Borders Canadian Identity Analysis

Improved Essays
Borders — whether internal or external, social or economic, geopolitical or psychological — have assumed a most significant role in developing Canada's sense of nation. Borders, starting with those in common with the United States, in addition to the artificial internal regional borders, frame Canadian identity. Identity, however, is a notion both revealed and invented. The Canadian identity is composite and multifaceted to the point of not being easily understood even by those who would try to create or define it.

A pan-Canadian identity has very often been countered by the panoply of attachments existing in the country: allegiances to regions, to ethnic groups, to religion, to outside interests. Although it is certainly not a gathering of
…show more content…
As a result, these contradictory energies have created a country that is in itself a paradox, obsessed with the definition of a "Canadian identity," which has become an elusive notion.

The metaphor of the border, however, has become synonymous with Canada's geopolitical predicament. Borders partake in the construction of the imaginary of the nation. The border is in fact also the symbol of the exclusionary practice inherent in the discourse of the nation. Border and borderlands, nonetheless, are not static, inert entities but organic ones; they change over time and space and become different and often unfamiliar kinds of places.

In the present discussion of the novel Obasan by the Japanese Canadian author Joy Kogawa, I look at the relationship between the developing of identity and the metamorphosis of space and place over time, with a particular emphasis on the representation of the border. I shall look at ways in which identity and place, mutually dependent notions, are formed by borders and borderlands. I shall also draw attention to the liminal sites of merging of interiorities and exteriorities, to the moments in which outside and inside face each other, when everything is suspended in a state of redefinition. In such a process, representations of subjectivity, territoriality and belonging are discordant to the official imaginary
…show more content…
Race makes the "exclusionary discourse of the nation possible, solidifying and edifying the borders of the nation-state through the delineation between who is 'at home' and who comes from elsewhere. This elsewhere is defined and coveted by the white supremacy either covertly in the name of such pluralist liberal discourse as multiculturalism or overtly in the blatantly racist discourse that form the vocabulary of nationalism" (Manning 2003: 72). Borders are also sites of separation that strictly regulate the relations between self and other, citizen and non-citizen, thus stipulating "the manner in which otherness is created and reproduced" (Manning

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    He argues that there is no singular national identity and that citizenship is the unifying force of society. Although both authors raise practical arguments,…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Standoff At Oka Analysis

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages

    A nation 's identity not only represents the physical boundaries of the country but also the citizens living within the boundaries. Hesford and Brueggemann explore how the identity of a nation can be portrayed in memorials within "National Gazes: Witnessing Nations", whereas Adam J. Green focuses on investigating the complexities of identity within Canada and the United States through editorial cartoons in his essay "Mapping North America". In Ryan Edwardson 's essay "The Many Lives of Captain Canuck", he instead focuses solely on the struggle for a presentation of Canada that does not depend on American support. I will incorporate all three of these previously stated works into my essay as well as the photograph "Standoff at Oka" as I discuss…

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Canada has become a nation of a few different cultures, thanks to different events that have occurred throughout history that has helped from British and French nations. Canada was first discovered in 1534 by a French mariner who whom was Jacques Cartier (Quartier). Born on the 31st of December 1491 till the 1st of September 1557. After the Duchy of Brittany was formally united Cartier was introduced to King Francis 1 by Jean Le Veneur. He set sail for a mission by the commission to hopefully discover a western passage for wealthy markets in Asia.…

    • 349 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pierre Trudeau 's attempts to create a sort of "National Identity" during his first term, from 1968 to 1972, has resulted in much debate and controversy. Each of these works looks at Pierre Trudeau from a different historiographical viewpoint. The reason for this is because Trudeau, and his "nationalist" policies, affected every aspect of Canadian citizens’ lives. This was due to the fact that Trudeau was essentially trying, in creating these policies, to answer the question that the Canadian intellectuals were struggling since World War II 's conclusion. This question was: "If [Canadians] are not British [due to the rapid decline of the British Empire] and not American [due to Canadians ' long held distrust of American power and influence]…

    • 1174 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Throughout the past decades and presently, Quebecers have been known for their ongoing loyalty and strong devotion to their nation including their dying culture. Quebec’s advocacy of political independence from Canada, i.e. nationalism, has been significantly influential in shaping Canadian politics in the past and present. Nationalism has not only heavily influenced culture and politics in Quebec but more importantly has influenced politics in the Canadian nation as a whole. It is safe to say that Nationalism has led to various changes in the constitution, some of which are beneficial and some causing controversial debate. With Quebec putting a great effort and many its resources in it’s attempt to protect the French language, this ultimately…

    • 1554 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, as the French Canadians became proud of their accomplishments, their resentment towards English Canada grew, further impacting French-English relations. They viewed the lack of French-Canadian representation in the federal government as a personal offense. In addition, they were forced to speak English in their work place and in stores. And so, once again, French-Canadians believe that the only way for this injustice to stop is for Quebec to become its own independent nation.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Themes In Bone And Bread

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Bone and Bread Themes and How They Relate to Canadian Identity Thesis; themes, such as isolation, survival, loss of a loved one, loneliness, and emotional instability are all connected to what Canadian identity is. Through the loss of parents and close family, these two sisters, Beena and Sadhana, have to navigate life while dealing with the loss of their loved ones. Beena becomes pregnant, having to be a single mom, as the biological father leaves her; this is when she begins to get reclusive. Her sister had no means to deal with the emotional trauma, so she became anorexic. Keeping secrets and always pushing people away, Sadhana never wanted help from her sister or uncle, who became their caretaker until they were old enough to handle themselves.…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Social and political marginalization, as well as political turmoil most accurately, construe Canada’s inherent history of…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We live in a world full of borders. Every time we glance left or right, we notice that we are surrounded by borders whether they are the physical, mental or cultural. The physical borders are geographic borders that determine the territory we live in or the territory in which we can walk about as a citizen, these borders separate one place from another. The mental borders are limited to our imagination and our thought process, our mind dictates us what is right and wrong, it separates one thing from another. The cultural borders are the borders that separate one culture form another.…

    • 1396 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Identity can stem from many places for example; people may pull their identity from achievements and experiences, many draw identity from their hometowns and places they’ve traveled. Place can be central to a person’s identity, while physical landscape and all the resources that it holds can shape ideas of value. Canada is known since written history, and the history before that as a place with unbounded natural beauty, unique to itself. Canada, as a whole, in a physical sense, in an emotional and spiritual sense, draws its identity from this and does its people. Canada’s power is also sourced from its natural resources, from resources like tar sands, oil and water.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The political dispute of identity versus citizenship is one that is persistently debated. In “Borders” by Thomas King, the narrator’s mother is traveling to Salt Lake City and must go through the borders between America and Canada. The protagonist experiences the conflict of man versus society as she feels the need to defend her identity from the guards. Thomas King makes the implicit political claim that identity and citizenship are not one in the same. The story is written from the point of view of the narrator, a twelve-year-old boy.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nevertheless, before discussing how effective the multiculturalism act has been, it’s necessary to discuss parts of Canadian identity, and asses how multiculturalism shapes Canadian society. Canadian identity is ambiguous; often been describes described as an inclusive nation, rather than exclusive nation. Instead of promoting its own interest Canada has been known as a compromising, pace-making, compassionate nation filled with virtue. Canadian identity is closely associated with the promotion of diversity and multiculturalism. Unlike their American neighbors in the South, Canada is said to have embraced distinct cultures and language, without forcing in assimilation.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    From financial expenses to the loss of rich history, it comes to great cost to separate and become an independent country. On the other hand, becoming an independent country can allow its people to have a powerful say in the politics, rather than being alienated when one should rightly be involved in the politics governing one’s province. However, considering both issues, Canada should not separate because it is a country that functions by depending on the advantages and differences each province has to offer. Although Ontario generates 37% of the national GDP and is a substantial part of the North American manufacturing, (“About Ontario”) it wouldn't have been able to reach this favorable economy without the support and the advantages its…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Canada is perhaps the most experienced negotiator when it comes to protecting it 's cultural identity. Over the last 30 years, though the judicious use of international courts, local media content requirement, and tax credits it has managed to halt and reduce the influence of this cultural invasion (Content made by Canadians. n.d. & U.S. magazine spill into Canada. 2014.). This must all be done with an eye towards maintaining a reasonable trade balance. Failure to safeguard ones markets can lead to a steady Americanization of local cultures.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Vertovec implies in his work on “super-diversity,” migrants could not be conveniently grouped into clear-cut “diasporas” because the realities of cultural dynamics are more complex than those envisioned in simplistic models of “multiculturalism,” which wrongly attribute homogeneity and cultural stasis to groups of people from particular parts of the world. Bhabha and Stuart Hall has highlighted the quality of transcendental identity on the whole and the diasporic identity in particular. In his Introduction to the Questions of Cultural Identity, Hall argues that “identities are never unified” but ,“ increasingly fragmented and fractured; never singular but multiply constructed across” therefore they are “constantly in the process of change and transformation”(4). Inquiring into diasporic culture, both Bhabha and Hall move away from the “bipolar model” to “tripolar model” which gives more priority neither to the motherland nor to the residing country, rather accentuates the “middle ground” which Bhabha calls “the third space”…

    • 1132 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays