Bouvia V. Superior Court: Quality Of Life Matters

Improved Essays
Ethics are very important in a workplace. According to the Ethics pdf file on google classroom, ethics are the application of moral principles, standards of behavior, or set of values regarding proper conduct in the workplace as individuals in a group setting. Good ethics in a workplace depends on how trustworthy, respectful, responsible, fairness, and caring you are. There are many ways to show or perform bad ethics. Examples of bad ethics are illegal practices, stealing, ignoring procedures, falsifying information, and lying. There are many court cases that involve poor ethics. One example of a(n) court case dealing with ethics are Bouvia v. Superior Court: Quality of Life Matters. A couple other examples include Blum v. Blum and _______________. …show more content…
The court issued an order that allowed the hospital to force feed her by inserting a nasogastric tube. According to medscape.com a nasogastric is a medical process involving the insertion of a plastic tube through the nose, past the throat, and down into the stomach. The first unethical practice that i notices in this case was that the hospital is going against the patient's wishes and follows their own procedure. Journalofethics.ama states that her caregivers believed that the state's interests in preserving life compelled such an action.Ms Bouvia sued the hospital and its staff so that she could have the nasogastric tube removed and to stop all medical measures to which she did not consent. According to Journalofethics.ama the court said that to rule otherwise would be aiding and abetting suicide. The appellate court acknowledged that a competent adult has the right to exercise of control over his or her own body. Physicians may establish the medical diagnoses and prognoses of patients, but the competent patient is entitled to make the ultimate decision about what care will be rendered, with the "patients interests and desires…the key ingredients of the decision-making …show more content…
The court noted that Ms Bouvia was mentally competent, understood the risks involved in refusing nasogastric tube feeding, and, hence, any objections to her refusal of the feeding could not be based on those grounds.The hospital staff argued that the interests of the state should prevail over the rights of the patient to refuse treatment. Traditionally, viable state interests include: preserving life, preventing suicide, protecting innocent third parties, and maintaining the ethical standards of the medical profession. The court decided that these interests, although valid, were insufficient to overcome Ms Bouvia's right to refuse medical treatment. The appellate court concluded that the trial court had erred in deciding that, just because Ms Bouvia could live an additional 15 to 20 years with sufficient feeding, the state's interest in preserving her life for that period prevailed over her individual right to autonomy. The appellate court emphasized that the trial court's focus on the potential additional years of life available to Ms Bouvia without considering

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Director, Missouri Department Of Health 1990,” Encyclopedia (2001) states the case along with Majority and the Dissenting opinion. This article states my case, which is of course part of the government. Justice William J. Brennan, Jr. wrote “Dying is personal… For many, the thought of an ignoble end [not noble] steeped in decay, is abhorrent [horrible]..., no state interests could outweigh the rights of an individual in Nancy Cruzan’s position. Whatever a state’s possible interest in mandating [requiring] life-support treatment under other circumstances, there is no good to be obtained here by Missouri’s insistence that Nancy Cruzan remain on life-support systems if it is indeed her wish not to do…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kansas Vs Crane Case Study

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Content of Litigation Plaintiff: Argued the New York ban violates the 14th amendment’s equal protection clause by allowing ill adults to end their own lives. Also brought up the point that there was no direct distinguished difference between the two ways. Defendant: Defended the ban stating that it prolonged the lifespan of the patients and it was valid as it had important public interest that satisfied the constitutional requirements. III.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Perin V Hayne Case Study

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Perin v. Hayne This is a case that involved the plantiff named Irene Perin, and the defendant who was named Robert Hayne. Robert Hayne who is the defendant was accused by Irene Perin of malpractice. November, 1968, Irene Perin had an anterior approach cervical fusion procedure done. This is a surgery that removes a herniated or degenerative disc in the neck.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cruzan v. MO Dept. of Health People are born with natural rights including life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, which the Constitution protects. Nancy Cruzan lost her ability to express and revel in her natural rights when a tragic car accident left her severely debilitated and in a ‘persistent vegetative state.’ Nancy Cruzan’s parents requested that their daughter be removed from a machine distributing artificial nutrition and hydration that kept her alive. Nancy’s parents strongly believed that pursuing a ‘plan of medical treatment that allows nature to take its course and permits [her] to die with dignity’ would be the most just decision for her (Cruzan v. Mo Dept of Health (Brennan, J., dissenting)). However, the majority of Justices…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    MGM365-1604A-02 Instructor: Jennifer Hacker Unit 1- The Legal Environment Amanda Kranning October 5, 2016 Ethics can take on many meanings depending on whom you speak with. However, when it comes to business ethics most would agree on a few standpoints. Such principles would consist of promoting values such as trust, good behavior, fairness, and/or kindness.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Case name: PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF SOUTHEASTERN PENNSYLVANIA, ET AL v. ROBERT P. CASEY, ET AL. Court: Supreme Court of the United States Year of Decision: 1992 Facts: This was a United States Supreme Court case in which the statutory provisions of Pennsylvania regarding abortion was challenged. It required that a married woman seeking an abortion must inform and get consent from her spouse, a 24 hour waiting period, and required consent from at least one parent of a minor seeking an abortion. The parties of this case are Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania, ET AL v. Robert P. Casey, ET AL.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mary Mallon Case Study

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It is difficult to decide where the rights of one citizen stop, and the rights of all other citizens begin. In the case of Mary Mallon, health care officials placed the greater good of the population above the rights of an individual, for the right reasons. However, officials at the New York City Health Department went about it in the wrong way. I do not think Mary should have been kept in isolation for the rest of her life. However, I do believe she was given a fair chance at a normal life when she was told to stop cooking.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethics are the general standards of right and wrong that guide behavior in society. Accepted actions can be judged by determining the extent to which they promote good and minimize harm. Having a code of Ethics is so important it provides people with a good understanding of ethical issues they might have to deal with in their workplace. For Dental Hygienists it helps out a lot. It helps to realize to always be morally…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are multiple reasons I have found through experience and research of why I want to be a Diagnostic Medical Sonographer. The first time I experienced sonography was ten years ago when I received a prenatal ultrasound; this is the very first time I was blessed to see my baby. I was immediately fascinated by the technology and how I was able to see so much. I even spotted the fact that my baby was a boy and asked my sonographer, she confirmed that yes indeed he was. I want to be a part of using that ever progressing technology for the benefit of others, not only for prenatal but for all the ways it applies to imaging and procedures of the human body.…

    • 758 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This paper examines Case 7 in our text “Is Birth Control Bad for One’s Health?”. This is quite an old case (1970), but nonetheless applicable in several ways to ethical and moral issues we face in today’s society. We will examine the original case and some of the applications to similar situations today. We also recognize that in today’s society, legal charges would likely be brought against the physician who acted in a similar manner as Dr. Browne.…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Medical Ethical Paper. Physician Assisted Suicide. For me as a future nurse, it is very important to care for and maintain the health of people. It is my responsibility to do it well, and to protect the highest values that are the life, health, and rights of the people in my care.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Patient Deontology Case

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages

    1. What are the primary ethical issues to consider in this case? (1pt.) The primary ethical issues to consider in this case are to keep the patient alive or to remove them from life-support. This is a more difficult case, then it sounds as the health care professionals have to choose between what the patient, who may have brain damage says, which is no, I want to be on life support.…

    • 1693 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If doctors are enabled the decision to terminate a life on behalf of a unconscious patient, they would be then granted a power over society that not only breaches the Hippocratic Oath, but also empowers them to “play God”. This responsibility could then reflect upon society, altering their views and their trust within doctors and medical professionals as they could then be seen as “providers of death” (Cosic, 2003. 25) In addition to this, a doctor’s decision to terminate a life may not rely on the condition and best interests of the patient, but instead of amount of hospital beds and facilities that are…

    • 2101 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is important because each aspect of business has its own standards and principles that are related to ethical behavior. By definition, ethics are rules or standards that decide the decisions made on a daily basis. Relative to business, business ethics are aimed to determine the core justification by which a company will be ran (“Business Ethics and Social Responsibilities”). Past…

    • 1479 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    External Ethical Issues

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ethics can be described as an acceptable code of conduct or behaviour someone exhibits or is expected to display in a society. That behaviour is dictated by various scenarios or situations that are different in nature. For example in a company there are various ethical issues that dictate how the company runs. These ethical issues can be internal or external in nature. Internal ethical issues mainly involve the shareholders of a company, employees and the management.…

    • 940 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays