Botstein's Analysis

Improved Essays
Walking through the halls of high school I notice the behavior of some of the students. People mature differently, some may need more time while others will not. Few have the capability of graduating and leaving high school early and beginning life in what Leon Botstein, the president of Bard College, calls "the real world" (154). A high school student will graduate at age 18 after going through elementary, middle, and high school for four years, this system gives students a chance to attain knowledge in several subjects, find their interests, and to mature.
As one may think the system in how high school is ran is efficient, Botstein feels it has outgrown itself. Botstein writes, "young people mature substantially earlier" (154). Botstein's point is valid, supporting it by saying, "the age of first menstruation has dropped at least two years since the beginning of the century" (154). His
…show more content…
Botstein believes "young people" are maturing earlier than before. He feels students are equipped to enter the adult life sooner than when high school was first created. Although, Botstein does not address the student's mental, social, and emotional maturity. Todd Gitlin, author and university professor, writes that liberal art educators need to say, "We don't want to add to your information glut, we want to offer some ground from which to perceive the rest of what you will see" (157). Gitlin believes liberal art teachers need to prepare students to be able to adapt to enter the world and learn how hey are "not that different from the common run of humanity" (157). This will prepare students for a career after high school with age 18 still he graduation age. He believes that high school anticipate what is to come which shows that graduating at 18 is still effective. Early graduation is not beneficial because graduating at a young age limits students' opportunities to learn the liberal arts subjects Gitlin

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    High school is a staple of American culture. Popular culture is littered with high school imagery: cheerleaders at the homecoming game, senior prom, and finally, graduation. It is a major time of growth for adolescents and serves as a stepping stone into the adult world, giving students the skills and experiences needed to be successful later in life. However our perception of high school and the ‘high school experience’ is rapidly changing as alternatives to traditional schooling appear. An excellent example of this is an emerging program commonly referred to as ‘early college high school’, a duel enrollment program that allows high school students to receive an associate’s degree while earning their high school diploma.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In Laurence Steinberg article, “What’s Holding Back American Teenagers?” Steinberg talks about the importance of education and how there is a big problem we all aren’t seeing. We think the problem is making school more affordable which is an issue but it’s not the problem. Throughout time, many kids have improved in elementary and middle school by challenging themselves but when they get to high school it goes downhill. Adults think that the problem in the education system is providing affordable education to their kids, so the government gives them charter and public schools.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Oliver Clarke Should Students be able to Shape the TDSB Curriculum September 28th, 2015 Highschool, a place teenagers to develop important skills that they need for their journey into adulthood, whether it be grasping life 's basic fundamentals, establishing a connection to the laws of our society, and most of all, the skills for their future career, whether it 's something as simple as a librarian or as complicated as a brain surgeon, highschool is where it all begins, or at least where it should be begin. Giving students the power over their own curriculum is a critical step forwards in creating a highschool experience that is not only considerably more useful in helping students leave highschool with a career goal in mind,…

    • 1397 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First, Let Teenagers Have a Fair Shot at Adolescence Across the hypercritical and interconnected global society that exists today, a multitude of notions and opinions constantly stream from every source imaginable; however, Leon Botstein’s analysis of education in America stands out among the most profound. Bluntly writing in a piece entitled Let Teenagers Try Adulthood, Botstein proposes, “the American high school is obsolete and should be abolished” (153). This provocative nature of Botstein’s writing leads to polarized views of the education system that could ultimately result in alienation of individuals or groups with more moderate views. That is not to say Botstein lacks valid points.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    American High schools as presented by Leon Botstein in “Let Teenagers Try Adulthood” are “obsolete and need to be abolished”, while this is one way to look at how to fix high school, it is not the only solution. There are some major concerns with high school, however abolishing them is unnecessary and an overreaction. Instead of using Botstein’s extreme changes to reinvent the helpfulness high schools are capable of, a few small changes that take time would be more beneficial to bring forth the full potential of high school and therefor the students that will attend them. A few changes that could be made include rethinking the attitudes of those associated with high schools, the lack of individualize teachings, and a reappraisal of the effect…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As the juniors get ready to take the dreadful SAT and the seniors fall into a dark hole of where to apply to college, one question comes into mind: Am I “smart” enough to get accepted into a prestigious university? Nowadays, a syndrome of ‘overachievism’ fills the halls of High Schools as students overload their schedules with numerous rigorous classes and get hyperly involved in extracurricular activities. In the Overachievers: the secret life of driven kids by Alexandra Robbins, the overachieving Yale graduate goes back to her high school a decade later only to discover that the mindset of students is transforming into a obsession with grades and number of AP classes, not the joy of learning and early adulthood. Not to mention the stressful…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wake up!! The dream of a publicly funded, curiosity sparking, creative, learning experience is dying. Replaced by a system bent on making money, and foisting students off onto corporations as employees. The process starts in Middle School, gets more defined in High School before coming to a crescendo in college.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his article, “I Go to a Competitive High School in Suburbia,” Virginia student Ethan Brown outlines the sources of his stress of finding a balance between success and a social life. His life is full of other stressors like the expectations of teachers and parents to excel academically through college and have a successful career. Brown also shares his complaints about the conflicting expectations of him to be a hard working, college-prepared young adult, as well as a fun and social teenager. The major theme of his piece is the stress of finding a balance between the two, but he fails to provide any solution to manage this stress other than asking for a lighter workload. Brown dictates how a family of successful graduates and his upbringing…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most people would agree that there is a need for educational improvements in America, particularly at the high school level. Both “Let Teenagers Try Adulthood” by Leon Botstein and “A Model for High Schools” by David Broder acknowledge weaknesses in the American high schools today. Although both authors propose valid improvements, Botstein has the better proposal for the two. Botstein claims high schools are obsolete and should be abolished because they are unorthodox.…

    • 355 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In 2002 The United States Legislature passed the No Child Left Behind Act. The negative connotations of this act has pervaded our failing school system now for fourteen years. Students, parents, and teachers alike have all grown a resentment for the idea that, despite the effort, a student has the opportunity to fail, parents have the opportunity to bear witness to that failure, and teachers hold the considerable weight of believing it is due to their inadequacy. Individuals who possess potential for something better are squandered and placed in the general education system that any academically unprepared adolescent can comprehend. The process of moving every child along through the twelve years that they are forced to endure the school…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    High School High School: a place where students come to learn and better themselves in a safe and caring environment, which will prepare them for their bright futures. Students walk through the doors in the morning sleep deprived from the hours of homework the night before, but these hours of homework are only to help the students. It helps with unlocking the true power of a student’s brain. There have been multiple studies that prove people learn better when their brains are not working. Today I am going to take you on a tour of the high school so you can see how it helps prepare these students for the rest of their life.…

    • 653 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Morgan Boice Mrs. Miller English 12 23 March 2016 Life after High school Fewer than half of high school students across the country feel like they are ready for college and careers, even though these remain top goals for students. Results from a survey given by College and Career Readiness of 165,000 high school students conducted by YouthTruth, Found that 45 percent of students feel positive about their college and career readiness. And an overwhelming number of students, 87 percent, want to eventually earn a college degree and land a career. High school graduates need to know how to fill out college applications, and job applications if they are wanting to move on to higher things in life after school.…

    • 799 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Meaning of High School “Particular individuals who might never consider dropping out if they were in a different high school might decide to drop out if they attended a school where many boys and girls did so.” -James S. Coleman. This quote illuminates an unfortunate truth. Imagine a very smart student in school. This female student is in 11th grade and performs well in and out of the class room.…

    • 1603 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural Movement

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Cultural Movement in an American High School Graduation In America the high school graduate rates have increased due to the is Ones family heritage reflects a person’s background. Throughout the world, many cultures have traditions that differ from each other. In America, teenagers are required to attend high school, ninth through twelfth grade. Once the completion of twelfth grade, the graduating students are celebrated during a ceremony to be recognized.…

    • 1020 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With harsh statistic like “one-third of college freshmen don’t return for a second year. Kids take about six years to complete a degree, and only 9 percent of students from low-income backgrounds will have a degree by the time they turn 24”(Falik), she explains how this could be a systematic flaw. Too many high school graduates go straight to college without knowing what they want as a future career or even if college is indeed for…

    • 1256 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays