly believe it improved the command. I like how you highlight the planning trap of re-doing your work over and over. You go to any staff, and you can witness this firsthand.
